{Update2}
LATEST NEWS: Judicial Post Mortem: Zygier Tranquilized Before Death, Body Bruised
{Update1}
Original Australian Report on Prisoner X – DFAT knew of Australian’s detention in Israel
A spokeswoman for Senator Carr says the Minister was initially advised that the Department of Foreign Affairs (DFAT) was unaware of Mr Zygier’s detention.
“DFAT has now advised that some officers of the department were made aware of Mr Allen’s detention at the time in 2010 by another Australian agency,” the spokeswoman said in a statement.
“Minister Carr has asked department secretary, Mr Peter Varghese, to review the handling of this consular case.”
ABC Foreign Correspondent Mystery of Prisoner X slowly unravels + transcript
See comments about story in the Jerusalem Post, most readers justify act with reference to US detention, rendition and Gitmo.
This stain will remain for decades on US abuse of Human Rights.
Prisoner X was Mossad Agent, Ben Zygier by Richard Silverstein
(Tikun Olam) – Back in 2010, I reported that Israel had arrested an unidentified individual, and imprisoned him in total secrecy in an Israeli jail. The cell he occupied had once housed Yigal Amir. Even his jailers didn’t know who he was. His jailers apparently did a lousy job of monitoring Prisoner X, as he was called and he hung himself from a bar in his cell. In December 2010, Australian Jewish media reported that Ben Zygier had died in Israel and was to be buried in Melbourne’s Jewish cemetery. There was little spoken about the cause of death.
Now Australia’s ABC network blows open the story (transcript here). Prisoner X was not an Iranian general, as my Israeli source reported to me at that time. He was a Mossad agent named Ben Zygier, age 34 with two small children and an Israeli wife. Yossi Melman, reporting in Walla (the report is displayed here, but has been censored and removed by the military censor) says no one knows why he was imprisoned, but that it must have involved a crime that endangered the existence of the State of Israel. That’s a pretty hefty sentence even for security-obsessed Israel. This has to mean he was involved in an act considered treason. It might possibly involve selling secrets to an enemy power. Jonathan Pollard comes to mind in the U.S. context.
Today’s update, very interesting … Ben Zygier Visited Iran Undercover for Mossad, Recruited Saudi, Iranian Students at Australian University
Israel’s ‘Prisoner X’ was Australian Mossad agent, documentary claims
(Guardian) – Like the fictional Man in the Iron Mask, Israel’s infamous “Prisoner X” was allegedly held in solitary confinement in conditions of such strict secrecy that even his own jailers were told neither his name nor the crime he had allegedly committed.
The man’s identity became the subject of intense speculation when he was reportedly found hanged in his cell in 2010, but the prisoner’s existence has never been officially acknowledged by Israel’s government, which has gone to extraordinary lengths to stifle media coverage of the case. Now, however, new evidence has been uncovered by the Australian Broadcasting Corporation that strongly suggests Prisoner X was an Australian citizen, Ben Zygier, whom it described a Mossad agent.
In the immediate aftermath of ABC’s claims, the Israeli newspaper Haaretz reported that the Israeli prime minister’s office had called “an emergency meeting of the Editors Committee … to ask its members to co-operate with the government and withhold publication of information pertaining to an incident that is very embarrassing to a certain government agency”.
Later in the day the gagging orders were explicitly linked to the claims about the dead Australian by several Israeli MPs who also raised questions about the affair during a debate in the Knesset.
A new documentary screened this week for ABC’s Foreign Correspondent programme claims Zygier used the name Ben Alon or Ben Allen after moving to Israel. He was secretly imprisoned in Ayalon prison in Ramla in the wing built to accommodate Yigal Amir, the assassin of the Israeli prime minister Yitzhak Rabin, ABC reported.
The 34-year-old was married to an Israeli woman and was the father of two young children. He had reportedly spent a number of months in the cell before his death.
Zygier’s father Geoffrey, a prominent leader of the Melbourne Jewish community, apparently refused to speak to the programme makers.
NY Times – Silenced in Israel, Spy Tale Unfolds in Australia
Continue below the fold …
MKs blow cover off censored security affair
(JPost) – The citizens of Israel will soon learn information on a sensitive anonymous prisoner case that the government has kept under wraps, MKs told Justice Minister Yaakov Neeman on Tuesday.
“An article was published that an Australian prisoner committed suicide under a different identity. Do you know about the situation? Do you confirm that it occurred?” asked MK Ahmed Tibi (United Arab List-Ta’al), in reference to a report from earlier in the day by Australia’s ABC News.
“Are there people in prisons whose incarceration is kept secret? What are the supervision mechanisms on this kind of imprisonment?” demanded Hadash MK Dov Henin. “What are the possibilities for parliamentary supervision on such incarcerations? How can the public be critical in this situation?” Meretz MK Zehava Gal-On told Neeman, “I want to hear your stance on the fact that journalists volunteer to censor information at the government’s request.”
Referring to the informal forum that includes the heads of the country’s Hebrew press outlets and The Jerusalem Post, she asked, “Is it proper that the Prime Minister’s Office invited the Editors’ Committee to prevent news from being publicized? Today, we hear that in a country that claims to be a civilized democracy, journalists cooperate with the government, and that anonymous prisoners, who no one knew existed, commit suicide.”
Details of the case are expected to be released Wednesday.
Australian suspected of Mossad links dies in Israeli jail (dupe of article #146486)
.
.
Added to article early this morning – Prisoner X was Mossad Agent, Ben Zygier
Sorry, not the Mavi Marmara, this would not be embarrasing enough. Israel’s national security at risk would mean Lebanon/Hezbollah/Syria/Iran … think of assassinations carried out in Lebanon. Ben Allen – lawyer – telecom – spy network – false evidence/witnesses – STL investigation – Hariri bombing. Look at the 2010 timeline of the STL investigation in Lebanon. See also the early 2010 reporting by Jason Koutsoukis: ASIO targets new spy suspects. Ynet News covered this story today: Did Zygier visit Iran, Syria, Lebanon?
This input was used by Richard Silverstein in a new, extended article. Very interesting …
Ben Zygier Visited Iran Undercover for Mossad, Recruited Saudi, Iranian Students at Australian University
Reports/stories like this one make my head spin.
This new Guardian article Mossad and Australian spies: how Fairfax reporter homed in on Zygier is interesting. Someone apparently outed Zygier. But why secretly arrest and jail him? Then he apparently turns up dead and his family has nothing to say. Very odd indeed.
.
Did he do anything? Other than keeping his mouth shut almost a year later when Zygier’s body was returned from the Israeli prison.
.
“Either Zygier had mistakenly compromised the identities of the agents through an inadvertent error. Or more darkly, perhaps Zygier was stricken with conscience over the fact that his acts of passport fraud.”
In this event, don’t get misled by misinformation dropped into the media. I don’t see a link to the Mossad hit in Dubai as certain media want you to believe. The Dubai police uncovered all Mossad agents because it’s an ultimate high-security state with video cameras, passport scanning and facial recognition. The passport fraud (Jackal ploy) was public knowledge, see article February 18, 2010. Who was the US helping with its investigation in money transfers?
The killing of a terrorist in Dubai is not a cause for conflict of conscience. I would focus on his activities in Iran, Syria and Lebanon. Ben Zygier was a soft, sensitive person according to close relatives in Australia. In his work to infiltrate in Iran, he may have been involved with setting-up Mossad terror cells which led to the assassinations of scientists. The Mossad agents who were captured were all hanged.
Some key information to consider, Ben Zigier’s lawyer said he claimed innocence to charges. Zigier could have been wrongly accused, the high pay-out to his family would be an indication. Perhaps it’s more about embarrasment in the end then national security of the state of Israel.
Early in 2010, Israel had plenty of problems with its security and publicity: the Anat Kamm leaked documents and publication of UN Goldstone report: Gaza War Crimes. WikiLeaks of US Embassy in Canberra documents expressed the frame of mind of PM Kevin Rudd towards Israel. It seems as Shin Bet leaders grow older they mellow – Film The Gatekeepers.
Australia intelligence chief makes secret trip to Israel over Dubai passport forgery – May 2010
IMO there is no truth to the article in Kuwait daily Al Jarida. Ben Zygier was not unveiled as a Mossad agent in the Dubai probe.
“Head of Dubai police, Dhahi Khalfan, said the top-secret Israeli-Australian prisoner, Ben Zygier or Prisoner X, didn’t contact authorities in Dubai to give information of the 2010 killing of Hamas leader in the UAE.”
The NY Times article reported by UAE The National has apparently been deleted – cached version.
“Prisoner X” linked to Mossad hit in Dubai this URL has a new article: “Tunisian PM seeks political solution”.
The United States insular to Article 36 of Vienna Convention on Consular Relations. [Dual-citizenship is not covered under Art. 36 VCCR according to US State Dep’t]
Texan authorities’ misunderstanding of, or contempt for, international treaties – here. [warning right-wing rant]
History of Consular Relations – Mexico vs USA [a pdf file, need to click on page to scroll] .
The US Supreme Court, in the case of José Ernesto Medellín v. Texas, held that decisions of the International Court of Justice are not binding domestic law and that, without authority from the United States Congress or the Constitution, the President of the United States lacks the power to enforce international treaties or decisions of the International Court of Justice.
No Comment
Australian spy agency handled the case of Prisoner X, spooks stated Zygier’s legal rights would be respected.
Mr Smith: “It would be inappropriate to comment in advance of the outcome of the investigation.”
What did Mr Kevin Rudd know? “No comment.”
Australia’s embassy in Tel Aviv was clearly sidelined.
Israel’s ambassador in Australia, Yuval Rotem said: “I told you guys I’ve got no comment to make about this.”
Former Australian FM Downer says in 1990s Israel was warned not to issue fake passports to Mossad agents.
Yuval Rotem, Israeli Ambassador to New Zealand, responds: “Try wearing Israeli Shoes”
‘Mossad spies’ jailed over New Zealand passport fraud, identity theft of tetraplegic man – 2004
‘NZ quake victim was Mossad agent’ – July 2011
Original article by Jason Koutsoukis ASIO targets new spy suspects (February 27, 2010)
“ASIO is investigating at least three dual Australian-Israeli citizens who they suspect of using Australian cover to spy for Israel. The investigation began at least six months before last month’s assassination of the Hamas operative Mahmoud al-Mabhouh, widely believed to have been carried out by the Israeli security agency Mossad.”
Thus the ASIO investigation started in July 2009 and Jason Koutsoukis contacted Ben Zygier in the fall of 2009 when he was in Israel. This new report therefore does not make sense, is a deception.
Confidential cable from US Ambassador Jeffrey Bleich dated February 25, 2010 – the day the passports story first broke – shows the embassy believed Australia would vote against the UN resolution [Goldstone Report] despite its anger at Israel. The cable quotes senior DFAT official Joel McGregor as saying Australian officials were “furious” all the way up the chain of command.
“The recent revelations that suspected Mossad agents used fake Australian passports to enter Dubai and kill a Hamas commander have made this decision more complicated.”
My analysis, this is just smoke and mirrors. The Mossad and ASIS have worked very closely throughout these events, these articles about what politicians say could be for public consumption. Australia and New Zealand (Israeli Ambassador Yuval Rotem) were deeply involved with the fake passports for many years.
The accusation against Ben Zygier must have been as grave as the Vanunu affair. I’m thinking more along the line of the Hariri assassination. The Mehlis Report got the wrong suspects and the STL trial of Hezbollah agents is very weak and based on circumstantial evidence provided by Western powers and Israel. One of Australia’s top cops and former chief investigator for the tribunal, Nick Kaldas, reiterated accusations that Hezbollah was behind the killing.
Who Killed Hariri? The Simplest Theory
.
.
.
LATEST NEWS: Judicial Post Mortem: Zygier Tranquilized Before Death, Body Bruised
Revelations Al-Mabhouh Assassination started as early as February 15, 2010
.
Putting out statements to close ranks with Israel’s Mossad on the Zygier affair, it’s a words game. See also Jerusalem Post and Ynet News [plus video]. Being under surveillance is not the same as being in contact with the intelligence agency. I also believe there will be a discrepancy in Zygier’s dossier known by ASIS and the domestic intelligence unit ASIO. Perhaps it was even in the dossier name: Alon or Burroughs.
.
I picked-up on two interesting background articles in Australian blogs about Ben Zygier …
Prisoner X Was From My Shtetl
But among Melbourne’s Jews these questions have a slightly different tenor–one of distress and sympathy for the Zygier family. In quiet conversations, everyone is wondering: How did this happen to one of ours?
Dangers in Dual-citizenship and Serving In Het Majesty’s Secret Service
Galus Australis – But moving, as Ben Zygier did, from a simple IDF role to an espionage one is where the lines become blurred. It appears that Australian spy organizations, either ASIS or ASIO, did know what he was doing. Under Australian law that should have crossed a line, at which point, for his own safety, the Australian authorities should have brought him home.