(I Initially wrote the following as a response to AngryTeacher’s comment on Booman’s most recent Serious Question post of March 18th. It grew…plus I didn’t want to have to fuss around with possible kneejerk zero raters…so here it is as a standalone. Please go there if you want to read AngryTeacher’s whole comment. It’s a good one.)
##############################################################################
AngryTeacher wrote…regarding a trip that he recently took through Northern and Western VA:
What I didn’t hear was much belligerence, for or against Mr. Trump. The overall sense was one of exhaustion with the news, exhaustion with the constant political combat. This surprised me. I was expecting a lot more fighting spirit, on all sides of these debates. People just seem exhausted.
You need to go to the cities and talk with the younger people and ghetto dwellers to hear belligerence, AT. Older people…and by that I mean over about 40… generally seem only to be exhausted and worried about their future and the future of their families. And no wonder…the country has been through a lot in the previous couple of decades.
A necessarily incomplete list follows:
The unmasking of Bill Clinton as a sexually obsessed fool, liar and neoliberal seller of the U.S. down the river to globalist corporate interests instead of a well-functioning president, the theft of the two Bush II presidencies backed…or at best passively accepted…by both parties, 9/11, the Iraq War, the hope offered by the growth of the digital info world and the taking over of that world by those same hostile, entirely self-interested globalist corporate forces, the continuing rise of wanton and mostly random violence in the country, the shipping out of much of the industrial economy to low-wage countries and the resultant economic breakdown in the late 2000s, the fall of the middle class, the decay of the country’s physical infrastructure, the shattering of thousands of years of widely accepted sexual…”preferences”…and the societies that were based on them, the unmasking of Barack Obama as a willing tool of the Permanent Government and its surveillance state instead of the fervently hoped-for “Peace President,” the rise of China as a more-than-just-competitive world power, Putin’s rise as essentially a hostile dictator controlling a serious military and nuclear arsenal and quite obviously angling for a return to power in Eastern Europe, the ongoing fracturing of the European Union, the success of terrorist tactics as societal disruptors, the whole refugee swarm that has resulted from those many factors and the societal changes that it has wrought, the changes in the climate and the threat of much worse changes to come, etc.
And then there was Trump, followed quite rapidly by the concept of false news and the misuse of social media as a propaganda weapon.
The cappers.
Talk about a “New World Order!!!”
The end result?
Sure.
Read on.
People are now mostly confused, especially people who have lived through this rapid, ongoing decline. They don’t know who to trust anymore…except of course for the Fox News addicts, who are by and large belligerent as hell in defense of Trump. At least they have something to trust, stupid though it may be. They’re stupid, too. You cannot eliminate the stupid from the human genome; you can only either attempt to control it or use it as a weapon…as has been the case with Trump and the Republican party.
And so here we jolly well are, aren’t we. Two Democratic presidents and two Republican presidents later…if of course Trump can be accurately labelled a “Republican”…still accelerating down the tubes.
It’s no wonder many people are not belligerent towards the bad actors on both sides of the UniParty aisle. They are too shell-shocked to be belligerent. Too frightened. Too fucking exhausted. Societally shell-shocked. Post Traumatic Stress Disorder on a national…possibly even global…level.
He also wrote:
I was expecting to see a much greater divide between blue and red. Instead, what I saw was a a class divide. Those with large bank accounts and diversified portfolios were less fearful, more sanguine about the fate of the Republic.
Yup.
“More sanguine about the fate of the Republic?”
No surprise there. “Republic” is the first part of the word “Republican,” and if nothing else, the Republicans have always taken care of the upper middle and wealthy classes. As long as they remain in the catbird seat, those with large bank accounts and diversified portfolios simply have less to fear than the rest of us.
Will this situation change?
I really don’t know. I used to think that it would; I used to think that the flow of evolution which has marked the entire history of life on earth would continue the way it has gone since time immemorial.
Intelligence, ever upward.
I’m not so sure anymore.
Maybe artificial intelligence is the next step in evolution. Or maybe a blend between human intelligence and AI-assisted intelligence.
Whatever.
I do know this:
Unless we get our shit together…and quickly…there is a serious reckoning approaching. It may be economic; it may be nuclear; it may be climate-driven or it may be a combination of all of those things plus other, heretofore unforeseeable events, but we can’t keep on the way that we are going without drastic consequences.
Hunker down, AngryTeacher. There’s more right around the next news cycle.
Bet on it.
AG
Arthur, while we will have to agree to disagree on some facets of politics, globalization and the place of the US in the world, I appreciate your taking the time to read my comments.
When I arrived in Booman’s little corner of cyberspace, it became clear that you are one of the lepers here. I have a feeling that I’m soon going to be another leper here – untouchable because I’m a bit of a contrarian. I question the orthodoxy of the right and the left.
You should expect that I will still call you out when I think you’re wrong, and I expect no quarter in the battle of ideas. Nevertheless, I generally find something to like in most of the souls I meet. In your case, it’s jazz.
When I was about 10, or 11, I heard Miles’ ’58 Sessions, and a homemade recording from Ronnie Scott’s in London, by various artists. For a kid in a small town in the Great Plains, it changed the arc of my universe. I’m no jazz expert – I just dabble enthusiastically.
I’m going to check your page again in the future – I’d love to see a weekend playlist, or a mention of some of your upcoming gigs.
Thanks for your comment. Peace.
I have sequestered my professional and musical life from my socio-political commentary life as much as possible, AngryTeacher. There are valid reasons for that, not the least of which being making a living as a working musician. I try to maintain a certain public…neutrality…as far as playing music for some sort of profit. Booman knows who really am, and I suppose maybe some others do too. Whatever. Not outted yet, and it’s probably not very important if I am outted or or not…one way or another…in my own life. But as long as I try to maintain this neutrality on a public level, I will remain behind my honored maternal grandfather’s name…Arthur Gilroy, the leftist son of a NYC Irish immigrant mayor, a good man who taught me how to read and think, and also radicalized me at his knee during the McCarthy hearings, long ago and far away.
This of course stops me from sharing my specific musical adventures on Booman Tribune. Suffice it to say that at about 13 years of age I heard Charlie Parker’s recording of KoKo…I remember it well…and before its intro was over I had already gone through through my own “arc of the universe” epiphany. That change has lasted throughout a long and successful career as a jazz and latin musician in NYC. Suffice it to say that I have played with damned near everyone in those idioms in NYC that needed my talents on my chosen instrument and as a teacher, composer and arranger.
Glad to meet another jazz lover.
We are all comparative lepers in today’s culture.
So it goes…
AG
My life changed at Minute 4:30 of this performance. Or more accurately, it changed in the ensuing minutes before the 10:09 mark.
Eventually, the video kicks in, and I was standing on the other side but with a similar perspective. Just turned 15, away from home at boarding school on a school trip organized by my English teacher.
For much better sound (with Phil Lesh’s bass audible), but no video: go here and play the first track.
It’s not an exaggeration to say that those five and half minutes completely reprogrammed my brain.
And of course there was much more to come…like tracks 7-19.
Deal with it.
None of us can change our genetically-established tendencies, Booman. You must deal with yours, I with mine. We can dye our hair, wear different color contact lenses, use makeup, wear wigs, lose or gain weight, but that’s about it. You hear…and react to…certain musics and so do I. So it goes.
Live and let live.
AG
P.S. I will say this, though. The oft-expressed hostility of many highly accomplished jazz musicians…especially black ones…to people who resemble the musical term “no-playing motherfuckers” but reap great fortunes and wealth is as understandable as is the general hostility of the black population towards white people. They feel as if they have been robbed. They’ve got a point, too.
For example…go listen to the white band that first recorded “jazz,” The Original Dixieland Jass Band. Now go listen to Louis Armstrong and Earl Hines playing Weather Bird as a duo, Armstrong’s recording of Struttin’ With Some Barbecue or any of Jelly Roll Morton’s masterpieces with Jelly Roll Morton & His Red Hot Peppers. The easily heard difference in basic musical competence…let alone musical brilliance…between The Original Dixieland Jass Band and the others I have mentioned is palpable. (Louis Armstrong and Jellyroll Morton were verifiable geniuses, bet on it. Also Fletcher Henderson and Duke Ellington, just for starters.) The Original Dixieland Jass Band is nothing much more than a hot mess, but they made money while the originators and masters continued to scuffle.
As the culture grew…with very few exceptions…black artists rarely made anywhere near the same money as white artists playing in styles that were originated by black musicians in black cultures. I like to call this “The Elvis Presley Syndrome,” myself, but Presley actually had some talent, although he threw it all away for cheap fame. Things got a little better during the Swing Era, but as soon as black “Rhythm and Blues” styles…really just a simplified jazz/blues hybrid for dancers…were found to be big sellers and Rock ‘n Roll was invented (say mid-’50s) the same process repeated itself.
American cultural history.
In black and white.
Don’t forget Pat Boone (is there anyone more white bread?) getting rich from black songs without even attribution.
Heard this one on PBS a decade or two ago.
You ask:
Yes.
Eddie Fisher.
I have on eyewitness account that Fisher was so time-challenged that in recording sessions they had to hire someone to stand with him in the recording studio and place his hand over Fisher’s mouth so that the fool didn’t come in at the wrong time in the arrangement.
This makes Pat Boone look like Charlie Parker in comparison!!!
Sad…
AG
Wow!
Then you’ve got to be down with Booker!
Hell, Booman oughta be down with Bayou Maharajah.
You think, therefore you are hated by the mindless bots.
. . . “mindless bot” or otherwise, “hat[ing]” on angry teacher or anything he’s ever written here.
(Prediction: yet again, you can’t, of course; because it’s never happened. Precisely because we think!)
Pretending that people who see through your and ag’s lies and bullshit don’t “think” makes for a “nice” evasion from Reality and responsibility for your words and actions, though!
(Go ahead, give me another LOL: troll rate this substantive critique and challenge . . . which you’ll predictably run away from.)
You write:
and:
“Substantive critique!!!???”
Wonderful.
Thank you.
Is there anyone left on this blog that does not see where this person is coming from?
ASG
Here it is again:
That’s what’s known as a “substantive critique and challenge” . . . among people who can read, and who aren’t dishonest, anyway.
Your bizarre misquotation via truncation is either very stupid or very dishonest . . . or both.
What could be less surprising?
Not that that was hard to foresee.
Was not referring to Angry teacher as the object of hate, but rather AG.
For an example of a hateful mindless bot, look in the mirror. Or do you not have a reflection?
. . . not mine!
For the record: in direct reply to angry teacher, you wrote
Your failures at scathing insults are always good for a belly laugh, though, so keep ’em coming!
. . . shit-detector test, considering that angry teacher had said, in the comment you (directly!) replied to
But, yeeaahh, you were talkin’ to ag, not angry teacher, when you wrote that! Yeeaahh, that’s it! That’s the ticket! (h/t Jon Lovitz, SNL)
One other observation. I find myself vacillating between more optimistic and more apocalyptic expectations for the future.
Anything that can’t go on forever… won’t. As I move through middle age, I find myself leaning more and more towards the apocalyptic view. The political, economic, and environmental challenges are too many for our fragile Republic to withstand.
On the other hand, large cities in the US had a tremendous manure problem 120 years ago. Someone must have said, “we’re going to drown in all of this shit!”
And then, in a generation, technological change removed most manure from city streets. On the other hand, fatalities from auto accidents increased. So, the disasters we’re expecting may not be the ones which finish off the species.
Peace.
Follow the Leader: Exploring American Support for Democracy and Authoritarianism
Liberalism? Forget it
Governing as (sort of) commercial service…