Lawrence Colburn
Good Guys:
Hugh Thompson, Jr. (April 15, 1943 – January 6, 2006)
Thompson exhibited the highest level of heroism that day in March 1968. At personal physical risk, tepping in to stop an atrocity and leading his younger subordinates to follow him.
One of his men, Glenn Adroetta (October 30, 1947 – April 8, 1968), only lived a few weeks after that day. Another casualty of that unnecessary war.
The third hero, Lawrence Colburn (July 6, 1949 – December 13, 2016) made it all the way to four days ago. He and Thompson remained lifelong buddies.
Reflect for a moment on how young these three men were that day. Respectively twenty-four, twenty, and eighteen. Thompson also reported the massacre to his superiors. Those that were older and more experienced who proceeded to do their best to cover it up.
There was also a whistle-blower. Ronald Lee Ridenhour (April 6, 1946 – May 10, 1998). (A role that wasn’t as thankless back then as it has become today with those on the left, right, and center expressing loathing for such people.)
Specialist 5 Ronald L. Ridenhour, a former door gunner from the Aviation Section, Headquarters Company of the 11th Infantry Brigade, sent a letter in March 1969 to thirty members of Congress imploring them to investigate the circumstances surrounding the “Pinkville” incident.
…
Most recipients of Ridenhour’s letter ignored it, with the exception of Congressman Mo Udall[81] and Senators Barry Goldwater and Edward Brooke.[82] Udall urged the House Armed Services Committee to call on Pentagon officials to conduct an investigation.
When this massacre made its way to the RealNews (as contrasted with the earlier FakeNews: On March 16, 1968, in the official press briefing known as the “Five O’Clock Follies”, a mimeographed release included this passage: “In an action today, Americal Division forces killed 128 enemy near Quang Ngai City. Helicopter gunships and artillery missions supported the ground elements throughout the day.” and Colonel Henderson issued a Letter of Commendation to Captain Medina on March 27, 1968.)
Thompson was vilified by many Americans for his testimony against United States Army personnel. He recounted in a CBS 60 Minutes television program in 2004, “I’d received death threats over the phone…Dead animals on your porch, mutilated animals on your porch some mornings when you get up.”
(It should be noted that the “Alt-right” back then wasn’t a majority view. In real time the majority is usually silent. Waiting to be told by someone of high stature which way they should go.)
There was one “by the books” senior officer that figured into the aftermath of the massacre, Lt General William R. Peers (June 14, 1914-April 6, 1984) (A Major General on that day in 1968.)
The Army had Lieutenant General William R. Peers conduct the investigation. [Ordered by Westmoreland] He conducted a very thorough investigation. Congress did not like his investigation at all, because he pulled no punches, and he recommended court-martial for I think 34 people, not necessarily for the murder but for the cover-up.
Some were indicted and trials held. Only one served some time, under house arrest for three and a half years. All but one were disgraced in some way. Whether or not they lived happily after that day, they all lived or are living more years than the heroes did.
General William C. Westmoreland (March 26, 1914-July 18, 2005)
Brigiadier General Samuel W. Koster (December 19, 1919-Janary 23, 2006) (demoted from Major General).
Colonel Oran Henderson (Aug. 25, 1920-June 1998)
Captain Ernest Medina (August 27, 1936–)
Second Lieutenant William L. Calley, Jr. (June 8, 1943–)
General Colin Powell (April 5, 1937–) (Only a Major on that day in 1968.)
There are many lessons to be learned from this very sorry tale. Unfortunately, we Americans not only don’t seem to be learning but appear to be regressing.
Thank you Mr. Colburn for your service that day in 1968 and in the months and years after as you spoke truth to power and doing the right thing.
The armed services were different, then. I think it was because the draft (
mal)functioned to pick up some honorable people against their will. This does not seem to be happening now. Most armed services people go in with their eyes wide open, thinking of it it as a good gig (if they don’t get killed or maimed, and most don’t) from which they can retire early with a good pension.Now?
I don’t think anyone now would report such things. How long were Abu Ghraib and the other torture camps going on? How many heads rolled for those kinds of actions and how low in the chain of command were those heads? People who join the military for the security it offers will be loathe to report crimes if they value their pensions.
Back then? I spent some time…a month in 1966…in S.E. Asia when the Vietnam War was in full swing and I hung out with a great many soldiers on rest and recreation leave in Bangkok in a jazz club there. Let me assure you…they were not there for the security; they had been forcibly drafted and were to a man totally against the war.
Not now…the military is completely voluntary today.
I wonder how many My Lais happened during Bush II’s Blood For Oil War that went totally unreported. How many drone attack “errors” have happened under Obama’s reign as Peace President.
Lots.
Betcha.
Not a word from anybody except poor, confused little Bradley/Chelsea Manning, and look what happened to him/her!!! They made an object lesson out of Private Manning.
So it goes.
AG
P.S. Numbers to back up that that “most don’t” get hurt reference above:
There look to be about 1,500,000 people on active duty in the U.S. military today. Military deaths since 2003? Offficially? About 7000. I cannot find up to date injury numbers, but there were roughly 10 times more injuries than deaths during the Afghanistan and Iraq conflicts so I will guess that there were 7,000 deaths total there were probably around 70,000 injuries. 77,000 deaths or injuries total….about a 5% injury/death rate. Not a bad gamble, considering that most of the really smart ones probably tried to get non-combat gigs. That leaves the gung-ho types taking the brunt of the harm.
Of course…these are published numbers from an entirely unreliable source, the U.S. military, but still…they can’t be lying that much!!!
Can they?
Interesting to note that the all volunteer military after the Vietnam War did get rid of that pesky problem of personnel with ethics and/or a conscience for a good thirty years. Then the manpower needs for Bush’s great adventure exceeded the standard operating recruitment rules and a few with a conscience slipped through. Someone did take those Abu Ghraib photos and passed them onto others so that they could see the horror. Pat Tillman responded with traditional patriotic fervor by enlisting and was beginning to see the sham when he was killed. Manning (although she may not have been clear as to her motivations) collected and passed on information restricted to those in the military and higher up civilians.
WWII was possibly the peak in the numbers of those with ethics/conscience. Looks as if there was a 60% drafted to 40% enlisted during those years. But the pool of enlisted men and women would be different from what we have today. Get in, serve, win the war, and get out prevailed; whereas today, it’s a secure job and therefore, the institution must be preserved.
Interesting and related article by Nassim Taleb – The Most Intolerant Wins: The Dictatorship of the Small Minority
Also recommend Taleb’s The Syrian War Condensed: A more Rigorous Way to Look at the Conflict, although it’s not related to the diary or AG’s and my comments.
Thanks. Lot of sly humor in his piece.
Sure hope he is right about Monsanto.
There are variables integral to GMOs that he doesn’t cover. It could go either way and I doubt that public acceptance or rejection of GMOs will be the major determinate.