I wrote most comprehensively about Felix Sater in a piece we published in February called Trump’s SoHo Project, the Mob, and Russian Intelligence and in an April piece entitled Trump, Felix Sater, and the FBI. I also mentioned him and his relationship with Trump’s lawyer Michael Cohen in How Did Alex Oronov Die and Why Does It Matter?, a piece I wrote in March. You might also be interested in the Mobbed Up article that Mike Lofgren published with us in February. In any case, if you’ve been following along, the name Felix Sater should be somewhat familiar to you. If you haven’t been keeping up with Sater here, perhaps you’ve been following the coverage at Talking Points Memo where Josh Marshall has been on the case like white on rice.
As a brief recap, Felix Sater was born in Moscow in 1966. His Russian Jewish family briefly emigrated to Israel before coming to the United States and eventually settling in 1974 in the Brighton Beach section of Brooklyn that is known for its large Russian population. As a child be became acquainted with Michael Cohen, who would go on to represent Donald Trump. In 1991, Sater was arrested for stabbing a commodities trader “in the cheek and neck with the stem of a margarita glass, breaking his jaw, lacerating his face, and severing nerves, creating a wound that would require 110 stitches to treat.”
In 1998, “Sater was convicted of fraud in connection to a $40 million penny stock pump and dump scheme conducted by the Russian Mafia.” The scam may have served as inspiration for a storyline in the HBO show The Sopranos where mafia “soldier” Christopher Moltisanti ran the same kind of racket.
Sater decided to become an FBI informant after the latter arrest, and that’s a Forrest Gump story all on its own. I’m not going to describe the whole saga of Sater’s life for you again right now (that’s what the links above are for) but it’s important to know the basics of what kind of guy he is. He’s a violent criminal with long associations with the Russian mob who somehow managed to be an informant against that mob for the FBI for more than a decade without winding up in a shallow grave. He’s also someone who has worked extensively with Donald Trump on various projects, including the SoHo development and “the Trump International Hotel & Residence in Phoenix, Arizona, the Conrad Fort Lauderdale and Midtown Miami in Florida, and Cornwall Terrace and 1 Blackfriars in London.” Trump once stated under oath that he wouldn’t know Felix Sater’s face if he walked into the room, but that was perjury.
This will all become painfully obviously soon.
Trump has been telling a lot of lies, and maybe foremost among them has been the lie that he has had no business deals in Russia or anything to do with Russia at all. Felix Sater’s testimony and his documents will prove otherwise.
While Donald Trump was running for president in late 2015 and early 2016, his company was pursuing a plan to develop a massive Trump Tower in Moscow, according to several people familiar with the proposal and new records reviewed by Trump Organization lawyers.
As part of the discussions, a Russian-born real estate developer urged Trump to come to Moscow to tout the proposal and suggested that he could get President Vladimir Putin to say “great things” about Trump, according to several people who have been briefed on his correspondence.
The developer, Felix Sater, predicted in a November 2015 email that he and Trump Organization leaders would soon be celebrating — both one of the biggest residential projects in real estate history and Donald Trump’s election as president, according to two of the people with knowledge of the exchange.
Sater wrote to Trump Organization Executive Vice President Michael Cohen “something to the effect of, ‘Can you believe two guys from Brooklyn are going to elect a president?’ ” said one person briefed on the email exchange. Sater emigrated from what was then the Soviet Union when he was 6 and grew up in Brooklyn.
There’s a tremendous amount of stuff to unpack here, and the intelligence committees in Congress will have to pore over Sater’s documents and question him carefully. Special Counsel Bob Mueller will be looking, too, although we won’t hear anything from him unless and until someone gets indicted or there is an impeachment referral.
For now, let’s just try to remember why Trump denied having business deals in Russia. He denied it because he demonstrated an abnormal tendency to praise Vladimir Putin that was hard to understand absent some financial incentive for doing so. That he either had Russian deals that were vulnerable or wished to pursue Russian deals and didn’t want to jeopardize them was such an obvious inference that it didn’t need to be explained to anyone. He was asked if these were the explanations for his behavior and he said the whole idea was made up and ludicrous.
But people’s suspicions were 100% accurate. He was lying the entire time.
Trump’s panic indicates there’s more to this than just business deals in Russia. My guess is that shady Russian financiers bailed him out of one of his many financial crises. But it’s only a guess, and I expect we’ll find out what he’s hiding soon enough.
I don’t understand why Sater is running his mouth, unless he wants to “commit suicide” by shooting himself in the back of the head two time and then jumping out a highrise window in Manhattan or something like that.
you have to ask yourself how he is still alive and in good enough standing in Russia to spend time there openly and negotiate with Putin’s inner circle. Makes no sense.
It makes sense for Slater to continue to be influential only if Putin, et al are planning on Trump not being the President in the near future. President Pence, Speaker Ryan and Majority Leader McConnell will then be quite indebted to the Russians for saving their offices, asses and brand. Hell, get rid of Pence (Shouldn’t be too hard) and President Pro Tem Hatch will be delighted to be of service.
In order to be an effective Manchurian President, you have to effective. Trump is stupid, in terms of intellect, in terms of empathy and in terms of politics. Just as an example: What would Nixon have accomplished with the setup Trump came in with?
Trump as president is worse than useless to Putin, the Russians and the Russian Mob. It is quite conceivable that the price of Slater’s life is that he becomes the mole that brings down the mountain of Trump & Co.
One possible theory of Russia’s behavior is that Trump winning was not the real goal – that the goal was to create chaos and to delegitimize and weaken Clinton, who was expected to win it. I think that the Russians would have been smart enough to look ahead to see the Trump winning would not be a bonanza for Russia, and in actual fact, Trump’s winning HAS created more problems for Russia not less.
Following the Chaos Theory, the Russians will at some point let the cat out of the big, fatally weakening Trump and triggering more crisis in our political system. Creating more crisis and discord in our politics will very much make the Russians happy. I think this all fits well with the very real question: Why is Sater still talking and why is he not dead?
You write:
Yes.
You do.
And there are no simple answers to this one simple…and glaringly obvious…question.
Maybe Sater has some really damaging info securely stashed away on Putin et al? On Trump et al? On the rest of the nasty hustlers on both sides of this ongoing drama?
There is only one thing that is almost 100% certain to be correct.
We will never know the real story. Even if it were to appear, intelligence forces from all sides would so muddy up the water that it would rapidly sink into a morass of false news and disappear from sight.
And the beat goes on.
Just as it has since the JFK murder.
Only…they are much better at the game than they were in 1963.
Much better.
Better disinfo tactics and better disinfo weapons.
To say the least.
Watch.
AG
Or was that Butthead?
Both.
AG
Though most of the commentary has assumed that Putin runs his oligarchs, it may not be out of bounds to recognize that some of those same oligarchs have the knives out for Putin and may be interested in working deals with Sater for yet another sinister plot we haven’t even imagined yet.
Fantastic clarity and mastery of the detail.
One quibble: I think it’s always essential in this context to note planning for Trump Tower Moscow in association with Sater goes back to 2006, when Sater took Grand Duchess Ivanka and Grand Duke Donald Jr. on a trip there to look at potential sites.
yeah, not trying to get bogged down in this piece.
The Saga of Sater is an epic tale, too crazy to be non-fiction and yet completely true.
exceptions?
Six months and more information after your first post on this, and well away from Russian cyberwarfare line, it is clear that someone in Russia wanted very much to ensure that Hillary Clinton would not become President.
With Trump as the means, no doubt someone hostile to the US national security community saw Trump as an instrument to create problems in the US intelligence community and military. US intelligence apparently got wind of this scheme at some point around the political conventions, and we witnessed Clinton as the beneficiary of a number of ex-intelligence community leadership who might be expected to endorse the Republican candidate.
No matter how messed up the immediate post-election response of the Democrats was (and it was very messed up), it did get an independent investigator. These reports are obviously leaks to journalists and have their own agendas that will be tested in grand jury and maybe even jury proceedings (if we are lucky).
The wild card is still the inconstancy of the media and the constant spinning of the partisan machines.
I said in a comment on one of BooMan’s articles he cited above that the focus on mob in the US and Russian seemed a more fruitful focus to investigate than a direct allegation of the highest levels of the Russian government, which have connections with some part or other of the Russian mob.
What Mueller can do that no one had the authority to do before his appointment is to request of the FBI a search of records (and most likely with some very specific probable cause) that would be searched from the NSA’s signals intelligence databases. And Mueller can make the strong argument for whether some items should be released to the public.
There never was any doubt that when Trump himself was talking that he was lying. The doubt was over what properly was in fact the truth. Trump plays that as a strategy for discrediting his critics. And uses that as a means of exerting power in politics.
I was always very very cynical and suspicious about the Russian angle to all of this due to the crapulous way the D party has handled the whole thing.
Trump has been clever and canny all along using his favorite meme of Fake News and constantly attacking the media, some of which is justly deserved.
So I have long been on the fence about purported collusion with Russia, particularly the Big Dawg Putin, to ensure that Trump wins and Clinton loses.
I always figured that Trump was in bed with the Russian mob, bc why not? He’s mobbed up here in these Yew Knighted States, too, which bothers no one in the GOP, for some reason. Trump apparently couldn’t get money via the standard legalish means, so it figures he’d go begging and cutting “deals” with rich Russian Oligarchs.
Now there’s more proof in the pudding, but we’re not done yet. And I’m not sure where this leads. Will it end in impeachment? Not holding my breath. The GOP will have Trump’s back for as long as possible.
Trump does seem to be ever more desparate as he finds any way possible to fling red meat at his White Supremacist/Nazi base, and the sycophantic Ayn Randian GOP goes along to get along.
Sheesh. What. A. Mess.
Affiliating with NYC mobsters early in his career may have meant that he didn’t have to haul out a begging bowl to attract other organized crime individuals and groups. New Jersey and Florida were the first to welcome him with open arms. (Until only recently, he stayed away from Las Vegas because NV’s gaming regulators are tougher than he encountered in NJ.)
Like all salesmen, Trump isn’t fussy about who willingly puts up money for him and where the money comes from.
Wait until the GOP light bulb comes on and they realize they’re not protecting their brand or their power, no, they’re protecting Trump’s empire.
Yet another serving of lettuce, pickles, tomato on a sesame seed bun.
But where’s the Walter Mondale?
Yes.
Also yes.
Yes, squared.
I doubt it.
You?
AG
P.S. The real deal, according to John le Carré?
Spies Like Us: A Conversation With John le Carré and Ben Macintyre
Closer to the truth than any of this neocentrist foofaraw.
SpookWorld.
Where what “is”…isn’t.
Get used to it.
It’s the New Reality.
AG
New? Not hardly.
Don’t they say that Spying is the second oldest profession?
The “New Reality” of which I was speaking? Of course spies and spying are not in themselves “new,”…what is new is how deeply spy mentality and practice has penetrated into the lives of everyday people.
Here’s the deal as far as I am concerned:
In mechanical engineering, there is a tolerance past which gears cannot be machined. After a certain point, they lock rather than spin.
For eons, the hustlers have tried to machine our own personal lives to the point of complete control, but they did not have the means…other than threats of slavery, imprisonment and/or death…to do so. There has always been some considerable amount of personal wiggle room in all but the most vicious systems, and those kinds of systems eventually perished of their own faults. Their own “locked-up-ness”
Now?
In our lovely, rapidly approaching Total Surveillance World?
If the controllers choose to do so, we will be liable to prosecution for failing to throw a scrap of paper in the right bin, let alone pursuing great human traditions like jiggering personal taxes or fucking other peoples’ mates.
Wiggle room will soon be a thing of the past, and when that happens…before that happens, if the failures of previous totalitarian systems are any guide…this system will falter and die.
Life evolves due to wiggle room, and without evolution there is only stagnation.
Bet on it.
Watch.
AG
Whatever you’re on, I’d like some.
There seem to be some pretty severe side effects.
It is what i am off, jammerjim. I am off of mainstream media, especially the televised…and thus much more hypnotic…examples. You can cut and skim through print media, but not the TV-type. You have to sit through the news entire spiel and then sit through further trance-inducing advertisements.
Step away from the screen…the computer screen as well, if it’s mainstream media film/video etc…with your brains in the air.
You’ll be glad you did.
AG
Lots of contenders for #2. Time weighs in that #2 is medicine.
Forbes disagrees wrt #1
So, #1 and the most of the #2 nominees are mere subsets of Forbes #1 — selling good/services.
Among the historically very oldest is one that FDR was employed in for a few years. The running joke among professionals in that industry is that they are #2, but the joke is probably of recent vintage, 1920-1950.
GOP already trying stop Mueller