I have provided you with a roadmap for what would happen, and why, to the Trump administration when September rolled around. It’s important to understand what I did as a structural analysis more than a prediction of how any particular individual would act or what they might say. There might be some slight psychological component to the following essays, but not much. Not really.
Insofar as I discuss what anyone is thinking it is to argue that they aren’t thinking. I say that Trump has been sold a bill of goods, but also that the salesmen are nearly as deluded as he is. I say that Trump is in error, but I don’t really take much of a shot at explaining why he is susceptible to this error. I don’t think I make any mention of what people might be feeling at all.
I also don’t spend any time wondering how people might make decisions and spinning out various scenarios that are dependent on what they ultimately decide.
None of this was really necessary to game this out. They created a legislative plan that could not and would not work, and its failure was so certain that there wasn’t any way to change their course of doom.
Trump is Failing for Same Reason That Boehner Failed, April 5th, 2017.
And Now the Trump Presidency Begins to Fail for Real, June 29th, 2017.
How Trump and the GOP Congress Failed in Just Six Months, July 19th, 2017.
Trump has a tendency to do this to himself all the time. Just this weekend he said he wanted to cut off economic ties to every country that trades with North Korea. It took two seconds for people to point out that China trades with North Korea and that we can hardly cut economic ties with China. Laying out plans that have no prospect for success is part of his DNA and probably explains why he’s gone bankrupt five separate times.
But the legislative plan was sold to him by Paul Ryan and Mitch McConnell. They explained how they would achieve Trump’s goals and Trump believed them when they said they could deliver. He can be blamed for this, of course, but less so than for the self-inflicted mistakes he makes, like promising that Mexico will pay for a border wall.
Trump is magnificently bad at his job, but show me the workable plan to pass a 2018 budget, or repeal and replace Obamacare or to enact tax reform. Those tasks require a lot of steps and some legislative and procedural expertise. Trump ought to be able to rely on the Republican leaders to come up with a plan that has some prospect of success. But they gave him plans that were unlikely to work and then showed no sense of urgency about completing the preliminary steps that would be required.
What they all agreed on was that they could succeed without worrying about a legislative filibuster or the need to win any Democratic votes. They’d be able to muscle all of it through with just Republican votes.
But there was never any prospect of that actually happening.
You should really read the Heritage Foundation’s action plan for September to see just how radical the right’s ambitions are and just how bad their advice is to the people responsible for getting basic stuff done. I wouldn’t necessarily call the authors of that report deluded because they’re advocates and they’re taking a hard line. Taken at face value, though, their recommendations certainly read like the ravings of madmen.
And no one has really had the balls to stand up to them and explain that these things are not possible, and that even attempting them is worse than folly.
Stan Collender and I have been writing on these topics in similar ways, and I have to agree with him that the House Freedom Caucus is about to be neutered and angered. That’s an essential component of the reckoning I’ve been describing.
But it will only be a beginning, and it will come far too late. The fatal mistake was made at the inception of this presidency when Trump failed to understand that he had defeated both party establishments and could not succeed by relying on either of them to push his agenda through. He needed subject-dependent ad hoc coalitions, which could only plausibly be found at some intersections in the middle. In most areas, Trump could not rely on the far right either because they’d disagree or because they’d refuse to make compromises to attract vulnerable or sympathetic Democrats.
This isn’t one more call for centrism or bipartisanship. It’s a simple analysis of how you get the votes to pass legislation. And if you decide your entire strategy will be to use budget and procedural gimmicks to avoid working with Democrats, you have to have the unity pull it off.
You need the kind of unity it takes to kick 23 million people off their heath care, for example. You need the kind of unity that will allow you pass the budget plan you’ll need to enact tax reform under reconciliation rules.
But worse, they acted like the things that could not rely on procedural gimmicks actually could.
They need to have eight Democratic votes in the Senate to pass their appropriations. They have no plan for getting those votes and Trump will meet with the Democratic leaders this week for the first time since January.
All along, they’ve been operating in an alternative universe, but none of these plans could succeed. And it was very easy to see that they could not succeed and that a time would come when it would all come crashing down on them.
By the end of the month, they will either separate from the far right or the country will cease to function at all.
Ideology isn’t what drove us to this point. What drove us to this point was a failure of basic reasoning combined with cowardice. No one on the right wants to explain the limitations of their power, so they proceed as if they have more power than they do. No one wants to explain that certain arguments are made in bad faith and shouldn’t be taken literally, so we get investigations of Benghazi and voter fraud instead of serious governance. Promises that literally cannot be kept are held aloft until the very last dog dies, and then people wonder why Congress and particularly Republicans in Congress have such low approval numbers.
It’s all destroying the fabric of our country, but it’s been working at the ballot box.
Playtime is finally over. And now we get to pay for their mistakes.
That Heritage manifesto reads as though there are no Democrats in Congress and Republicans can make all decisions unilaterally. It’s steadfast refusal to address reality reminds me of:
Precisely.
And they score a lot of these votes and pressure members to follow their direction.
So, they punish anyone who doesn’t fight like the Black Knight.
Well, it worked when the game was total obstruction — and they went where no corrupt asswipe politician had gone before. So they got carried away thinking they could govern that way too. Ryan was always more mendacious, in a shallow “such a nice boy” way, than brilliant but the genius McConnell ain’t looking so smart at anymore.
I should feel more cheerful about the imminent collapse of the GOP Coalition. Yet I feel nothing but dread for the next two years.
I should feel more cheerful about the imminent collapse of the GOP Coalition.
I would except the Democrats in Congress will not take advantage. The DCCC is very bad at their job. And the buck stops at the desk of Nancy Pelosi for that. She appoints the person who heads the DCCC. What’s the point of raising crap loads of money if you continually piss it away? Example number one of the DCCC being bad at their jobs is Booman’s Congressional district. Complaining about gerrymandering only gets you so far when you can’t win, or bother competing in, districts that HRC carried last year.
“But the legislative plan was sold to him by Paul Ryan and Mitch McConnell. They explained how they would achieve Trump’s goals and Trump believed them when they said they could deliver. He can be blamed for this, of course, but less so than for the self-inflicted mistakes he makes, like promising that Mexico will pay for a border wall.”
But didn’t Trump insist on it? I think it’s more accurate to say they were bullshitting each other. Was any “good” plan possible for doing what they were trying to do? The whole thing was crap from beginning to end.
I’ve been reading how this or that is going to break the fever for the last 5 years. And yet it still has not happened.
Ideology did bring us to this point.
It’s not that I disagree with your analysis; it’s that they keep finding new ways to dig the hole even deeper. They keep breaking convention and defying expectation.
But, Irma seems to be on the way to Florida. Nothing, especially politics, happens in a vacuum. Right now it looks like the donald is going to war without a budget but a plan to cut taxes.
Booman, the bill of goods the GOP sold the donald, wasn’t Pence in the room? Was Pence as dumb as the donald?
Thank you.
Your structural analysis has been ENORMOUSLY helpful in understanding a “legislative” process that might as well be taking place in the day room of a mental institution.
Or to mix metaphors, like watching a poker game where many of the participants can’t be bothered to learn the correct odds and details of successful play because they are sure they will magically either get four aces or just bluff their way through to win.
I’m not sure Mr. Longman understands how unique and essential his voice is. I read widely on thoughtful blogs and I’ve subscribed for years to the POST and the TIMES. There is absolutely no one else who does this kind of remorseless, almost dispassionate analysis. It’s like seeing an expert in the structural analysis of bridges explain, without emotion, that the oncoming convoy of freight trucks will certainly cause a bridge to collapse and precipitate everyone into the river. There’s a kind of chilling elegance about it.
It’s also absolutely what we need. As Robert Heinlein reminds us in “Starship Troopers,” the franchise is force — “the power of the Rods and the Ax.” When force is exerted, things happen. It is, in a sense, a kind of physics of the political sphere. Voters in America have long been using that force to empower liars, cowards, and fanatics; and as Longman so well put it, “the grim waiter has brought the check.”
That’s the thing I really detest about so much of our debate on the extent to which the lying that so characterizes our political debates, especially from the right, has placed us in some area of alternate facts and reality. No such area can or does exist. All we can do is to deceive ourselves for a while about actual reality. And as Heinlein put it, “If he [the voter] voted the impossible, the disastrous possible happened instead–and responsibility was then forced on him willy-nilly and destroyed both him and his foundationless temple.”
Seconded.
+2. That’s why I donate (and I hope you do too).
Gee whillikers.
It’s almost as if the Republican leadership wanted Trump to fail.
Hmmmm….
The GOP leadership in all likelihood loathe and despise him, for assorted reasons.
Congress’s approval ratings are already subterranean, yet most GOP pols should easily win reelection in their gerrymandered districts.
If Trump fails so spectacularly that he is forced from office, there’s (a) Pence to do the bill signing, and (b) failing him, Ryan to live the dream.
Not much to lose, eh?
Almost.
Except that’s not what happened.
It’s be less frightening if it were, and on the other hand a bit more frightening.
Legislatively, der Trumper has accomplished none of the goals his backers desired. That doesn’t mean they will turn toward saner behavior. They have other goals that are being satisfied. Trump’s minions are happily dismantling the EPA, the State Department, HUD, DOE, with a great deal of success. By the time they are through there will be little left but a bloated military.
The goal of the “conservative” theorists, such as Grover Norquist and the Heritage scholastics cited above, was to destroy the federal government. This was amenable to the nation’s plutocrats and CEOs—having previously destroyed labor power, government power had next to be destroyed—so they happily funded the operation.
Unfortunately, to accomplish their goal, the electorate had to be morally and mentally destroyed as well, and with the sweep to total power of the Trumpites and Know Nothings in 2016, the victory is complete. The divided house cannot stand. The “democracy” is now a complete facade.
I wonder whether any of the envisioned legislative crack-up (should it actually occur) will even merit much time on the American boobs’ teevee and smartphone screens, given the approach of another Category 5 storm towards Florida and North Korea’s desperate desire to turn the imbecile Trump into a beloved War Prez. What if the long awaited crack-up comes, and no one notices? A perfect epitaph for FailedNation, Inc., haha!
Finally, it remains mystifying why exactly Ryan and McC cannot simply propose a debt ceiling bill which lays out a plethora of (future) cuts to social programs since this is all the Freedumb Caucus demands. It’s not like any so-called “moderate” Repub has to care too much about re-election, or that any of it would have to be taken seriously in future, since every Congressional budget action is now ultimately a scam and fraud.
If I may suggest a topic I’d like your take on, BooMan, your thoughts on if the Dems have any leverage right now for protecting the Dreamers.
They don’t seem to care about destroying the fabric of the country. They don’t seem to care about DACA or Nk or anything. Sad day when Vladimir Putin makes sense talking about NK, and we have the Mad Dog using the word annihilation. Last night RM treated us to a short takeout of Richard Spencer and his screed on the master race. Then they stood up and raised their hands like a Hitler salute. Hail Trump! And if you are transgender or LGBT the Family Research Council will pray over Trump to make your life a little harder. This morning on CNBC the wizards agreed with you that taxes have only a small chance of passing this year and not much next year. They think there is a good chance they will raise the debt limit. WTF is happening to my country? Hate is in the air everywhere.
This is your country on “conservatism”.
Also, too, the failed constitution was a latent defect.
Would be a really good time to double-check the sprinkler system on the Reichstag.