I think it’s only polite when the country has a huge success to kind of back off the criticism and nitpicking for at least a day. I don’t mean necessarily that ordinary folks should feel restrained in any way, but politicians do themselves no favors when they react with “yes, but” downers. That’s what Howard Dean did the day we captured Saddam Hussein. His polls went into an immediate decline and he ultimately lost his considerable lead in Iowa. I always thought the two were closely related. What Dean said was true, and it needed to be said. It just didn’t need to be said that day. Rick Santorum doesn’t have any kind of lead to blow, and he’s probably not going to ever be competitive in his run for the presidency, but he still comes off as a jerk.
“Congratulations, well done, well orchestrated,” Santorum told the Des Moines Register before an event with voters. “That’s one isolated area as opposed to the president’s foreign policy and how it’s affecting our security. The president’s foreign policy with respect to our security is to make our allies less confident in us and has resulted in them in distancing themselves from us.”
…
“I don’t believe that this particular event of killing Osama bin Laden is going to change our enemies’ feelings about this because the president has been very clear that he always wanted to get bin Laden but he’s also been very clear about dealing with our enemies, his policy is to engage them not confront them,” Santorum said. “So I don’t see anything in this that would give any enemy of the United States any concerns beyond that one event.”
Personally, I’ve had enough confrontation, so to the small extent that I’m willing to grant Santorum his point, I am actually glad that the president is more interested in engagement. But, even if I agreed entirely with Santorum, I’d still think he’s politically tone-deaf, just like I did with Howard Dean.
Going forward, I don’t expect Republicans to drop their critiques of Obama’s foreign policy or offer unqualified praise of the operation that killed Usama bin-Laden. I do, however, think many of those criticisms will have less resonance or sense of plausibility to them as a result of this success. I am hoping that the public with gradually get the sense that Obama is fixing and solving problems that the Republicans either created or failed to address. As always, I intend to point out how these things would be fixed or solved with better solutions and more quickly if the Republicans had less power to obstruct.
And there’s climate change. That one is not getting fixed anytime soon, by any conceivable politician. And it may be the most serious of all our problems.
From a strictly strategic POV, al Qaida’s loss of bin Laden probably doesn’t significantly weaken them. He appeared to be pretty irrelevant to their plans and outlook. And yet I think this could be an event that shifts history, both globally and in the US.
To all appearances, bin Laden had taken on the role of a superhero or minor deity for his followers, a figure to rally around when needed to convince oneself of one’s justification for murder — much as the Pope was similarly used to justify the atrocities of the Crusades. It seems very possible that this cult leader’s ignominious defeat and death is taking the air out of the inflated “heroism” that the suicide bombers and their cronies imagine they are enacting. A belief in invincibility, in inevitability, is necessary to sustaining cults like these, and now that’s seriously weakened. I think the event opens up a new opportunity for everyone involved to take a step back, sweep the stale myths from their eyes, and consider new sets of values and perceptions about what really matters and how to pursue it with reason and enlightened self interest instead of heroic fantasy.
In the US, we have been as dogged by silly myths as anyone else, most recently about Obama’s true intentions and capability, about the evil of government, about the “corruption” of “our” country by the Others. I’m not a fan of the military, but the brilliance, resourcefulness, and courage shown in this operation has to cut through some of the intellectual cobwebs that have passed for thought in this country for too long. Leadership matters. Rationality matters. That’s how things get done. Obama has said, to the point of ad nauseum, that America has what it takes to get the job done if only we set our minds to it. Now, after all the years of empty bluster that went before, he’s orchestrated a living and dramatic example of what he means. I think this example has the potential to change our mental state as deeply as Sept 11 did.
With any luck, today it becomes just a little bit harder to sustain politics on the basis of petty sniping and the propaganda of twisted facts. While bin Laden’s end in one way changes nothing, in a larger way it has the power to change everything if only we open ourselves to its lessons. We’ll see.
I like your optimism.
I don’t know about optimism. Thinking one sees a turning point doesn’t necessarily mean believing the right road will be taken. I do think, given the weirdness of this country, that the current administration offers the most hope along that line that we’ve had in a long time.
Well, you provide the basis for optimism, which is its own form of optimism. Opportunities exist.
Well, he didn’t need to get Boehner’s or McConnell’s approval (or the gang of 12, 6 or whatever number in the Senate) before acting. That always helps a president.
Imagine what they would be saying today if this mission failed?
Impeachment would be on the table in the House of representatives.
Hey Boo, get with the new talking pointa:
Buah is like totally responsible for killing Osama bin Laden and saving Western Civilization
AND
That Kenyan Usurper destroyed our economy by passing health care reform.
Oh, I thought it was the troops, and the Commander-in-Chief of said troops had no claims to “victory” whatsoever. Do I have my talking points wrong?
(I guess I should never be surprised by Republican hypocrisy and vileness, but I didn’t think this issue would be one where they were partisan hacks. I’ve seen more statuses than I can count saying how we should be celebrating the troops — not Obama. Lesson learned?).
When I saw this headline:
Supporters gather outside Bush home after bin Laden killing
I envisioned a flag waving throng of admirers like this to be waiting outside the Bush residence
But alas, the report quickly gives away the disappointing reality,
I think I saw more people than that at the BP Station this morning waiting to get to the coffee pot.
Not sure, but I think I can surmise that he’s still about as popular as chlamydia.
Why was a dozen people outside Bush’s house even a story?
because it’s DFW and TExas still loves Bush, even people who would not be considered his voters.
having lived here now for 5 years, it still amazes me how many people here are STILL fans of his.
It’s delusional and almost pathological.
You are correct! Every one of the links I saw which carried this headline were from news organizations in Texas, with one exception (which is where I saw it)…………..on Drudge Report.
Hmmm, why does that not surprise me?
Really Virtual, the guy who tweeted the attack, is totally cool
http://twitter.com/#!/ReallyVirtual
Less OT of the thread – what I want to know is how it came about that Osama was living in the Ridgefield, NJ of Islamabad????
I can appreciate this tweet from 9 hours ago:
Maybe Trump will have him on his show.
I like the part about the helicopter and the giant swatter.
(but luckily his giant swatter didn’t work that well)
hey Boo,
what do u think this does for John Huntsman’s possible campaign?
Wouldn’t his strenght have been having foreign policy “experience” that the other’s did not?
Also, which one of the “undeclared” do you think will rethink 2012 because of this news?
I gotta say, I have never seen a president deliver such a steaming pot of STFU to his critics as Obama has this week.
Also, I’ve observed that whenever Republicans start whining about how the president has “politicized” an issue, it means they’re taking a beating and wish it would just stop. The staggering thing is that I’ve read apparently intelligent right wingers whining about how Obama politicized the birth certificate issue. Like, he was pulling the strings on it or something.
Santorum is a punk.ass.bitch