.
Of course you and me and the rights granted and guaranteed under the US Constitution!
Watch 2013 Barack Obama Debate 2006 Joe Biden Over NSA Surveillance
(EFF) – June 14, 2013 – After a leaked FISA court document revealed that the National Security Agency (NSA) is vacuuming up private data on millions of innocent Americans by collecting all the phone records of Verizon customers, President Obama responded by saying “let’s have a debate” about the scope of US surveillance powers.
At EFF, we couldn’t agree more. It turns out, President Obama’s most formative debate partner over the invasiveness of NSA domestic surveillance could be his Vice President Joe Biden. Back in 2006, when the NSA surveillance program was first revealed by the New York Times, then-Senator Biden was one of the program’s most articulate critics. As the FISA court order shows, the scope of NSA surveillance program has not changed much since 2006, except for the occupant in the White House.
Watch this video, as Senator Biden from 2006 directly refutes each point President Obama made about the NSA surveillance program at his news conference last week.
Biden in 2006 schools Obama in 2013 over NSA spying program
Extensive hearings in the US Senate and a debate between Democrats and Republicans. Only names have changed: for Bush read Obama, for Cheney read Biden, for Gonzalez read Holder and for Biden read Wyden. [large pdf]
NY Times exclusive: Bush Lets U.S. Spy on Callers Without Courts