I’ve waited until today to make my first comments about the murder of the Chair of Arkansas’ Democratic Party. I wanted to make sure that there was no personal connection between the shooter and Bill Gwatney, and apparently there wasn’t one. Instead, there are some initial eerie similarities between the shooter Timothy Dale Johnson, and the man who massacred members of the Unitarian church in Knoxville, Tennessee last month. Both, for example had just lost their jobs, and both were very, very angry about that fact:
Wreaths and flowers lined the sidewalk in front of Arkansas’ Democratic Party headquarters Thursday while police and others tried to explain why a man who lost his job at a Target store drove more than 30 miles and fatally shot the party’s chairman.
Until Wednesday morning, when he wrote profanity-laced graffiti on a store wall, Timothy Dale Johnson had been a good employee in a stockroom, a Target spokeswoman said.
Johnson apparently lived alone and had never married. Under most circumstances he probably would have continued this isolated, but not all together unproductive life. He probably had certain emotional difficulties with people. According to neighbors he kept to himself, yet was considered a model employee at Target. Yet, after losing his job (or leaving it), the first action he decided to take was to murder a prominent liberal and Democrat, much like Jim David Adkisson decided to take his rage and anger at his personal situation out on the “liberal” church in Knoxville. Both chose to use firearms to murder innocent people they did not know personally. It is logical to assume that they both chose their targets to make a statement. Indeed, we know for a fact that Adkisson, the church shooter, wrote a specific hate filled manifesto detailing his reasons for targeting the most prominent “liberal” church in Knoxville for his massacre.
I don’t think it is a coincidence that within a few weeks, another disturbed individual who had lost his job (at least by his own perception — Target is denying they terminated him), chose to shoot someone associated with “liberals” and “Democrats.” The right wing bloggers and talk show hosts can deny their complicity in these “random” actions, and, indeed, legally they are not responsible for the criminal actions of a few “rogue” individuals. However, their writings and commentary, widely disseminated on TV, radio and the internet, has spread a culture where violence against liberals, Democrats, feminists, gays, blacks, immigrants, Muslims and any other out group is frequently expressed as “comedy” or in fantasies of wish fulfillment. They can claim all they like that they cannot be held accountable for the aura of hatred they have engendered in American society, but their protestations ring hollow to me.
People too young to have lived through the Civil Rights era might not remember that much of the same hate speech was prominent among conservative, racist and nativist circles. The result was a wave of violent attacks on prominent liberals and activists, and I am not just referring to the Kennedy brothers and Dr King. A whole host pf people were murdered by those who felt entitled to take the lives of those who threatened their political ideology and belief system. The bombings in Birmingham, church burnings, Medgar Evers assassination and many other acts of violence.
Since the rise of talk radio and Fox News in the 1990’s we have seen the slaughter of hundreds of people at the Murrah Federal building in Oklahoma City by individuals with right wing leanings. We have seen reports of numerous arrests of right wing “terrorists” (though they are never labeled as such in the media or by the Bush administration) who have planned massacres of “illegal immigrants” and other violence. We have experienced another wave of African American church burnings. We have seen numerous murders of gay men and women, where the defendants raise the ludicrous excuse of “gay panic” as a defense for their evil, premeditated killings.
It’s past time for members of the the right wing wurlitzer to apologize for their hate speech and to renounce any further use of the language of extermination with respect to their political, religious and ideological adversaries, as well as their demonization of minorities. I don’t expect them to do so, but it would be the right thing to do, and aren’t they always preaching about how much more moral and decent their movement is compared to us “Leftards’ with our evil gay agendas, our eco-terrorists, our traitorous failure to “support the troops” and a myriad of other imagined sins?
All I know is no prominent liberal spokespersons have made the following statements:
“I tell people don’t kill all the liberals. Leave enough so we can have two on every campus — living fossils — so we will never forget what these people stood for.” — Rush Limbaugh
“I would have no problem with [New York Times editor Bill Keller] being sent to the gas chamber.” — Melanie Morgan
“”[T]he day will come when unpleasant things are going to happen to a bunch of stupid liberals and it’s going to be very amusing to watch.” — Lee Rogers
“And if Al Qaeda comes in here and blows you up, we’re not going to do anything about it. We’re going to say, look, every other place in America is off limits to you, except San Francisco. You want to blow up the Coit Tower? Go ahead.” — Bill O’Reilly
“Howard Dean should be arrested and hung for treason or put in a hole until the end of the Iraq war!”– Michael Reagan
“Some liberals have become even too crazy for Texas to execute, which is a damn shame. They’re always saying — we’re oppressed, we’re oppressed so let’s do it. Let’s oppress them.” — Ann Coulter
“We need somebody to put rat poisoning in Justice Stevens’ creme brulee. … That’s just a joke, for you in the media.” — Ann Coulter
My only regret with Timothy McVeigh is he did not go to the New York Times Building.” — Ann Coulter
“We need to execute people like John Walker in order to physically intimidate liberals, by making them realize that they can be killed too.” — Ann Coulter
And Joe Wilson has no right to complain. And I think people like Tim Russert and the others, who gave this guy such a free ride and all the media, they’re the ones to be shot, not Karl Rove. — Rep. Peter King (R)
Where does George Soros have all his money? Do you know? Do you know where George Soros, the big left-wing loon who’s financing all these smear [web]sites, do you know where his money is? Curaçao. Curaçao. They ought to hang this Soros guy. — Bill O’Reilly
“Has there ever been a more revealing moment this year?” Mr. Rove asked. “Let me just put this in fairly simple terms: Al Jazeera now broadcasts the words of Senator Durbin to the Mideast, certainly putting our troops in greater danger. No more needs to be said about the motives of liberals.” — Karl Rove
Miller is not alone, though some are more sanguine when it comes to evaluating the roster of contenders. Here’s a note I got recently from a friend and former Delta Force member, who has been observing American politics from the trenches: “These bastards like Clark and Kerry and that incipient ass, Dean, and Gephardt and Kucinich and that absolute mental midget Sharpton, race baiter, should all be lined up and shot.” — Kathleeen Parker
Right now, even people sitting on the fence would like George Bush to drop a nuclear weapon on an Arab country. They don’t even care which one it would be. I can guarantee you — I don’t need to go to Mr. Schmuck [pollster John] Zogby and ask him his opinion. I don’t need anyone’s opinion. I’ll give you my opinion, because I got a better stethoscope than those fools. It’s one man’s opinion based upon my own analysis. The most — I tell you right now — the largest percentage of Americans would like to see a nuclear weapon dropped on a major Arab capital. They don’t even care which one. They’d like an indiscriminate use of a nuclear weapon.
In fact, Christianity has been one of the great salvations on planet Earth. It’s what’s necessary in the Middle East. Others have written about it, I think these people need to be forcibly converted to Christianity but I’ll get here a little later, I’ll move up to that. It’s the only thing that can probably turn them into human beings. … Because these primitives can only be treated in one way, and I don’t think smallpox and a blanket is good enough incidentally. Just before — I’m going to give you a little precursor to where I’m going. Smallpox in a blanket, which the U.S. Army gave to the Cherokee Indians on their long march to the West, was nothing compared to what I’d like to see done to these people, just so you understand that I’m not going to be too intellectual about my analysis here in terms of what I would recommend, what Doc Savage recommends as an antidote to this kind of poison coming out of the Middle East from these non-humans. — Michael Savage
Funny, but I have never heard of Michael Moore or Phil Donahue or Keith Olbermann or Al Franken or Nancy Pelosi or Barack Obama or Dennis Kucinich or Howard Dean or (name your favorite liberal here) making public statements recommending the murder of of conservatives, media figures, politicians, or judges. They blame us for 9/11 and Katrina but as Jesus said: And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother’s eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?
That’s a pretty big beam, my conservative friends. Start doing something about it before we see any more innocent people killed.
I could have sworn that yesterday as I was bouncing around different sites while the story was still in the breaking stages that I saw a report somewhere which said Gwatney had some kind of affiliation with Target. But I can’t seem to recall where it was I saw this.
Was it just my imagination? I don’t see anything like that now floating around in any of the current reporting.
.
LITTLE ROCK, Ark. – The man who fatally shot Bill Gwatney, chairman of the state Democratic Party, after he lost his job had a Post-it note at home with the victim’s last name and phone number along with 14 guns, antidepressants and a last will and testament, according to court documents.
The search of Johnson’s home near Searcy, northeast of Little Rock, turned up two sets of keys for vehicles from Gwatney car lots. Johnson also had a pistol and 13 long guns.
Police Lt. Terry Hastings said officers didn’t know what to make of the note and police didn’t disclose the phone number or say whether it was to the party headquarters or a car dealership.
Tentative information about link to Gwatney
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."
This story, which I linked to in my comment to Indianadem’s diary on this subject, gives a lot more info on Johnson’s behavior Wednesday morning.
I think it is very important to note the sequence of events before we go making the (tempting, and all-too-easy) assimilation of this case to that of the Knoxville shooter.
First, early am (apparently), he scrawls the initial graffiti about the hallway’s being too f—ing narrow. (At this point I would say he already is angry at his employers and his anger is causing erratic behavior.)
Second, a store meeting is called at which the managers ask whoever wrote this to speak up. (Nobody did.)
Next, within about an hour, Johnson signs the offending graffiti and adds another one reading “Target is run by dumb jocks and sorority b—–s” and another just reading “sorority b—–s”.
Then comes the termination. You know the rest.
First point: His erratic and angry behavior precedes his losing his job.
Second point: He obviously was angry at Target for some reason — but it’s hard to believe he was angry at them for firing him (if they did). He had already decisively said “F–k this” to the job by signing the graffiti and adding more.
Third point (a minor one, but worth noting): His anger at Target management, at least, did not seem to have any particular anti-liberal thrust. Jocks and sorority girls are not, so far as I’m aware, typically regarded as liberal demographic groups.
In any case, treating this as a second instance of someone’s being angry over his lack of employment and blaming it on liberals doesn’t, at this point, seem to fit the facts.
except, what did he do next?
This comment rather obtusely misses the point.
Or should I say, “Your comment ignores so much of what I wrote that I don’t know how to respond”?
So let me make it clear enough for you to understand.
He was obviously flipping before he “lost” (or threw away) his job. Whatever he was angry about, losing his job wasn’t it.
Clear, now?
Finally, the fact that he has something in common with the Knoxville shooter — which you point out, as if we didn’t know that — doesn’t entail that he has everything (including motive) in common with him.
Thank you.
well, unless he was pissed off over a car rental, it appears that he decided to take out his anger on a Democrat for some reason.
[I]t appears that he decided to take out his anger on a Democrat for some reason.
Exactly. For what reason? We don’t know. Was his anger caused by losing his job (thus, was he angry because he lost his job)? NO. That, again, is the point — why we shouldn’t too quickly assimilate his case to the Knoxville one, as I started out saying.
Was his anger even against Watney qua Democratic Party Chair? I strongly suspect so, but again, we don’t know. (Watney could’ve sold him a bum vehicle.)
By the way, Boo, wittiness and sarcasm are not your forte. Stick to earnestness.
Maybe your problem is that you are reading ‘wittiness and sarcasm’ where none exists.
I’ll grant that.
One thing he didn’t do is run to the Republican Party office and shoot the Chair of the Arkansas Republican Party.
These are some seriously sick people, who strangely enough, feel as entitled as the haughtiest loudmouth wingnut on radio or TV.
Even stranger, their lives are the stereotypes they smear “the other” with. I’m just done with the dumb. The wingnuts LAUGH at them, count their money, and go on their way.
Speaking of wingnuts: As far as the Drug Rushes and O’Liely and the rest of their ilk, THEY ARE COMPLICIT.
Period.
I am not yet ready to classify this in the same category as the Knoxville incident. There is just not enough evidence yet to go that far. But one thing is perfectly clear. The steady drumbeat of hatred, marginalization of those deemed different and the us-vs-them viewpoint which has saturated this country’s psyche by virtue of its emanation from car radios, bookshelves and televised bloviators for the last 25 years has made violence appear to be an acceptable method to deal with transgressions and perceived slights. All you need is an already unbalanced mind, an unfortunate set of circumstances to befall them and you have all the makings of blind and mindless death and destruction. All aimed at those who have been demonized to these people on a daily basis. Hundreds of millions of people are beaten over the head every day by this constant flow of hate, hate, hate.
Why do we act surprised when the unstable among us feel like they can take no more and act out to take down the very type of people they have been told are at fault for their problems?
Hey, as far as these purveyors of hate are concerned……..MISSION ACCOMPLISHED!! One down, many more to go. Whose next? Me? You? Your family?
I know we shouldn’t jump to conclusions, but why would he kill someone with whom he had no connection? He hated his life, hated himself, and kills a stranger to make himself feel better?
LET ME HASTEN TO ADD–no one should have to go through this kind of madness and terrorism. (Sorry to shout, but I want to be absolutely clear about that.)
I am just so sick and tired of these types feeling like they can do anything to anyone, because someone lied to them and told them that everyone else is beneath them, less than human, and deserving of insult, blame, assault and yes, even death.
It is hard to make sense of the motivation for this type of crime. And many of us are trying to assign motive and blame when there is really a dearth of information right now on this particular incident.
As someone who has direct experience trying to deal with someone(my brother) suffering from a mental illness, I can say that questions such as those you pose are a constant when trying to come to terms with what seems to rational people a totally inexplicable act. If I had a nickel for every time someone very well meaning, but totally clueless, asked my why I didn’t just “kick his ass out in the street” or “give him an ultimatum” or tell him that he “just has to get his shit together, or else”, I’d be a very rich man. That is the very nature of mental illness. It often defies every sensibility and rationality you might have or try to apply to it. It tests your humanity and compassion beyond belief.
Now I don’t know if this guy had a mental illness. It appears that he, at minimum, had some severe emotional issues, an inability to deal with it and no support network to help him come to terms with his demons. And yes, he took it out on someone with whom he might have had no connection; who happened to be a high profile Democrat. Was right-wing hate indoctrination part of his make-up? I haven’t heard anything similar to what we saw with the guy in Knoxville. Maybe it will come out that he is similar. But for now we just don’t know.
Why is it that Democrats are the only politicians to get assassinated in America? Sure, there were two half-assed attempts on Ford and one on Ronnie Raygun, but no republican politician has been assassinated since Abe Lincoln (and he’d be a Democrat if here were alive today).
Indeed. There was a coup plotted against FDR, and assassination attempts against both FDR and Truman. Harvey Milk, a Democratic official who was gay was assassinated in San Francisco along with the Democratic Mayor. I’m sure there are others I am forgetting.
given the politics, and supposed rationale behind john wilkes booth’s assassination of lincoln, he’d be considered a reichwinger in today’s political and cultural climate:
nuff said.
Well, there was McKinley.
How about Garfield?
Thanks Booman, for rounding up the quotes. These people are no better than the Nazi’s. The only thing they lack is a Hitler to rouse the crowd, and organized Brownshirts. We will probably get the Brownshirts, but I don’t see any charismatic Nazi orator on the horizon. The only way to kill this stuff is with sunshine. Thanks for getting it into the light.
thank Steve…he wrote it 😉
.
The list of items seized: A personal computer, a bottle of prescription anti-depressants (Effexor XR); a “sticky note” bearing the word “Gwatney'” and a telephone number (LR police said they didn’t know if it was Gwatney’s phone number); a Smith and Wesson gun box; unspecified paperwork; a Browning .22-caliber pistol; a Thompson 50-caliber rifle; a CZ rifle; a Remington model 700 rifle; a Benelli double-barrel shotgun; a CZ rifle; a 12-gauge shotgun; a CZ M-1 carbine; a U.S. M-1 rifle; a Mohawk 600/308 rifle; a CZ 20-gauge shotgun; a Winchester .22-rifle; a Remington .25/06 muzzle loader; a New Englander muzzle loader; two sets of keys with a Gwatney dealership emblem and the last will and testament of Timothy Johnson.
… people who knew him as a quiet loner known mostly for his passion for guns. [NRA? – Oui]
Johnson participated in high-powered rifle competitions held by a Cleburne County gun club.
Ken Buster is the former secretary of the Cleburne County Shooting Club. He said that Tim Johnson attended meetings in 2004 and 2005, and shot handguns, rifles and shotguns at the club’s range in Heber Springs. Buster said that Johnson only competed in high-powered rifle competitions.
Dennis Shea, youth director of the gun club, said Johnson stopped attending club meetings soon after he was unable to stir enthusiasm among other club members in Wild West shooting competitions. In these, shooters don garb cowboy wear and target shoot. Like Buster, he said he couldn’t recall Johnson talking about anything but topics related to gun activities.
Johnson’s voting record in White County. He was a regular voter, casting ballots 13 times since November 2000. He voted Republican more often than not in primary balloting. He voted Republican in 2002 and 2004 primaries and the 2008 presidential primary. He voted in the Democratic primary and Democratic runoff primary in 2006.
The funeral for Bill Gwatney will be at 2 p.m. Monday at Pulaski Heights United Methodist Church.
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."
A Gun nut doesn’t sound like the kind of person who would blame Republicans for his problems in life. Having been a member of a gun club, I can confirm that the vast majority of them are very conservative and very liberal hating.
Has no one considered the possibility that we’re being conditioned through these apparently random acts by ‘lone nuts’ for an assault on Obama?
I have. Frightening. These people could all be mind-controlled assassins for all we know. The media would hardly give us any help were that the case.
for all we know they could robots controlled by the Japanese. C’mon, Lisa. People are crazy and do crazy things all the friggin’ time. Been to the DMV lately? It’s a zoo down there.
C’mon Boo. You know I’m just throwing that out there – there’s no evidence of that. But there WOULD be no evidence of that even if it were true. And yes – it could come from anywhere. But historically – only America seems to have ‘lone nuts.’ In other countries people are wiser to what’s really going on.
Imagine this, if you will.
The CIA has moved to Denver (Source: Wash Post a few years ago). The CIA is backing Hillary Clinton’s bid (obvious from the number of CIA operatives backing her). At the convention, Obama is shot by a sniper (with a patsy duly available and killed instantly, so there can be no investigation) and Hillary graciously steps up to the plate.
Think it can’t happen? I don’t.
I could completely see it. But can you imagine the quasi-revolution that would follow? I’d suggest that their would be an uprising the level of which has not been seen since the Civil War. And I’d suspect the planners of such an operation to understand this and either a) avoid taking such an action to avoid a potential revolution, or b) have contingency planning well in place to quash what I believe would be a civil shit storm like nothing we have ever seen.
On a lighter note, it was nice to see no prosecution for the officers who so nobly shot down the mentally ill guy as he fled from a bridge in New Orleans (when his only apparent purpose to be on the bridge was to escape the hell our lack of government response created by searching for something to eat). America. Love it or leave it.
They’d launch a revolution. Maybe. Or maybe the masses are too lazy. Hard to call at this point.
I think they’ve got plan b) set up and ready to go.
They kinda made that movie already — Manchurian Candidate. And it didn’t work out for the ambitious blonde.
Let’s hope we get so lucky. They replayed that live in 1968 in the Ambassador Hotel, and we all lost something incalcuable.
Every right wing nut job in the country is listening to talk radio and their crazy “bring em on” president. Steven your correct the right is armed to the teeth and they hate everything and anyone who disagrees with their narrow views. Some of the right’s quotes you posted are basically terroristic threats. Thats a crime by the way. I work with gun nuts and believe me they are way right wing. They are working in your government and it shows in our foreign policy.
Your posts on our taser happy police forces are more proof. Law enforcement should be preventing violence not practicing sadism.
If Obama gets elected it may only get worse as the lunatics will feel marginalized aka Timothy McVeigh and the militias of the 90s.
That’s also how the Rwanda holocaust was launched – by hate radio.
Whatever happened to human decency? I can’t BELIEVE what is allowed on the airwaves I supposedly co-own with the rest of you.
Yeah….Its time to cut the tall Democrats.
Those interested in right-wing hate rhetoric & what to do about it should check out Jeffrey Feldman’s new book and/or his blog.