Back in May, when BuzzFeed first broke the Moscow Trump Tower story, I wrote that just based on the lies Trump had told about his lack of business interests in Russia during the campaign, the news warranted impeachment and removal from office. In truth, however, I was also taking into account the obvious fact that Trump had been compromised by the Russians since they could have contradicted his disavowals of business interests at any time. I didn’t even consider the possibility that he had also suborned perjury on the matter before Congress. But, that’s what BuzzFeed is now reporting. It still needs to be confirmed, but if it’s true it is without question an impeachable offense.
President Donald Trump directed his longtime attorney Michael Cohen to lie to Congress about negotiations to build a Trump Tower in Moscow, according to two federal law enforcement officials involved in an investigation of the matter.
Remember that Michael Flynn lost his job as national security advisor because he was telling a story to the public and other members of the administration that the Russians knew not to be true. That opened him up to blackmail and other forms of coercion, and that’s the exact same problem Trump created for himself by signing a letter of intent to build a skyscraper in Moscow in October 2015 and then insisting all throughout the campaign in 2016 that he had no business with Russia. He couldn’t allow Michael Cohen to testify truthfully and it looks like he may have crossed a line and done it in a way that can be proven.
For starters, even though he’s not a very credible witness, Michael Cohen apparently says that Trump told him to lie to Congress.
Now the two sources have told BuzzFeed News that Cohen also told the special counsel that after the election, the president personally instructed him to lie — by claiming that negotiations ended months earlier than they actually did — in order to obscure Trump’s involvement.
Then there’s the fact that the special counsel’s office has reportedly assembled a lot of corroborating evidence.
The special counsel’s office learned about Trump’s directive for Cohen to lie to Congress through interviews with multiple witnesses from the Trump Organization and internal company emails, text messages, and a cache of other documents. Cohen then acknowledged those instructions during his interviews with that office.
We can try to rank the levels of concern about President Trump, but it should be beyond dispute that we can’t have a chief executive who is compromised by a foreign power. That’s a clear and present danger, and it’s even more serious than the possibility that he may have engaged in a criminal conspiracy with them to help him win the office. Directing someone to lie to Congress is probably next in line, and then we can talk about evidence of tax fraud, bank fraud, felonious campaign finance violations, and examples of graft, corruption, and criminal business practices.
In a way, though, Congress will have the hardest time shrugging off the suborned perjury. They can try to define some things as low crimes that don’t reach the impeachable standard, but they can’t allow a president to direct people to lie to them. At a minimum, they’d have to censure him. And that might be what would happen if a popular and competent president told his lawyer to lie to Congress, but this president is not popular and he is not competent. More importantly, censuring him over the perjury wouldn’t make the rest of the problems go away. How many times would they censure him, and for how many different reasons?
Trump is still holding onto the fact that his approval with Republican voters remains strong, but even that is slipping. And by pursuing an endless government shutdown to maintain that support, he’s quickly losing support among the Republicans in Congress.
Just consider, things look this bad for Trump and Mueller isn’t done indicting people. He hasn’t yet issued a report. The Democrats have not yet held a single hearing.
Do you want to place a bet that Trump will survive?
Certainly this is a watershed moment on many levels. That this cache of information was tapped into many months ago and stayed out of the media’s eye points to people wanting to get out of the way of what they now perceive as a failed presidency which Congress can’t protect. The WH lawyers who counseled or worked with Cohen to prepare his testimony are on the hook for this one with Trump.
And once again we learn that Mueller’s team was here first and yet they’ve held those cards as they built what surely will look 10x worse than Watergate.
So Trump sold his soul, his country, his fortune and his family for a $300 million tower in Moscow. Bets that Putin didn’t put something else into the kitty?
When do we get to the High Crimes and Misdemeanors part of this episode?
What is the bet?
I don’t quite see how Trump will be taken down!
The whole Republican party, or what is left of it, is going down with this shipwreck. They are more afraid of being primaried from the right than standing up for our Constitution. Otherwise the evidence for high crimes is deafening already!
I think till the polls show clearly that even amongst the self declared Republicans (not the MAGA fanatics) that Trump’s support is going down, the Senate Rs will continue to bury their heads in the sand, and hope that once again US electorate will have a short memory span. But the longer the shutdown goes on, the less likely they can hold out.
So perhaps it will be the shutdown and its attendant pain that will break this fever?
Well how about that?
Every new day DOES get worse in America.
Update: Special counsel breaks silence on Buzzfeed bombshell report Cohen
I know it will be unpopular to say this, but I’m still not quite convinced that Trump is an asset or whatever of Putin.
However, there’s mountains of evidence of other high crimes and misdemeanors that he’s engaged in.
A lot of Republicans love to hand wave away the campaign finance chicanery with the usual “both sides! both sides!” arguments.
The level of emoluments evidence grows daily, along with a host of other issues, concerns and crimes.
However, I seriously doubt the Republicans will do one damn thing to deal effectively with it. As it is, they are STILL getting everything they ever wanted (sans the Wall, which they really don’t give a stuff about other than as a sop to their idiotic racist base) and more, especially in terms of ruining the agencies, destorying our environment, and repealing regulation upon regulation. Plus: Tax Cuts for the Mega Wealthy (my taxes increased) and the SCOTUS, and they’re happy as little clams.
Even if no collusion – just saying – is ever proven with Russia, Trump’s been a disaster, but not as far Republicans are concerned. They’re happy as clams.
I don’t expect Trump to be impeached, and sadly, there’s still a darn good chance he’ll win again in 2020, as sickening as that is. The rightwing propaganda wurlitzer is just that strong.
Perish the thought, but there you have it.
I’ve been skeptical of Republicans turning on Trump this side of an economic meltdown. But I’m beginning to see the possibility. His support is slipping because of the damage he’s doing to the economy in various ways, the shutdown being only the most obvious.
Bush was popular until he wasn’t. Could be similar for Trump. A sudden erosion of support and then they’ll all claim he was never a Republican. In fact, we’re hearing those whispers already.
So many theories popped up last night after Mueller’s office pushed back on the BuzzFeed article. But that pushback isn’t a reason to throw up our collective hands and declare that this was a terrible day for the media.
A moment to slow down and process, yes, and that’s a good thing.
What we do know is that Cohen lied to Congress, because he admitted it in court. We know that Trump has included in his litany of lies, lies about all things Moscow Tower. We know he has had any number of enablers to his lies within the WH, including Eric Jr who just might be on the hook for lying about the Moscow Tower to Congress as well.
So BuzzFeed’s sources may have misinformed them on the logistics or resources that Mueller had in hand but I’m thinking that the core of the article was solid. At this point, there’s bound to be more and more information being flushed out of this cesspool and Mueller has got to be walking a fine line to preserve the integrity of his team and their findings. So, beware media, this is going to get hot.
Agreed. Even a cursory reading of the Mueller statement can’t be interpreted as a dispute of the entire story. And last night Buzzfeed editors are standing by the story. Even Cohen is saying Trump told him to lie, and I don’t believe, given he’s been convicted of lying to congress already, and given his current “relationship” with Trump, that he’d have any reason to not tell the truth.
There may be some details in the story that might not be correct, and I can see why Mueller’s office might want to push back on that as it may have the affect of calling into question the validity of the report they will ultimately produce. But if the story was completely bogus I would imagine Mueller’s office would have put out a much stronger and forceful statement refuting the entire story.
You write:
I dunno, csm.
Friday Cohen was widely covered as he returned to his home with a black eye, his arm in a sling and…frankly…looking scared shitless.
Yeah.
Right.
Maybe…
But if we look at this ongoing anti-Trump war as a conflict between major gangs…MAJOR major gangs, including various U.S. intelligence systems, its military and Russia as both a gang power and as a major, mafia-dominated system…Cohen would have many reasons not to tell the truth. He’d have to choose his poisons very carefully.
Wouldn’t he.
Later…
AG
Indeed, and I believe it will be politically fatal for a democratic congress to let Trump suborn perjury by doing nothing because 67 senators, yadda, yadda.
What may seem to be the “practical” democratic position, e.g. no point in going forward with impeachment until there are enough GOP senators on board for conviction, in a sense validates the intransigence of the republicans in refusing to set partisanship aside and act in the interest of the Constitution and nation and convict a president clearly in violation of the high crimes and misdemeanors bar.
The net effect of that is, “we” agree with these partisan republicans, albeit for somewhat different reasons, that Trump should not be held accountable. The danger is this is how it will be seen by those voters who rose up out of frustration in 2018 with Trump getting away with everything and voted in democrats to hold him accountable. Only to find in the end that, democrats, just like the GOP are more interested in political fortunes than doing what’s right.
And that feeling will become even more intense as Trump bumbles along, with damn near every day bringing some new breaking news of yet another thumbing of his nose at the law without consequence. Its already become even more acute with the shut down bearing down on people beyond the directly affected government employees.
And while House investigations will bring out information, I am concerned the democrats re going to half-step on that as well, judging by the decision now to not make going after Trump’s tax returns a priority.
The nightmare scenario: what if Mueller produces his report and its kept from the public, democrats don’t impeach and the visibility of the House investigations are at the level of CSPAN? Trump will reach 2020 with zero consequences for what he’s done. Voters who came out in 2018 to put democrats in to do something will not be happy.
Instead, impeach regardless of what the GOP is willing to do in the senate. Lay bare all of Trump’s and his family’s crimes in devastating, public detail. Then dare the GOP not to convict, and put the responsibility on them. Sure, their base may cheer them on, but who beyond them are going to believe Trump when he declares victory at that point? And who beyond them are going to believe Mitch McConnell at that point, and NOT see him as an accomplice and co-conspirator with a criminal president? And if they hold out and don’t convict, at the very least the voters will see that (a) democrats did exercise their constitutional duty to hold Trump accountable; (b) republicans are not acting as legislators in the interest of the people but protectors of Trump to shield their own complicity and (c) the GOP is as much if not more than the problem, than Trump.
The don’t impeach because 67 senators crowd seems to be thinking again that the GOP, even in its weakened state, will make the democrats pay a price with the public beyond the GOP base if they impeach and there is no conviction. There’s plenty utility in impeachment alone, which is why they’re trying to scare us off from it. Its another con, and its sad to see so many have fallen for it.
You write:
Yeah.
Well…
Publicly, the ruling Dems are saying that this set of half-step decisions is based on political pragmatism.
Could be, I guess, although your position of “Impeach the motherfucker. NOW!!!” also carries politically pragmatic possibilities.
But what if that Dem half-step pragmatism is only a media-promulgated whitewash?
What if discussions are already ongoing between an already trapped Trump, one who holds information cards that would prove decisive criminality…of any sort…amongst his strongest enemies?
What then?
Then the whole “half-step” routine…which has been drip-drip-dripping along now for the better part of two years…becomes much more understandable.
Trump:
What then!!!???
A deal, probably.
He stays, refuses to run in 2020…”I did my job, motherfuckers!!!”…and retires to a life of wealth and privilege.
Could happen…
If fiction wasn’t as good as dead in this Post-Truth world, that’s the novel I’d write.
Watch.
Later…
AG