So far, I’ve been focused on the successful hacking that the Russians did during the presidential campaign and haven’t focused much on the request Donald Trump made on July 27th, 2016 that Russia find the 33,000 emails that Hillary Clinton allegedly deleted because they were, she says, unrelated to official business and personal in nature. But I guess we need to revisit that request now in light of new reporting from the Wall Street Journal.
Let me just refresh your memory on this a little bit.
By late July, the intelligence community was reporting with confidence that Russian state-sponsored hackers were responsible for breaking and entering into DNC headquarters and leaking emails on the eve of the Democratic National Convention that led to the resignation of Debbie Wasserman Schultz as chairwoman of the party. The Obama administration was not yet publicly accusing the Russians of responsibility but they were privately developing options for retaliation. This was all known to the press and served as the context in which Trump made his now infamous comments:
Donald J. Trump said on Wednesday that he hoped Russian intelligence services had successfully hacked Hillary Clinton’s email, and encouraged them to publish whatever they may have stolen, essentially urging a foreign adversary to conduct cyberespionage against a former secretary of state.
“Russia, if you’re listening, I hope you’re able to find the 30,000 emails that are missing,” Mr. Trump said during a news conference here in an apparent reference to Mrs. Clinton’s deleted emails. “I think you will probably be rewarded mightily by our press.”
Mr. Trump’s call was another bizarre moment in the mystery of whether Vladimir V. Putin’s government has been seeking to influence the United States’ presidential race.
At some point after that press conference, our intelligence community intercepted communications from “Russian hackers discussing how to obtain emails from Mrs. Clinton’s server and then transmit them to Mr. [Michael] Flynn via an intermediary.”
Apparently, they did not identify the intermediary at that time. Yet, there is now strong evidence to suggest that the intermediary was Peter W. Smith, a recently deceased long-time adversary of the Clintons who helped finance the Arkansas Project back in the 1990s. The Arkansas Project hired David Brock and pursued the Clintons relentlessly on a variety of fronts from Whitewater to rumors that Bill Clinton had fathered a black child to what became known as Troopergate to the suicide of White House aide Vince Foster. Their efforts eventually resulted in the impeachment of Bill Clinton for matters that linked back indirectly to Paula Jones.
The evidence that Peter W. Smith colluded with the Russians to obtain stolen emails from Hillary Clinton’s server is incontrovertible because Smith admitted to it in May shortly before he died at age 81. But the really concerning part of this is that Smith was promoting his effort as something that was approved and coordinated by Michael Flynn and his son. He did, in fact, receive emails that were purported to be the Holy Grail of deleted emails Donald Trump had requested, but he couldn’t verify their authenticity and didn’t want to take responsibility for publishing them. He asked the hackers to send them to WikiLeaks.
Before the 2016 presidential election, a longtime Republican opposition researcher mounted an independent campaign to obtain emails he believed were stolen from Hillary Clinton’s private server, likely by Russian hackers.
In conversations with members of his circle and with others he tried to recruit to help him, the GOP operative, Peter W. Smith, implied he was working with retired Lt. Gen. Mike Flynn, at the time a senior adviser to then-candidate Donald Trump.
“He said, ‘I’m talking to Michael Flynn about this—if you find anything, can you let me know?’” said Eric York, a computer-security expert from Atlanta who searched hacker forums on Mr. Smith’s behalf for people who might have access to the emails.
Emails written by Mr. Smith and one of his associates show that his small group considered Mr. Flynn and his consulting company, Flynn Intel Group, to be allies in their quest.
Here’s the really alarming part:
Mr. Smith and one of his associates said they had a line of communication with Mr. Flynn and his consulting company.
In one Smith email reviewed by the Journal, intended to entice outside experts to join his work, he offered to make introductions to Mr. Flynn’s son, Michael G. Flynn, who worked as chief of staff in his father’s company. Mr. Smith’s email mentioned the son among a small number of other people he said were helping.
Michael G. Flynn didn’t respond to a request for comment.
In another recruiting email seen by the Journal, Jonathan Safron, a law student Mr. Smith described as a close colleague, included links to the websites and LinkedIn profiles of people purportedly working with the Smith team. At the top of the list was the name and website of Flynn Intel, which Mr. Flynn set up after his 2014 firing as director of the Defense Intelligence Agency.
Mr. Safron declined to comment on his email or Mr. Smith’s project.
I suppose there are a variety of defenses available here. Michael Flynn and his son can say that they never authorized Mr. Smith to use their names or their company in this manner. The Trump administration has already said that Mr. Smith had no role in their campaign and was acting as a free agent. At the time, even the Flynns were more informal advisers and supporters than salaried members of Trump’s campaign team. And, of course, Mr. Smith is now dead and unavailable to testify in court or provide further information to the Special Counsel.
But the alleged involvement of the Flynns in this activity is close to a smoking gun when you consider what subsequently transpired. I won’t detail all of that here, except to remind you that Trump ignored all advice and warnings and made the elder Flynn his national security adviser, refused to fire him even when told he was likely compromised by the Russians, and fired James Comey after the FBI Director refused to follow his request to drop his investigation of Flynn.
If nothing else, the case that Trump was attempting to conceal something and obstruct justice when he asked that Flynn’s connections to the Russians be dropped just got closer to a slam-dunk.
What’s odd about this is that it pertains entirely to events and actions that took place after the DNC hacks and after the initial release of emails. This seems to have been an effort to prove that Clinton’s private email server had been hacked, which at the time was something that James Comey said was possible but unproven. It looks like it was based on the conspiracy theory that Clinton was lying when she said the deleted emails were personal in nature.
While this story shows collusion, it doesn’t link Flynn and Trump back to the Guccifer 2.0 hacks that were the previous focus of interest. Yet, it also shows an amazing recklessness that these folks would aggressively seek to collude with Russian hackers at the exact same time that the intelligence community and the Obama administration was trying to figure out a way to punish the Russians for what they had already done.
If either Flynn left electronic records of communications with Mr. Smith, the Special Counsel will have arrived right at Trump’s door. And, of course, the elder Flynn is facing enough charges to add up to significant jail time. He may decide that testifying to Trump’s knowledge of his activities is the only way to remain a free man.
This is really well done. Thanks on behalf of everybody who stays on the other side of the WSJ paywall.
Much more likely, Flynn goes back-channel to Trump and decides to fall on his own sword, after receiving confirmation that Trump will give him a pardon if convicted. Don’t think he will turn states’ evidence to save his skin. You’d be surprised how stupid criminal defendants in conspiracies can actually be, even when facing serious felony time in Club Fed (where by the way they don’t give you 50% time off for “good behaviour”).
“Michael Flynn is a patriot being persecuted by a vengeful out of control special prosecutor on a partisan witch hunt” — will be Trump’s line in issuing the pardon. Fox News will parrot the line and the rest of the world will be shocked. But, what can they do? Trump will have bought the silence of one man who could bring him to impeachment.
But, there will be others. Lots of others. Remember that Trump’s business dealings are now fair game for the Special Prosecutor. And he’s been operating totally crookedly for decades. Tax evasion is probably the least of it.
“Lots of others” ?
Remember Spiro Agnew?
Trump has an Agnew problem.
When Spiro was Baltimore County Executive and Maryland Governor the graft rolled in.
Then, when he was promoted to Vice President of the Whole United STATES!, he thought that unlike a number of unfortunate Spanish conquistadores he had finally found the fabled El Dorado! (Hey, not unlike Trump and his whole odious family!)
That case was made in the classic organized crime manner by squeezing a little guy who could only save himself by giving up a bigger guy. You then squeeze that guy to work your way up the chain for bigger and bigger fish. Sort of a domino effect. The final domino in Agnew’s case turned out OMG! to be the Vice President himself!
Don’t expect any sudden new burst of creativity or insight with the Royal Baby either. Like Agnew he will keep trying to use the things that worked before ( bluster, bribing, lying, cheating, threatening, making shit up, etc.) and it will all end badly. Sad.
Unlike Agnew (nolo contendere plea and probation) and Nixon
(the pardon Ford apologized for to the end of his days), these times are more unforgiving. I would not be surprised to see Trump end up in a cell at the Trump Butner next to Bernie Madoff. Another first! The First Hard Time President!
Certainly would be nice to see, but I’m not holding my breath …
Yes, it’s the money. At some point we will find out how much the donald and Jared have borrowed from the Russians. I don’t want any of them to go to Club Fed so they can pal around with Madoff. They need to be out here with us so we can point and laugh till it get old.
I think Trump is not too smart, but nonetheless, there is a way of looking at it that makes some sense even in upside down Trump land:
–>Trump did not expect to win, and no one else did. Not Obama, not Russia. I don’t think he wanted to win, because if he did he would never have done so many reckless things.
What he wanted to do was to make a spectacle of himself, create a tribe of followers to grift to and then return to the life he really loves, which mostly revolves around loving himself. And the Russians most likely intended to weaken Clinton and just generally screw things up.
Can you imagine the look on Trump’s face (and on his Family’s faces!) when he realized that he won? I’m sure it was a priceless moment.
In fact I recall at least one photo of the Trump clan as the results came in, and yeh, a whole lot of grimness showing on the family’s faces amid the joy of their entourage.
U.S. GOP Activist Who Sought Clinton Emails Cited Trump Campaign Officials
Re: GOP Operative Peter Smith’s Death Ruled A Suicide
Truly a final moment of fame!
Was his exit choreographed? By whom?
What was his true conviction in the matter?
He was aware of Trump’s troubles with investigations
He knew the Mike Flynn story with Russia
Peter Smith was known to work on his own, had the funds for it
Was he really anti Russia, anti Putin?
Intent to undermine the Trump presidency
One last act of subversion
He failed in contacts with hackers on the Dark Net to recover the Clinton emails
See my follow-up diary where Peter Smith is linked to the alt-right
○ Peter Smith Tapped Alt-Right to Access Dark Net
Charles C. Johnson said he also suggested that Peter Smith get in touch with Andrew Auernheimer, a hacker who goes by the alias ‘Weev’ and has collaborated with Johnson in the past. Auernheimer–who was released from federal prison in 2014 after having a conviction for fraud and hacking offenses vacated [on appeal – May 2014] and subsequently moved to Ukraine.
This group is alt-right, anti-Putin and pro-Ukraine.
IMO fits handily in the collusion with Steve Bannon, the renegade inside the White House
○ Trump donor ‘kills himself’ after revealing he tried to get Hillary Clinton’s emails from Russian hackers | The Independent |