.
WEST BANK PROTEST
(Al Jazeera) – Hundreds of people in the West Bank city of Ramallah protested against the Palestinian Authority’s decision to support a delay to a UN vote on whether to endorse the findings of the report, which was authored by Richard Goldstone, a former South African judge. Protesters gathered waving placards saying the delay “insults the blood of the martyrs and wounds our people”.
“[The decision] was a knife in the backs and in the hearts of all the martyrs,” Jamal al-Jumaa, a protester, said.
Protests were also held in Jerusalem, where pro-Palestinian activists demanded an apology from Abbas.
“If the government had anything to do with the decision we want it to resign,” Muhammad Jadallah, the head of the Coalition for Jerusalem, said.
Thirty-two Palestinian groups in Europe also called on Abbas to immediately step down from office.
In a statement, the groups said “the step to delay the endorsement was not less dangerous than the atrocities committed by the Israeli occupation in Gaza”.
While everyone else is welcoming the hopeful signs from the nuclear negotiations with Iran — and I’m cautiously encouraged too –I’m going back to the less-than-hopeful news from elsewhere in the Middle East. According to the Associated Press, the Palestinian National Authority has agreed to defer its efforts to get the Goldstone Report on war crimes in the Gaza conflict referred out of the UN Human Rights Council to the Security Council or the General Assembly. This seems puzzling: given the findings of the report, and the fact that roughly 1,300 Palestinians were killed in the carnage (along with 13 Israelis), why would they decide to hold back? Simple: because the United States, principled defender of human rights, put a lot of pressure on them. Here’s the Associated Press’s explanation (my emphasis):
- “Senior U.S. and Palestinian officials in Washington and Ramallah, speaking on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the issue, said the Palestinian decision came after heavy U.S. pressure and a warning that going ahead with the resolution would harm the Middle East peace process.”
Many Palestinians have protested against the delay in endorsing the Goldstone report(AFP)
The UN today put off action on a report criticising Israel’s actions during the war in Gaza after Palestinian leaders suddenly dropped their support for a resolution, apparently under heavy US pressure.
The decision marked a surprising reversal in the Palestinian position which, until now, had backed the findings of the report by the South African judge Richard Goldstone.
That vote will now be delayed until the council meets next, in March next year.
Israel had strongly rejected the findings of the Goldstone report as biased, even though it also criticised the actions of Hamas.
The US administration said it had “very serious concerns” about Goldstone’s recommendations, which included a call for the UN security council to investigate and raised the possibility of investigation by the international criminal court and judges from individual countries.
The Palestinians do not have a seat on the 47-member UN Human Rights Council, but Arab and Muslim countries with council seats had been expected to push for the report to be endorsed.
The Palestinian reversal came after “intense diplomacy” by Washington, which told the Palestinians that going ahead with the vote would harm efforts to restart peace talks with the Israelis, according to diplomats quoted by news agencies.
“The Palestinians recognised that this was not the best time to go forward with this,” the official said.
However, Imad Zuhairi, the deputy Palestinian ambassador in Geneva, said the report “remains alive” and would be debated next spring. The delay “is not a victory for Israel”, he added.
It appeared that the Palestinian leadership was reluctant to lose the chance to return to peace negotiations with Israel and unwilling to try other steps to put pressure on Israel such as international legal action.
Robert Blecher, an analyst with the International Crisis Group, said a similar decision had been taken last week when the Palestinians agreed to meet the Israelis in New York despite Israel’s decision not to accept their call for a full halt to settlement construction.
“This is a further indication that the current Palestinian leadership is not considering any options except for negotiation and in that sense the climbdown, like the climbdown in the meeting in New York city, is not unexpected – just the speed with which it was taken,” he said.
Israel launched an intense diplomatic and public relations operation against his report, particularly after efforts this week in Britain to have an arrest warrant issued against Ehud Barak, the Israeli defence minister who oversaw the Gaza war.
Binyamin Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister, said an endorsement of the Goldstone report would “strike a fatal blow against the peace process” and deny Israel’s “right to self-defence”.
Goldstone defended his work against Netanyahu’s criticism, saying: “I think he got wrong what our report is all about. He talked about Israel’s right to self-defence. That is not what the report was about.”
Obama and change: human rights delayed …
Thanks for this diary, Oui. I caught this piece from Mondoweiss. Nobody is pleased.
Obama gave the dirty work to Abbas and now both are soiled
LINK
October 5, 2009
The Palestinian reaction to the Palestinian Authority selling out Gaza on the Goldstone report has been vehement. Now, Arab News reports, Abbas is shocked, shocked over the cashiering of the report:
Jerry Haber has the best post on the debacle, saying that the nullification of the report has given a huge boost to the BDS movement because Palestinians have no other power in a world where international courts and systems routinely overlook the destruction of their rights. Haber:
As for the Obama administration, giant loser here. Paul Woodward says that Obama tried to dodge this one by sticking it to the P.A. And the result has been to demolish the PA as a credible spokesman for Palestinian interests.
A year ago had there been a similar scenario, Abbas would not have been alone in receiving well-deserved expressions of contempt. Bush and Rice would have drawn as much criticism. Whichever “top White House official told Jewish organizational leaders in an off-the-record phone call” that the Goldstone report would get strangled (in a “natural conclusion”) was telling the truth. [This site never bought the Obama administration’s correction of this report the next day; no, we believe in the Israel lobby]
Abbas did the inexcusable dirty work but the Obama administration made him do it.
(And just for the record, I voted for Obama.)
….Phil Weiss
.
(Haaretz) – Nathan Diament, director of public policy for the Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations of America, said in a statement.
“Jerusalem has been at the center of Jewish life and faith for thousands of years. Just days ago, at the close of Yom Kippur, Jews around the world declared, as we have for thousands of years, the hope and prayer ‘Next Year in Jerusalem.’ A majority of Jews, in the U.S. and Israel, continue to oppose relinquishing Jewish sovereignty over our eternal capital. The enemies of our people recognize this, and seek to deny our history. In the face of all this we reaffirm that ‘for the sake of Zion we will not be silent’ and we will not allow history to be denied.”
Israel on Campus Coalition (ICC)
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."
Was it authur Koestler who demonstrated that more people have been killed throughout history in the name of religion than for any other reason?
Overlooking the problem it is as if there is a game of musical chairs being played out.
.
How I’m Losing My Love For Israel
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."
Palestinian U-turn on Gaza report
.
(Haaretz) – The United Nations Security Council is scheduled to meet Wednesday to discuss Libya’s request for an emergency session on a report that accused Israel and the Palestinian group Hamas of committing war crimes during Israel’s offensive in Gaza.
The Palestinian UN Mission issued a press release saying it affirmed full support for the Libyan request.
Libya holds two key positions in the UN which make it easier for the country to initiate a session on the report – it is a member of the Security Council, and one of its representatives is currently serving as the president of the General Assembly. Libya has the authority to convene the UN Security Council to vote on the Goldstone report in the name of the Muslim nations or the Arab League.
If the Security Council session on the Goldstone report ends without a resolution or an American veto, Libya could convene the General Assembly, whose vote cannot be vetoed.
Lieberman’s Foreign Ministry orders staff to keep mum on Goldstone report
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."
.
The Palestinian Shahab agency quoted well-informed US sources as saying that a video was behind the Palestinian Authority’s decision to withdraw support for Goldstone report. The agency said that a meeting was held in Washington in recent days between the representatives of the Palestinian Authority and Israeli delegation on the Gaza report. The sources pointed out that the PA representatives strongly rejected the Israeli request to defer the report and insisted on their position, until the Israeli Colonel Eli Avraham presented a video file displaying a dialogue which took place between Abbas and Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak in the presence of the former Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni.
According to the same source, Abbas appeared in the video as trying to persuade Barak to continue the war on Gaza, while Barak seemed reluctant to the enthusiastic support from Abbas and Livni to continue the war.
The source pointed out that Avraham also introduced to the PA delegation a telephone conversation between the Israeli Chiefs of Staff office director Dov Weisglass and Tayeb Abdel Rahim, secretary general of the Palestinian presidency. Abdel Rahim was quoted as telling Weisglass that “conditions are ripe and ready for the Israeli army to enter Jabalia and Shatea camps”, adding that the downfall of the camps will end the rule of the Islamic Resistance (Hamas) in Gaza Strip.
According to the tape record, Weisglass told Tayeb Abdel Rahim that this will cause the killing of thousands of civilians. Abdul Rahim replied that “they all elected Hamas, they have chosen their own destiny, not us.” So, Israel blackmailed the PA with the video and tape in order to win against the Goldstone report.
Israeli Maariv newspaper had previously quoted the Israeli occupation Chief of Staff Gabi Ashkenazi as saying that the Palestinian Authority represented by its president, went to war with Israel in Gaza. Ashkenazi sent a letter to the Israeli Attorney, in which he revealed that the Abbas maintained unprecedented cooperation with the Israeli occupation army during the Gaza war.
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."