Well, after President Obama last week managed to temporarily save face by turning a lemon into lemonade, trust Israel to find a way today, with this announcement from the Knesset, to defy physics and turns the lemonade back into even more lemons:
…the Knesset will vote on [a] bill to annex the West Bank at the end of October. The bill also nullifies the Oslo Accords, ending all Israeli agreements with the Palestinian Authority.
The JTA reports it mirrors a bill being considered in the U.S. Congress and seems to have support among leaders of the [Israeli] coalition government.
No, wait, make that a festival of lemons:
The Palestinian Authority on Tuesday slammed Israel’s approval of construction plans to build 1,100 new housing units in a settlement in East Jerusalem.
Israel’s regional planning and construction committee on Tuesday approved the plans, described by one committee member as “a nice gift for Rosh Hashanah.”
… The last round of peace talks collapsed over Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s refusal to extend a partial freeze on illegal settlement building.
President Mahmoud Abbas said Sunday that he would not return to negotiations unless Israel stopped building Jewish-only settlements on occupied Palestinian land. Netanyahu indicated Tuesday that he was not about to offer one.
So last week, as a way to avoid US and European awkwardness over its support of Israel, Obama finds a way to save face by strongarming both the Palestinians (at least, the Fatah faction) and Israel into accepting new talks. And today both Netanyahu and the Knesset, on separate fronts, do their level best to torpedo those talks.
Personally, really, I’m done with Israel. I mean, I’m sad about it. Good people live there, and don’t deserve the governments they get, or the knuckleheads that elect them. But after generations of indefensible behavior, really, if Israel want to commit political and economic and cultural suicide, why should I care? I mean, I would much rather any transition to a sane and peaceful and just Middle East not come at the expense of Israel having the entire world turn against it, but Israel’s not leaving a whole lot of wiggle room for sympathy here.
No, I’m more concerned by the prospect that the United States electorate seems, circa 2011, to be completely capable of heading down the exact same suicidal road. Good people live here, too, and we also don’t deserve the governments we get, or the knuckleheads that elect them. But our generations of indefensible behavior, crowned (so far) by eight literally torturous years of George W. Bush, is at significant risk of getting exponentially worse in a bit over 13 months. And an outlaw, pariah United States carries significantly more potential to damage global economic and political stability than a country of seven million people, no matter how many nukes it has.
So, yeah, it’s scary watching the Israel government, supported by a large and vocal segment of its rightward-drifting public, repeatedly shoot itself in the face. But one of the reasons it’s scary is that a not small portion of the U.S. electorate, and one of its two major political parties, would like to do exactly the same thing.
.
He’s one of us now, after assigning Israeli Dennis Ross as chief negotiator for the US in Mid-East talks and his “damn the Palestinians” speech at the UN. Obama is lauded by both Avigdor Lieberman and staunch Israeli ally former New York mayor Ed Koch.
Everyone comes to a moment in his life when a choice has to be made, Barack Hussein Obama failed at that crucial moment. US foreign policy is in line with previous administrations and US exceptionalism. Hurrah, hurrah, HURRAH!
Obama is no leader but a follower taking his orders from the worst of Wall Street and Pennsylvania Ave lobbyists.
‘Post’ poll finds surge in Obama popularity in Israel
"But I will not let myself be reduced to silence."
Don’t worry, Geov! Hillary Clinton “blasted” Israel for their new 1,100 settlements.
As she said, “We’ve been here before.” We know where “before” lands us, Madame Secretary…
Thanks! I feel so much better.
US: on the wrong side back when the Apartheid regime was extant in South Africa, and on the wrong side with Israel
s equivalent to Apartheid.
Wait a second, are we in Bizarro Middle East where the Palestinians declare a two state solution and the Israelis declare a one state solution?
That’s been the situation since 1967, dontcha know? Forty-four years of Bizarro.
Does look as if Israel is choosing Apartheid over two states. Desmond Tutu once noted that Apartheid in South Africa during the Afrikaaner era was nothing like the way Palestinians exist in the West Bank. The term Bantustan is not likely to sufficiently describe the conditions Israel has created and has in store for the Palestinian population under its military control once annexation is implemented.
Israeli Supreme Court Authorises Surrounding of al-Walaje Village by Separation Wall
Prisons. But al-Walaje is not the only prison Israel has created to house Palestinians.
Qalqilya: Prison City
Palestine Monitor
3 October 2009
In the official 2007 census, Qalqilya had a population of 41739. Quite a prison.
It very plainly is time for President Obama to recognize that there are as many muslim voters in the US as Jewish voters, that not all Jewish voters support Netanyahu’s actions, and that a vote for justice is in the US national interest globally.
President Obama should instruct Susan Rice to vote Yes on Palestinian statehood and should freeze aid to Israel. Better now than to face worse behavior from Netanyahu next year.
Yes he should, but no he won’t!
Annex the West Bank? How does that not destroy their democracy? If they were to give the inhabitants of the West Bank full rights as citizens they would be the Jewish state much longer.
Personally I wish Israel and the Israelis well, but I don’t see why the US should keep funding this bullshit. What do we even get out of it? The mantra we always hear is “Israel has a right to defend itself, Israel has a right to defend itself,” but to steal other people’s land and call it self-defense is just pure thuggery. It’s no less an act of aggression than launching rockets from Gaza. (Palestinians, evidently, have no right to defend themselves.)
If the Israelis really do want to exist in peace and security, their best bet is to chill. Stop building settlements. Make a fair and honest deal with the Palestinians. Granted, Hamas has to chill too, but Netanyahu and the rest of these yahoos are a far greater threat to peace and stability right now than Hamas.
It only makes sense if the plan is to engage in “ethnic cleansing”.
The Karma, she is a bitch.
I was curious, too, about this “bill being considered in the U.S. Congress.” That can mean one of two things these days: either it’s something that might conceivably happen or it’s some lunatic idea coming out of the Republican House that will die a quick and merciful death in the Senate. Somehow news reporters have a hard time making that distinction.
Sure enough, this one is being pushed by a far-right Congressman, Rep. Joe Walsh (R-Ill). Is the Senate really going to pass a bill endorsing Israel’s annexation of the West Bank? Is Obama going to sign it? I know the Israel lobby has an undue influence over our government, but I have a hard time imagining it.
I had the same curiosity, and in fact in first draft of this post pointed out that the bill was sponsored by Walsh and was unlikely to go anywhere. But then I thought about all the bullshit bills and resolutions supporting Israel that have passed Congress before, and the reflexive instinct many Congresscritters have to defend Israeli government behavior no matter how outrageous it is, and thought: if Israel went through with its law, how would Congress react?
So I took that part out.
“President Obama last week managed to temporarily save face by turning a lemon into lemonade…“
Seriously?! Lemonade is more of the same old same old talks that have served only to allow Israel to continue to sink its hooks more and more deeply into what is left of Palestinian land and life? Lemonade is buying Israel still more time to create facts on the ground that clearly are and always have been intended to lead to the incorporation of the erstwhile Palestinian state into Israel?
Are you sure that’s lemonade, and not Kool Aid you’re drinking?
Lemonade for the US, as it would have been a monumental embarrassment. Also, good to see you again. I was just thinking of you the other day.