When I wrote How a Trump Emergency Declaration Became the Mother of All Headaches, I explained how the Senate Republicans stumbled into the situation they now face where they’re on the brink of losing a vote in a chamber they control. Senate Majority Whip John Cornyn of Texas is already resigned to defeat, “I didn’t want it to come to this, because I think it’s probably going to get tied up in court. And I said it wasn’t a practical solution…All it takes is four right? You can do the math as well as I can.”
When Sen. Cornyn says, “It only takes four,” he means that if four Senate Republicans vote for a resolution overturning Trump’s emergency declaration then it will pass, assuming all the Democrats and the two independent also vote ‘yes.’ There are already three GOP senators on the record with an intention to approve the measure: Susan Collins of Maine, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, and Thom Tillis of North Carolina.
Sen. Tillis went so far as to write an opinion piece for the Washington Post explaining his decision. Here’s the key part of his argument:
Conservatives rightfully cried foul when President Barack Obama used executive action to completely bypass Congress and unilaterally provide deferred action to undocumented adults who had knowingly violated the nation’s immigration laws. Some prominent Republicans went so far as to proclaim that Obama was acting more like an “emperor” or “king” than a president.
There is no intellectual honesty in now turning around and arguing that there’s an imaginary asterisk attached to executive overreach — that it’s acceptable for my party but not thy party.
Republicans need to realize that this will lead inevitably to regret when a Democrat once again controls the White House, cites the precedent set by Trump, and declares his or her own national emergency to advance a policy that couldn’t gain congressional approval.
Because the declaration of disapproval will pass the Democratically-controlled House of Representatives on Tuesday and is a privileged resolution authorized by the National Emergencies Act, the Senate is compelled to bring it up for a vote within fifteen days.
There is a flaw in the law, though, because the president is allowed to veto Congress’s disapproval. No one is yet predicting that there will be enough Republican defections in either the House or Senate to sustain a veto override attempt. As a result, the main tangible effect of Congress passing the resolution will be to add heft to judicial challenges to the emergency declaration.
Nonetheless, the debate is roiling Republican unity in Congress. Opposition is widespread, but the appetite for taking Trump on is weak.
Numerous Senate Republicans say that, like Tillis, they despise Trump’s decision to declare a national emergency to get additional funding for his wall. But most aren’t ready to say they will vote to block him from doing so.
Interviews on Monday with more than a dozen GOP senators who have been publicly critical of Trump’s unilateral maneuver or warned him not to deploy it were cagey about their intentions for what would be a crucial vote in coming weeks on the Senate floor…
…Some Republicans still privately expect the resolution to pass the Senate, but there was little enthusiasm to get out in front of a conflict with the president.
As I wrote previously, the Republicans welcomed this emergency declaration because it gave them a way to avoid overriding a presidential veto so that they could reopen the government. But that only delayed their day of reckoning. What they’re going to do now is the absolute worst of all worlds. First they’re going to rebuke the president and then they’re going to fail to override his veto and hand him control of their pursestrings. They won’t avoid one of the toughest votes they’ll ever face, and they won’t defend their own power and prerogatives. They won’t stand with Trump, but they’ll still defer to him. And then they’ll hope that the courts side with them against Trump, thereby defeating Trump’s efforts to build a wall on the border with Mexico with American tax dollars.
They deserve this fate, but they also deserve the contempt they will get from every single quarter for their cowardice and lack of principle.
“They deserve this fate, but they also deserve the contempt they will get from every single quarter for their cowardice and lack of principle.”
The “party of values” have none, haven’t had any for decades and won’t discover any any time soon. They pay no price for this. There is no incentive for them to change. Empty suits fiddling while the world burns…
Its’ going to take a miracle for them to change…don’t hold your breath.
Well, they are going to pay a price for this. Senators like Cory Gardner are twisting in the wind. In Colo., the GOP base are wing-nuts extraordinaire, with a special bit of crazy sauce. They love Trump, and hate anybody who stands against him.
So, incentive for Gardner to side with Trump. But, Independents HATE Trump “with an H, because he’s Horrid” and Gardner won election by winning a plurality of them in 2014. Like many other states, the GOP base isn’t enough to win election, they need independents.
Therefore he has carefully crafted an image of being “bipartisan”, carefully masking his right wing voting record. This blows up that carefully crafted image sky high. He now has to take a very public vote, either to enable Trump’s power grab the way the base wants him to, or else oppose Trump in hopes of wooing Independents, but infuriate the crackpot right.
He’s expected to vote against the President, but then vote to sustain Trump’s veto, thus pathetically attempting to split the difference. But, how pathetic is this waffling? It’s unlikely to make him more popular in CO and will subject him to withering contempt and outrage and accusations of weakness, etc.
From voters who voted for him before. Everything Martin said about this is true: its a bad own goal for Republicans, putting them in a lose-lose situation.
I hate to sound so defeatist but I’ll believe it when I see it. There’s no escaping the fact that 63M Americans voted for Trump and continue to support him despite what any rational person would see as abhorrent and immoral behavior.
Things really need to deteriorate to the point the these people are physically feeling the discomfort of their decisions and then even that assumes they are not so brainwashed that they understand the cause and effect. I can see no evidence that this will happen any time soon.
I think you’re missing the point Martin is making. It’s not a question of whether GOP Senators are going to vote to sustain Trump’s veto: they are. The question is “what price will they pay?”
And in most states that price will be VERY HIGH. It’s going to probably cost them seats in the Senate, because, at the state level and outside a few reactionary states like MS, AR, TN, WY, ID, they need independents, not just Republicans to win statewide election. There aren’t enough Colorado Republicans to elect Gardner against any decent Dem. candidate.
They are being forced to take a very public vote on an issue where 2/3 of the public hate the decision and think it’s a blatant power grab by the President, and they don’t support the move, even if they think maybe the wall is needed.
That’s bad folks. Senators hate making symbolic votes on issues where they can’t accomplish anything, but still take a beating. That’s exactly what Trump is forcing them to do, because of his own ego and no other reason.
Oh, I get the point – I just have no faith in our electorate at the moment. As per Martin’s latest post – the Republicans think their voters are morons. And since 1980 they’ve been right. Why would that change now?
. . . Banana Republicans in similar situations who’ve similarly painted themselves into similar corners and . . .
. . . I like it! In fact “my cup runneth over with [schadenfreude]” as a result!
As a result of a discussion on a blog where I posed the question of whether the percentage of Republicans still supporting Trump is based on declining Republican registration and thus a smaller number of real voters, I decided to go to the latest registration numbers for Colorado (Feb 1 2019) and found the following: Unaffiliated 38%, Democratic 30%, Republican 28% and 5 other parties 4%.
Cory’s going to need a huge chunk of unaffiliated voters to win re-election. From what info I have on my county, unaffiliated voters tend to vote Democratic more often than Republican and many are left of the mainstream Democratic Party.
That is why the GOP got crushed in Colorado in the 2018 elections. Suburban women and Independents abandoned them in droves. Neither party can win election in CO without Independents, and the GOP embrace of Trump has caused massive defections to the Dems.
There is no reason to think that CO will be a swing state in 2020.
The original National Emergency bill didn’t allow for a veto, but that piece was overturned by the Supreme Court because the 2/3 majority to override a veto is in the Constitution. Congress should have cancelled the whole law for that part being unseverable.
The GOP is not weak or lacking in principles. They are a strong majority/minority opposition party. They do not believe in any role for government, thus making it impossible to agree within the party to move any policy forward. They have no DACA policy, no healthcare policy, no trade policy, no energy policy, no education policy, no immigration policy, no abortion policy. They gave everything to the donald and he issues EO signed with a magic marker. I have always expected the hear a beep beep when the donald turns to EO around for photos. That beep beep you hear when clowns want to accent some part of their act.
WTF was Mitch McConnell thinking supporting Trump on this?! As Senate Majority leader, one would think he would jealously guard his congressional power rather than cede it to this dangerous imbecile.
I guess not. And I guess he’s not nearly as smart, or Machiavellian, as he’d like to think he is. Instead, he comes across as weak and craven — which, of course, he is.
The damage McConnell has done to constitutional norms and the rule of law in our country is incalculable.
He doesn’t care about anything but tax cuts, packing the courts with right wing bigots and protecting his majority in the Senate.
The Constitution and separation of powers means less than nothing to him. But, this still doesn’t help Republicans. He can spin as much as he wants, this is Trump slapping the GOP Senators in the face.
First he signaled he would support the clean budget resolution without Wall funding. Then Trump got criticized by Fox News bigots. Then he switched and demanded wall funding. Then he shut down the government for over a month dragging their polling #s down. Then they had to endure more wrath from the useful idiots in the base, then they had to cave and vote to reopen the government with less wall funding than Democrats offered originally.
Now they are forced to vote on the emergency declaration which is widely unpopular in their states. Then, after the de-certifying resolution passes, they have to vote again to sustain Trump’s veto.
All this is going to be used against them in 2020 and beyond. And they got exactly NOTHING out of it. NO wins, not even a tie.
Trump gets his emergency, they get criticized from both sides as corrupt useless tools, or obstructionist “Deep Staters”. Either way they lose.
Is it truly hell for them if they can’t overturn the veto? All they have to do is sit back and hope the court overturns it for them? Cowardly? Yes. Hell? Probably not.