I’m not fond of comparing generations to make political points or to satisfy a desire to express frustration, so I don’t write about “The Greatest Generation” or make a habit out of bashing baby boomers or comparing Generation X unfavorably with Millennials. In our present circumstances, though, I think it can be inspiring to think about what other generations have lived through, if for no other reason than to remind us that things have been a lot more difficult in the past than they are now.
My father was fortunate to serve his time in the army in-between the Korean and Vietnam wars, but he certainly had colleagues who fought in both of those conflicts as well as World War Two. A close friend of his did the beach landing at Anzio and fought up Italy’s boot. I met a relative by marriage in the 1990’s who had done five beach landings in the Pacific, each of them as terrifying as the D-Day landing depicted in Saving Private Ryan. He came home and farmed in the flatlands of Minnesota, and I’m not sure I’ve ever met a tougher or more weathered individual. At one point, he survived for two days by playing dead on a Pacific Island while Japanese soldiers walked around bayoneting anyone who seemed to still be breathing. On the third day, the Marines showed up and rescued him while collecting their dead. Then he did three more landings.
My generation was spared these kinds of things. The main civil rights bills were all completed by 1968, a year before I was born, and the Vietnam War was completely over by the time I was six. The Supreme Court’s Roe ruling has been in effect since I was in my first year of nursery school. I did lose my job after the 9/11 attacks and suffered some losses and financial hardships during the Great Recession, but that’s nothing to compare to what my parents’ generation experienced growing up during the Great Depression.
As unpleasant as our political battles have been over the last thirty or forty years, they simply don’t compare to the Civil War or the battles to end American apartheid or the way the country absolutely came apart in the 1960’s. No one has been drafted to fight in our wars.
Older generations than mine endured much worse with less complaint and more fortitude, and I find myself having to remind myself of this whenever I feel worn down and exhausted. What’s really bothering me, when I stop and think about it, is that I thought these prior generations bequeathed to us something more stable and enduring. I resent that their hard work is being squandered, and I honestly resent having to do the kind of hard work I thought they had spared me.
It turns out, my generation will get its time in the barrel after all. And the younger generations won’t ever know the kind of relative peace and calm we enjoyed for most of our lives. What’s old is new again, and no one should kid theirselves that the battle will be shorter or easier this time around. It would be an excellent start to have a good midterm election, but that’s not guaranteed and it would only be a first step.
On climate alone, our children’s challenges will far exceed our own, and we’ll be fighting a 1920’s-era Supreme Court at every step along the way.
So, when you’re feeling shocked or fatigued and want to just check out, remember that you’ve had it comparatively easy up to now. The country has come apart more than once before, and so far the good guys have found a way to come out on top. This is a low point. With hard work, things start getting better from here.
Wise advice, even if one can quibble one way or another. Americans born after say, 1960, have had a pretty easy row to hoe compared to their predecessors, although two substantial economic collapses within a 10 year time-span is not nothing, nor is the absurd life-killing level of debt today’s kids have thrust upon them for no good reason whatsoever. Not to mention having to deal with a simply insane and deadly Gun Culture. But it’s not exactly being drafted and having to charge the heights of Fredricksburg under the rifle fire of slavers, or onto Omaha Beach under the machine gun sights of Nazis.
The challenges ahead will not include meaningful foreign expansionist militarism. Yes, Putin’s Poor-man Russian Empire will be constantly finagling and radicalizing some Russian Sudetenland from Ukraine or wherever. But it’s more likely that our zombie neocons and National Trumpalists will be the ones urging The Deplorables into illegal wars of aggression BY US against some pygmy nation or other–ala Bushco. Our battles will be restoration of civil and social rights and saving the climate and environment from Gun-nuts, American Talibaners and malignant resource-exploiting plutocrats. At some point the unsustainable fiscal position of a (supposed) financial powerhouse will also have to be addressed. There will also have to be some constitutional reforms, which have occurred after every meaningful social reform in American history.
Technically all that’s needed is the political de-legitimization and destruction of the thoroughly corrupt and anti-American Repub party (in whatever iteration it happens to be), as well as the illegitimate Trumper Court majority, Roberts’ Repubs. It’s a tall order but certainly one that is in theory manageable. A fly in the ointment is that medical advances will now keep conserva-turds like Justice Bart O’Boofer going until their 90s. This necessarily means the Court must either be substantially reformed or the resignations of the two (so far) Trumpites coerced.
The problem is that even if National Trumpalism can be shattered it will have consumed an enormous amount of wasted effort simply to return to the days of Jimmy Carter, politically. And as the routinely grim UN Report on Climate Change makes clear, time is most definitely not on our side. So a long-fought War Against Plutocrat Reaction, even if victorious, may well turn out to be Pyrrhic.
Fewer people will know what that moniker means, and there is no point in not rubbing the horrible reality directly in people’s faces. Plus, “Justice Bart O’Boofer” is a perfect oxymoron.
The groper wingnut Bart is now a justice of the Supreme Court, and one of the most powerful men in America. No reason not to make that absolutely clear in every instance. It’s another prominent badge of our national decay and abject failure.
. . . the title of “Justice” to either Bart or Gorsuch implies they legitimately hold that title, which they do not, so I refuse to apply it to either.
I was there for the 1960s; not real old, but I was there. There was strife and division and rioting and violence but I’m afraid it will pale in terms of what’s coming. Maybe it’s just the gloss of memory but the 60s weren’t that bad.
We are still seeing the rise of power and the breaking of the government. There is still a way to go before we see the worst of it.
I was in my twenties during the sixties. The open polarization and violence were worse then they currently are, but there were common media that cut across the divide. Minority party privileges and constitutional checks and balances, not always honored only in the breach, were there to provide more ballast and equilibrium. It’s the unseen supports for democracy, present then and missing now, that differentiate the eras. I don’t believe the times we’re in are uniquely bad, but I don’t think the bad times I’ve seen in my long life have prepared me for them.
Yep. I lived through it and today is much worse. No Fox, no Hate Radio, no social media. Disagreement but not toxic division like now. People were more moderate. There was more actual violence in the 60s.
I was there too and would not say it was less hateful or more moderate. Divisions were completely toxic. Today’s divisions grew out of those.
A veer back and forth between being a political science teacher freaking out and a history teacher who just wants to sigh and say, “Yeah, we’ve trod this road before.”
Anyway, here’s the musical accompanient to this post:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?reload=9&v=NIQ1NHa0g6A
A-fucking-men.
While your post did absolutely nothing to lift off a single ounce of the burden that I feel when I wake up every single day, it somehow managed to make me feel quite a bit better, by virtue of your stepping back and taking in the much larger perspective; thereby allowing me to reevaluate things from within the greater historical perspective.
Thank you for that, Martin.
Considering that we are fighting for 1776 principles right now, it’s pretty clear that the hard work is never over.
I almost feel like this is directed to me, since by June or July next year, I’ll be in Canada, with the goal of eventual citizenship.
Good luck!
thanks! I’m setting up an appointment with an immigration lawyer this week to make sure all my ducks are in a row and to outline the process. I’m very excited though: I found two excellent potential neighborhoods within 20 minutes of my family, and another about 30 minutes away.
When I was out canvassing this weekend I ran across a college student from Canada who wanted to help with the campaign here in my District, and who told me he was planning on becoming a U.S. citizen in the near future, after he finished college.
When I got home and told my wife about this, she looked at me with a puzzled expression, and asked, “Why would he want to do THAT”?
And I then wondered the very same thing.
Things were much worse during the Great Depression, where 25% of the workforce was unemployed, and people were marching in the streets of American cities to demand food.
But, people had a plan of action. Right now, there’s no plan of action. People don’t join things, so everybody talks online without getting anything actually done.
That could begin to change in a few weeks time. If Democrats can gain power in this election, they can begin to point out how they would govern differently. That can be an effective strategizing point.
But, we must understand that the S.Ct. will be totally against us every single step of the way. Every progressive piece of legislation will be declared unconstitutional. Every right wing strategy will be endorsed, no matter how obscenely undemocratic it is.
The right wing will suddenly love the S.Ct. and will talk pompously about “preserving our institutions” after attacking and delegitimizing the Courts for 40 years. THe media will talk about how terribly partisan the left is that they’re criticizing our wonderful institutions like the S.Ct.
It’s all terribly predictable. The 2016 election really did have terrible consequences that are impossible to undo piecemeal.
But, we’re going to have the option of radical change. That will be open to us and there will be radical change, because the population is not going to sit quietly and starve and go extinct. The problems society faces will be orders of magnitude worse than anything that exists now. And now the old established order is already breaking.
Well, the old order did nothing and will do nothing to prevent catastrophe and the collapse of civilization, so exactly what use was it? Neither Obama nor Hillary were going to do anything whatever serious about global warming. Trump merely refuses to even pretend to do anything and is fighting to make things
We will have to fight off fascism, which is the obvious default strategy for “conservatives” as order breaks down. But, we’ve had the Civil War and the Second World War as experiences. We managed to survive that.
We could survive this too, if we can gain some degree of power in the next 2 years. If Trump is re-elected then probably it’s time to think about emigrating.
“Neither Obama nor Hillary were going to do anything whatever serious about global warming.”
Then why is Trump undoing or trying to undo everything Obama did on the environment? And as far as emigrating, where to? Canada? Hard to get in unless you’re a certain age and have certain skills. And have you been paying attention to who’s getting elected in provincial elections lately there? And they have a national election next year and the Conservatives there are going the way of the Republicans. Stephen Harper was a POS and 3 years later the Cons are worse.
Excellent points. Obama was the first (and only) prez to take climate change seriously, and did what he could in the face of relentless and obdurate opposition by the loathsome Repub Congress. As for Canada, it apparently has embraced reckless exploitation of its high-cost tar sands, despite the universal warnings of the world’s climate scientists. It may as well be classed as just as climate denialist as TrumpAmerica. Canada also wantonly cuts its ancient boreal forests for the production of such valuable products as toilet paper. Both actions make saving the 11,000 year old stable climate much, much more difficult. Both the US and Canada were willing to sacrifice all to stop the Nazis, but save the climate, not so much.
Although I would note that Canadians were smart enough to get idiot “conservative” Americans to build the cross-country pipelines transporting the Canadian tar shit to refineries and foreign markets. Why take the environmental risks when you have braindead Americans who will take them just to make political points and checkmate the libs?
. . . forests to get at those tar sands. It’s a twofer!
I know we are in a fight for maintaining our health care coverage, but the sheer amount of diseases that plagued earlier generations that are a thing of the past is staggering. Antibiotics are a miracle. What we can do to keep premature babies alive now: astonishing. Trauma care. Mental health advances…think about what was considered mental illness 50 years ago: being gay. Women’s health care has advanced considerably now that doctors are finally believing women when they report symptoms.
A little known advantage we have in this county that our ancestors didn’t: There are no more locust swarms that consume everything in their path. That is one species extinction no one minds.
Weather prediction–being able to get out of the path of a hurricane is a big deal.
In many ways we have it better than earlier generations. One stark difference: baby boomers have always voted. That needs to change.
Sorry, that didn’t come out right. What needs to change is that younger generations need to vote in every election.
Agreed there. This is their future.
Actually, only the Rocky Mountain locust is extinct. There are many other species around the world that are very much thriving.
And while the world has seen amazing medical progress just in the last 70 years, a lot of that is going to be reversed due to mass starvation and diseases accelerated by climate change in the next 10 – 20 years.
. . . running low on steam, in part due to massive over-use, as more and more resistant strains evolve.
I met a relative by marriage in the 1990’s who had done five beach landings in the Pacific, each of them as terrifying as the D-Day landing depicted in Saving Private Ryan
It is one thing to learn history from the history books, and quite another to learn it from someone who was there.
I had a high school history class- way back when… and we were studying WWII. The day’s discussion was about dropping the atomic bomb on Japan and if that was the right thing for the United States to do. I think the class was somewhat divided, this being at the tail end of the cold war and and because our school had a pretty diverse population but the student body was definitely more on the give-peace-a-chance end of the spectrum.
Towards the end of class, our teacher said: “OK, thanks for all the great discussion. Let me tell you how I felt at the time…” We had no idea, but he happened to have been a marine participating in the island hopping campaign in the Pacific, with the end goal of invading Japan. He describe in graphic detail how awful and bloody the campaign was. At one point, he got assigned to body detail and had to go around, picking up mangled, unrecognizable remains for an entire day. The closer they got to Japan, the harder the Japanese fought and the more bloody each battle became. He said they knew nothing about the bomb until it was dropped, and he said to a man they were absolutely ecstatic that the bomb caused Japan to surrender, because they knew a final invasion of Japan would be an absolute bloodbath and the Japanese would have fought to the last man.
I have always felt lucky that I was of a generation that wasn’t thrust into the middle of a bloody military conflict. I think the closest I came to military service was when Carter reinstated registration for the draft after the Russians invaded Afghanistan (If only they were still stuck there now and not us…) which, unlike a lot of my friends, I never objected to because I knew that it was a purely symbolic act.
I’m grateful that I was able to get a really good, broad and diverse education that provided me with a great context about how our country got to where we are at now. At the same time, I never had expected things to go this wrong… I really didn’t. Sometimes I wonder if we haven’t slipped into an alternative universe that’s a complete opposite of how I thought our country would be at this point in time. Still, as you point out, the horror scale has been much higher in the past.
This essay provides startling testimony of and historical meditation on the incredible brutality of World War II.
I first discovered this essay here in oral form. This was a particularly well-chosen set of radio stories for the “This American Life” program at the end of September 2001.
It looks like you accidentally tagged some stuff on the end of your link to the essay, making the link non-functional.
Here is the link to the story.
Losing The War
That’s the one.
Thanks for the assist, Mike. Keep on doing what you’re doing, Brother.
Wow, that’s an astonishing essay — haven’t finished it yet, but this chillingly leapt out at me:
Having been born in 1963, I feel lucky. Was around to catch the very tail end of the idealism of the “60s. Witnessed the rise of cynicism that’s been with us ever since. Though this is not an inspiring time to be alive, it’s certainly convenient. Trump and the Republicans can get away with so much crap because most of us continue to live in lovely homes and drive nice cars. Hell, we watch football on smartphones.
I’m not sure where the future will take us. I hope we resist what Republicans are trying to create but only time will tell. Democracies do not typically survive forever. We may go through some very dark days, perhaps inoculated through it all by smart phones and 4g internet connections.
Mid 1960s here. Brought up with a sense of a future that was only going to get better. Yes there were problems, but there was this sense that they would be sorted out. I am now staring at a future my kids are inheriting now as they enter adulthood. Collectively we as a species managed to really make a mess of things. I don’t know how those who come after us fix it. The older I get, the more sleep I lose over that prospect.