I encourage you to peruse the Heritage Foundation’s September action plan to see how unreasonable and unrealistic their demands are for how they expect Republican leaders to behave and Republican officeholders to vote. Here are some examples, and please remember that Congress has twelve legislative days to complete their entire September must-do list.
On the debt ceiling, which must be raised very soon to avoid a possible global economic catastrophe, Heritage advises, “Congress should not raise the debt limit with another bad budget deal. Rather, Congress should address the debt limit separately, and adopt spending controls before raising the debt limit again.” Where will they find the time for that?
On reauthorizing the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) before a September 30th deadline, “Congress should convert CHIP funding into a defined contribution program” and “require the states to share more of the cost of the program.” Those are much more complex (and radical) proposals than they might sound, and when is the debate over them supposed to take place?
On reauthorizing the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) before a September 30th deadline, Congress should “[l]ocalize airport funding by eliminating the (Airport Improvement Program) AIP,” eliminate the Essential Air Service program, relax regulations on “air carrier employment practices, ticketing operations, and airport grant assurances,” and “[e]xpand access to the Airport Privatization Pilot Program.” These are truly radical and destructive policy proposals and even Heritage admits there isn’t time to debate them. Ultimately, they ask for as short of an extension as possible so these things can be revisited in the near future.
On reauthorizing the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) before a September 30th deadline, Heritage says, “Congress should phase out the deeply flawed program and enable private insurance to replace it.” They lay out a complicated and basically insane phase-out plan. They don’t explain when the debate over this plan is supposed to take place.
On avoiding a government shutdown, Congress should “[r]eject any attempt to increase overall discretionary funding levels. Instead, lawmakers should prioritize national defense funding within the boundaries of the aggregate [Budget Control Act] BCA spending limits for FY 2018, and offset any defense funding increase with prudent domestic program eliminations and funding reductions.” In other words, no deals, just magic. Somehow, the Republicans should get the Democrats to agree to spend every available dime we have on weapons and to offset the cost by cuts to other government programs.
None of this is real advice. How would Ryan and McConnell achieve any of it in the twelve legislative days available to them?
Republican lawmakers, however, don’t like to get on the wrong side of the Heritage Foundation. If Heritage says not to raise the debt ceiling unless new spending controls are adopted first, then it doesn’t matter if there is no way to accomplish that task. If the flood insurance program shouldn’t be reauthorized until it is basically dismantled and privatized, then that might just be the end of the story. If the only acceptable appropriations plan is completely unachievable, then a government shutdown we shall have.
If you’re Paul Ryan or Mitch McConnell, you’ve got nothing to work with here. No realistic deals are deemed acceptable.
Yet, they sold Trump a plan premised primarily on the fact that they could pass through his agenda on party-line votes.
While it’s hard to blame them for the predicament Heritage puts them in, they can absolutely be blamed by Trump for making promises to him that were ridiculous and absurd.
To avoid a catastrophic default, a government shutdown, and a lapse in children’s health care, federal aviation safety and flood insurance, the Republican leadership in the Congress and the White House will have to tell Heritage to pound sand.
And then they’ll have to figure out how to survive politically, which John Boehner and Eric Cantor can tell them will not be easy.
Easy peasy, no?
“implement the Trump agenda”….(?)
Well, our fine rightwing scholastics always have a preposterous position on every issue, “reasoned” from one dubious premise after another to one bogus “conservative” conclusion after another. Not that many Freedumb Caucus members can read past the executive (haha) summary….
But what in the world is “Trump’s agenda” on CHIP, FAA, and Flood insurance? And aren’t these Heritage scholasticist positions directly opposed to whatever “guidance” the imbecile’s WH has bleated on shutdown and debt ceiling?
And of course our Great Leader spent the day injecting a new major issue into the roiling seas of dysfunction: DACA recission. At least there one can see the Trump “agenda”: “want your DACA kids? Give me my Wall”.
LOL – “rightwing scholastics” – this morning’s coffee spew moment. Thank you I needed that!
Pretty good, but you’ve been reading this stuff from me for months and months.
Well we might have a lot less Rush Limbaugh listeners to take care of if they take his advice
Stupid is as stupid does
https:/www.rushlimbaugh.com/daily/2017/09/05/my-analysis-of-the-hurricane-irma-panic
That’s because they will brook no debate. These are the marching orders. They’re so close to smashing the 20th century to bits and retreating to the <strike>19th</strike> Confederacy they can taste it.
I saw that Heritage screed last week, and glanced over and discarded it as completely insane and irrelevant. But, I suppose I was being hasty. The GOP has to take that crap seriously, even if it is not serious at all.
Basically they are demanding that the tides of the sea retreat like King Canute did.
But, the political fallout from defying Heritage is a LOT less than defaulting. That one they won’t be able to blame on someone else. “My opponent was IN Congress when they defaulted on the sovereign debt and betrayed the American people!”
There’s really no good answer to that one.
If you just can’t do your job, then there’s no reason to keep you in it Congressman. I suspect a lot of them will be suffering that fate next Autumn. But, that’s a whole year from now. And there’s a ton of “creative destruction” to get through before then.
That’s just the thing. I bet Heritage’s bullshit isn’t even very popular with GOP voters. But they’re in hock to their big donors. So that puts them up shits creek with out a paddle.
I’m late to comment on BooMan’s definitive post from yesterday (“This Wasn’t Hard to See Coming”), but these new points work along the same lines. When BooMan wrote
he provided the most succinct and damning paraphrase of the Right’s tactics since the Clinton years. They’re like advertising techniques (which, of course, is no accident, as Joe McGinnis and others have documented so exhaustively in the years since Nixon used Roger Ailes and Madison Avenue to win the White House), because all they do is sell the product — meaning, amass the votes from the public — without actually solving anything, advancing any real ideas, or reacting to reality and changing conditions. It’s exactly the recipe for disaster that BooMan describes.
If you showed McDonalds executives a Vegas airport full of morbidly obese, unhealthy Americans, they would protest: “What has that got to do with us? Nobody made them get fat. We’re just selling food people happen to enjoy; it’s up to them to manage their lives” etc. (with no regard to market domination or strong-arm lobbying involving Big Agro or “artificial flavor” laboratories or billion-dollar, decades-long ad campaigns). Similarly, when conservative campaign-advisor types are shown decades’ worth of wealth inequality, job insecurity, absence of healthcare, gun violence, and bad education, they say, “What are you looking at us for? We’re just selling candidates; telling them what to say to get elected and coördinating with Fox News, etc.” It’s not their fault. They’re just selling; they have no responsibility.
“… they can absolutely be blamed by Trump for making promises to him that were ridiculous and absurd.”
—————————–
Yes, and trump can absolutely be blamed by everybody for not knowing enough about his job, the constitution, governance, and on and on and on to know that those promises were ridiculous and absurd. Nobody’s fault but his own.
I see now the republicans want something in return for helping the Daca kids. Maybe border security perhaps, it’s been suggested. Blackmail is nice.
The Republicans had a brand that was good for a given period of American history:
But now –
-The hate doesn’t play as well with the younger generation
Only the hardcore 35% in the cult are following them at this point.