News that Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham is negotiating with the White House on legislation to create a framework for handling terrorism detainees has some civil rights groups alarmed at the prospect of indefinite detention without trial being encoded into US law.
The Washington Post’s Anne Kornblut reported Wednesday that Graham, who sits on the Senate’s Armed Services, Homeland Security and Judiciary committees, “has submitted draft legislation to the White House in an effort to create a broad framework for handling terrorism suspects, mapping out proposals that appeal to the administration and others that do not.”
Since when did we the people decide America should become the next Argentina under the Military Junta or Chile under Pinochet? Or, Iran under Mahmoud Ahmadinejad for that matter? How soon will “terrorism suspects” be expanded to other groups the next time a Republican is installed as President? And don’t tell me the Courts will stop this. I don’t trust the Roberts’ court at all when it comes to protecting the rights and liberties of individuals (as opposed to corporations).
Anyone in the Obama administration who is seriously considering this “negotiation” with Graham should remember that whatever political benefits may flow from it in the Fall (and those are highly doubtful to bear fruit in my view) will be small compared to the long term consequences of summarily constricting and deleting our essential constitutional protections. You would think we learned nothing from the excesses of the Bush administration and the past use of “bipartisanship” by Republicans over the last 14 months as a smokescreen to attack Democrats.
This stinks people. Try the terror suspects in court or release them. No more banana republic excuses for “indefinite detentions” of people who we often purchased from bounty hunters and then often tortured (and sometimes killed) to gain negligible and more often false intelligence.
Burma changed their name to Myanmar. Maybe President Graham should have us to that, too.
They are really playing hardball on this closing of Gitmo thing. Obama wants to keep his promise, they want him to destroy our Justice system to do it.
But Congressional acquiescence is probably needed to close Gitmo.
This is the problem. Congress is withholding funds to close Gitmo without a solution on the detainees. As problematic as any agreement may turn out to be, how can it be avoided altogether?
Executive Order.
However, Obama wants political cover for closing GITMO since he was charged with being a terrorist lover last year by daring to house terror suspects in Super max prisons in the US and hold legal trials in the federal courts.
He wants some GOP figure on the hook so he can claim bi-partisanship but he should know by now Graham is just scamming him. Remember Grassley and HCR? Same thing, different stalking horse.
Greg Sargent has been pointing out for months that Congressional Democrats have left Obama out to dry on national security and detainee issues.
I’m infuriated that Obama would consider compromising on his promise to restore habeus corpus – but with his requests denied funds and shut out of Congress, what path forward are you suggesting?
Since when? Since we let the the Presidential Chief of Staff negotiate these things in order to get the detention center at Guantanamo closed instead of letting the Department of Justice and the courts follow US law.
Since Lindsey Graham became an important “bipartisan” player.
Since those two got together.
Since Republicans in Congress get the power to dictate to the executive.
That said, no decision has been made and one could be made in advance of any legislation. Just haul KSM to New York and put him on trial. Once that is done, the issue becomes somewhat moot.
Note to those tracking my IP address and correlating it with other known personal identifiers … the views reflected in this blog where they write about things like ‘the rule of law’ and ‘the constitution’ do not reflect my own.
I am fully supportive of my government. I love my government. I have the ‘Love my Government’ bumper sticker, T-shirt and 6 of 12 collectible mugs.
So there’s no need to come for me until you’ve way down on the list.