Burning the Quran, the holy book of Islam, which is what a publicity seeking Florida Christian church plans to do on September 11th to demonstrate its bigotry, is a cowardly and incredibly stupid thing to do:
KABUL—The top U.S. commander in Afghanistan said the planned burning of Qurans on Sept. 11 by a Florida church could put the lives of American troops in danger and damage the war effort.
Gen. David Petraeus said the Taliban would exploit the demonstration for propaganda purposes, drumming up anger toward the U.S. and making it harder for allied troops to carry out their mission of protecting Afghan civilians. […]
Hundreds of Afghans attended a demonstration in Kabul on Monday to protest the plans of Florida pastor Terry Jones, who has said he will burn the Quran on Sept. 11.
It’s easy to for Terry Jones to express his “righteous indignation” against Islamic extremists from the safety of the Florida Peninsula, but to anyone in the armed forces serving in Afghanistan this is just another excuse for outraged Muslims to retaliate against them and for the Taliban to recruit disaffected individuals to their violent, extremist cause.
Obviously, Jones is doing this to make a name for himself since his church has all of fifty (that’s Five-0 folks) members. Just as obviously he has no respect for the millions of Muslims who are peaceful and have nothing to do with the actions of extremists in their ranks.
Imagine if you will if the United States were occupied by an Islamic country’s military (an event so improbable that only the most deluded individuals could possibly take it seriously, but humor me) and an Islamic scholar or Imam announced he planned to burn hundreds of Christian Bibles in retaliation for terrorist actions taken by a few fringe extremist Christians?
What would be the reaction of most Fundamentalist Christians in America? Even if those foreign troops had acted with the greatest respect and forbearance toward American civilians under their control, and had never tortured or killed innocent people by mistake, those American Christians would be filled with anger and a great desire to take revenge against Muslims. No doubt more than a few of the more extreme Christian sects would feel justified in killing those Muslim soldiers who occupied our nation.
Indeed, what would be the reaction of prominent conservative Christians to such an act even if we were not under the military occupation of a foreign power? There likely would be loud outcries at such an action, and a call by some of the more extreme conservative Christian leaders for the US government to take action in response. Pat Robertson anyone?
Now ask yourselves if what Terry Jones is doing makes any sense at all other than as a personal effort at pumping up his own ego at the risk of the lives of both US soldiers and the Afghan people?
As General Petreaus noted in his remarks:
“It is precisely the kind of action the Taliban uses and could cause significant problems. Not just here, but everywhere in the world we are engaged with the Islamic community.”
Not that I expect our man Terry Jones to be listening to the voices of reason and tolerance. He’s enjoying his extended fifteen minutes of fame to the maximum extent that he can. I fully expect him to carry out his stupid little book burning stunt. But it would be nice if more prominent members of the Christian Right and the Republican party called him out on it instead of riding the wave of rabid, foaming at the mouth Islamo-phobia which seems to have taken possession of so many Americans this election season.
Update [2010-9-6 19:30:37 by Steven D]: Gainesville Florida Clergy speak out against Terry Jones’ plan to burn the Quran (h/t to Joaey in the comments):
the stupid burns so bright it can be seen from 10 miles away.
they need to stop calling themselves Christians.
If this country were occupied by another country, my actions would not be terrorism but sabotage and armed resistance. Of course, the other side would perceive this with terror.
Yes I can see the Blockbuster Movie coming next Summer — “Red Crescent Dawn” starring Keifer Sutherland and a host of unknowns with swarthy complexions.
I prefer Donald Sutherland in Catch-22.
So, if forced to live under foreign occupation you would engage in sabotage and armed resistance rather than Ghandian pure non-violence? How interesting.
Well I’m sure he also wants to provoke reaction to “prove” he’s correct.
Just a little bit more evidence that religious Right = Taliban. The difference between them lies in how much power they have. They are kept out of power by the Constitution and the government, so it should be no surprise that they and their teaparty doggies should want to destroy both.
This video of clergymen in that Florida city coming together to support Muslims and oppose the Quran burning was posted a few days ago in the local newspaper. But they’re only local voices which probably not many will see or hear.
I also hope the message of opposition to this hatred and blatantly stupid proposed act, and the message of tolerance and inclusion can be given a much broader voice – a national voice – from both political parties. This is so beyond party and political posturing.
http://video.gatorsports.com/video/602031295001
Thanks for the link.
Bravo and thank you.
But if this so-called church has a grand total of 50 members, why has it gotten all this attention? Until the last 5 minutes, I assumed it was some kind of Coral Ridge mega-outfit. The MSM fails again. But they can try to redeem themselves by running this clip hourly for a week.
I suspect this proposed Qur’an burning is congruent with the sentiments of a very high percentage of the American population.
I’d like to think that this represents just the extreme tip of the rightwing iceberg. However, I suspect not.
I think General Petraeus’s statement means that the commander of US forces in Afghanistan believes Terry Jones’s proposed stunt poses a “clear and present danger” to American troops and civilians. And what that means, if I’m not mistaken, is that the Feds can arrest him, that is, unless the sheriff doesn’t arrest him first for making a fire without a permit.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_theater
The other point that is not being discussed is that, on top of everything else, this whole thing is a scam to distract attention from a money laundering operation that Jones has been running for some time.
Part 1:
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2010/9/5/893426
Part 2:
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2010/9/5/893426/-WARNING:-Money-launderers-using-muslims-as-red-herrin
gs.
http://8ackgr0und-n015e.dailykos.com/
Sorry, I got mixed up with the the URLs.
The second one I gave is not the right article.
The third one is Part I, and Part II is:
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2010/9/6/896744/-Keeping-up-with-the-Joneses:-Koran-burning-con-artist
s.
Yeah, the world-class self promoter Petraeus is right. Qur’an burning and other forms of anti-Islam behaviour are wrong because they endanger American troops who are occupying Muslim countries. The American military should be allowed to occupy Muslim countries in peace!
I believe that Americans have the right to burn any books they want. Even if it is stupid – but when is burning a book anything but stupid? As if ideas can be burnt out of our collective consciousness?
Equally to the point, in the overall scheme of things, killing innocent Afghanis is far more likely to radicalize Muslims than a small church burning the Quoran in FL.
No, on this one, Petraeus is full of shit.
Which, in my opinion, is often the case.
Jake
Yes, I just LOVE hearing that US military officials are concerned that burning the Qur’an may “spark violence” in Afghanistan. Soooooo, the military occupyers – you know, the ones who started the violence when they blasted their way into Afghanistan, and who are directly responsible for committing by far the greatest amount and magnitude of violence for the last decade or so are concerned that riling up the “natives” by burning a few Qur’ans is going to disrupt their peaceful occupation by sparking violence? Or is it that they do not consider invading and occupying a country by bombing and shooting and beating up and torturing people is not violent as long as a western military power does it? Only resistance is violent? And the American people are dumb enough buy that line of standard military bull** every single time, too.
Oh, and Petraeus is full of s*** most of the time. His only real skill is self-promotion, and he is extremely good at that. Start practicing saying “President Petraeus”, because that’s his goal, probably in 2016.
Maybe someone should take up a collection and buy 50 Qur’ans. They could be sent to libraries and schools.
Yeah, but then people would have to read them, and the kinds of people who want to burn Qur’ans wouldn’t want to taint their perfect ignorance with a little knowledge, now, would they?