It’s spring concert season at your local public school, and if you want to have your spirits lifted, your hope renewed, and see the promise of democracy in action, go.
This happens even—or perhaps especially—at that oft-feared and much-dreaded institution: the big urban public high school. Or, in the case of the concert we attended, a combined (7-12) middle and high school in a nearly century-old brick building bursting at its seams with thousands of students.
With so many students in the school, nearly 1,000 participate in one of the two “music nights” held each spring. There are concert bands, show bands and jazz bands; show choirs, gospel choirs and a capella groups; female choirs, male choirs and string orchestras.
There are 7th graders who’ve been playing their instruments for less than eight months. There are seniors who’ve been singing in public since they were five years old. And as they take the stage, and their parents, grandparents, brothers, sisters and classmates listen attentively (for the most part)…they make music.
Wonderful music. Glorious music. Sacred songs sung in languages living and dead. Popular music from the 21st, and 20th (and 19th, and 18th, and 17th, and 16th and 15th) century. Classical music from Russia, Germany, France, England and Italy… and from New Orleans, Los Angeles, Boston, Chicago and New York.
The younger instrumentalists play simpler pieces, with great concentration and great gusto. As the night goes on and the performers get older, the music gets more challenging and complex. Negro spirituals sung with the precision and power of the 19th century Fisk Jubilee Singers. Jazz songs that swing with the polyrhythmic assertiveness and assurance of mid-20th century bebop bands. Orchestral compositions performed with passion and nuance.
More girls sing than boys, so a few years ago the choral director formed an all-female choir for some of the high school students. Over 100 young woman fill the stage and sing with a piercing beauty—from tones barely above a hushed whisper to full-throated chords that seem to rustle the dusty old curtains.
One reason boys don’t sing is right around 8th grade their voices change. A note they could reach easily yesterday is out of reach today. They try to hit a note and instead slide up and down, desperately trying to shape their changing vocal chords into a position that will hold a tone. What to do?
The new choral teacher has formed an all-male choir…of 8th grade boys. The 15 of them are the smallest performing group to take the stage that night in the expansive, high-ceilinged, acoustically challenging auditorium. And they sing beautifully. Not perfectly, but beautifully. And now that’s 15 more young men who know what it feels like to stand tall in front of hundreds of people, open their mouths and change how every one of those people feels.
The final string orchestra—made up of seniors and the most musically talented juniors—always provides special moments. For one, it is stunning to hear the progression from the novices they were in 7th grade. Five years ago, they still were learning about eighth notes. Now they’re playing one of Bach’s Brandenburg Concertos—3 parts each for violins and violas, and 2 apiece for cellos and basses. It’s a piece written for a small chamber orchestra, such as would play for a king and his guests after dinner.
These teenagers, drawn from different backgrounds and circumstances, play with a grace and delicacy and beauty that would please any 18th century European monarch…while also filling the hall with a power and energy and sound that is, in its own way, utterly subversive of the culture of monarchy.
And that is as it should be in a democracy, in a public school. The arts—all arts, high and low, visual and performing—are the birthright of every citizen: to hear, to watch, to perform, to create.
Some older Americans view the generation coming of age in the 21st century with great fear and trembling. So many of them have dark(er) skin, speak different languages, use different slang, listen to different music.
At a public school concert almost anywhere in America today (yes, even in your town), those same children sing and play and perform not just the songs of their generation, but the songs that connect one generation to another, stretching back over hundreds of years and thousands of miles, dozens of languages and a multitude of differences.
They get up on stage, and in what they sing and play, and in what we hear, and then in the hushed moments of silence after an achingly beautiful melody, and the rapturous, raucous applause after the stunning climax of a song, the beautiful bonds that unite us as human beings, and the common culture we share in and create as citizens of a participatory democracy are strengthened and renewed once again.
The kids are all right.
I think that you live in or near Boston. Am I right? I know that you don’t live in NYC, because I teach outreach/short residency music to NYC, Long Island and NJ students, and I see a music education system in total disrepair. Not just disrepair…more like almost total neglect. My female friend teaches as a general sub in NYC schools…also Westchester and Connecticut…and whatever virus is infecting the NYC schools, it’s spreading. Not just in the music departments, either. It’s most of the teaching staff and the students. Except for a couple of really elite schools…and by that I do not necessarily mean rich, because one of the worst programs in which I teach is a suburban school rated among the top 10 richest public school districts in the nation…what I see is a bored and often hostile student body being taught by people who are disgusted with their jobs and are only in it for the money, the benefits and an early retirement.
My ex-wife and I moved out of NYC in the early ’90s because we saw this beginning to happen in the lower grades where my son was going to school…a once-highly rated Upper West Side public school that was just a shell of its former self. To our shock, the bedroom community to which we moved had schools that were not much better. My son had a music teacher in intermediate and high school that could not tune his own bass by ear. He had no pitch whatsoever. Naturally, neither did the ensembles he taught. Among many other mediocrities and worse, there were also a math teacher who couldn’t even add grades correctly and a Spanish teacher who spoke almost no Spanish. And forget about the administrators!!! Their sole idea of dealing with a kid who wasn’t going with the program was to give him meds. We fought through it and my son came out fine…he’s going to a major Ivy League school nowworking on his doctorate in environmental biology w/a full boat scholarship. (Which basically means he’s an indentured teaching servant. But he’s learning at the same time. On fire.) However, his last several years of public school were frightful! He rebelled against the entire system and started to get into real trouble. Until we got him into an alternate-lifestyle, open program-style school during his senior year…just lucky, we were…he was headed straight down. (By the way, that school still exists but every year is a fight to the death against defunding from the county.)
I envy you in Boston. Good luck with it. Pray that the current virus infecting NYC area schools doesn’t reach your area. I call it the digital disease because I think a large part of it stems from students’ early-life reliance on pervasive online technology instead of learning by a more hit-or-miss, succeed-or-fail linear manner. They do not learn to read, only to skim for memorization purposes; they do not learn to write, only to cut and paste and they do not learn how to study because it’s all available for them online when they “forget.” Musically, they do not learn to listen. Since everything is available at the click of a mouse, they flit form song to song, from piece to piece, all the while listening to it on earbuds that only reproduce about 1/4 of the real information needed to really hear music. They are so far gone that they cannot listen to music without simultaneously looking at images.
The YouTube generation.
So it goes.
We wanted an Information Age.
Well…we got it.
Disjointed, unconnected, incomplete but easily accessed “information,” all censored by the profit considerations of giant tech firms.
What’s on the horizon?
Damned if I know.
More of the same until the culture collapses, I think.
It’s better in much of New England, that I know. Better in the Pacific Northwest and better in Canada as well.
Have fun with it while it lasts, massappeal.
It’s a rapidly spreading disease.
Later…
AG
Thanks for your detailed and thoughtful comment. I know we’ve been lucky, in many ways, with our children and with their education. Our school system’s last superintendent had both strengths and weaknesses, but one of the strengths was a passion for the arts in education. As a result, over the last several years, there’s been a slow but steady expansion of music and arts education in the public schools in our district. It’s no nirvana, but it’s better than it was; and it’s always inspiring to see what young people can do with even a little encouragement and support.
Nice real post.
Where’s Marshall McLuhan when we need him?
McLuhan Hypothesis
The dynamics you describe so forthrightly in your third paragraph should have the attention of all social scientists and thinking people. No doubt, we are going through an extremely disconcerting transition, our minds polluted with millions of words and storylines, identifying with so much of it, most of it based upon base(r)intentions and conjobs. And it looks like it’s going to be a while before it smoothes out.
So I’ve committed to keep growing by asking questions and by chanting this mantra:
Hari Om TatSat Jai Guru Datta
This mantra ‘came in’ in 1975. It is specifically focused for the modern age. Flexible is rhythms like jazz, it is spiritual science and an essential tool for our time.