(aka The Helping Instapundit Project) Last week, the U.N. issued its annual top 10 list of under-reported stories. As might be expected, U.S. media have ignored the list.
I have a proposition for you: Let’s cover all 10, every day, for the next 10 days. Sign up as a story author. More below, including the story list sign-up status:
At the United Nations Web site — “Ten Stories The World Should Hear More About” — in the right column, you’ll find links to each story. Select one that interests you or about which you have some expertise. (However, I like picking stories about which I’m pretty ignorant, because then I learn something new.)
Choose a story and share below, or send me an e-mail at susanhu at earthlink dot net.
More on the stories from IPS, one of the few agencies to cover the U.N.’s list:
The solution: “Shoot him.” The problem:
”My prime minister is going to address the U.N. General Assembly on major social and economic issues crucial to the survival of Africa. How can I get the story in to the New York Times,” Vittachi recalled the man said.
”Shoot him, and you will get a front-page story,” replied Vittachi, a onetime columnist for ‘Newsweek’ magazine and legendary newspaper editor in his home country of Sri Lanka.
Vittachi’s had long argued that most Western media rarely provided in-depth coverage of issues such as poverty, hunger, maternal mortality, and debilitating diseases plaguing more than two-thirds of the U.N.’s 191 member states. These issues just weren’t ”sexy” enough for most newsrooms, he said. …
The stories:
Also overlooked, he said, were: the scant chances for small farmers in Cameroon and other poor countries to get a fair price for their produce; Grenada’s struggles to recover from the devastation of Hurricane Ivan, a story forgotten in the wake of the Asian tsunami; continuing violence against women; using development as an effective alternative to warfare to curb illicit drugs; and saving the environment to preserve potential cures for a catalogue of diseases.
Issues for the media — and this is one we face at Booman too. What will “sell”? What will you read? How can we make it interesting?
”Our counter-argument would be that the audience will become interested if the stories are written in a persuasive way that showcases their relevance,” Tharoor added.
What sells is highly debatable, he argued, as is the notion that only violence and scandal make for news.
”Why should the Asian tsunami be more newsworthy than the victims of Hurricane Ivan in Grenada? Why isn’t the horror of fistula caused by childbirth of interest to every woman in the world — and every man, too, since we are all produced by childbirth?” he asked.
Update [2005-5-9 14:3:31 by susanhbu]:
Story list so far:
Tuesday: Sirocco on Uganda
Wed: Susanhbu on Cameroon
Thurs: ?
Fri: ?
Sat: Ask on Somalia
Sun: ?
Mon: ?
Tues: ?
Wed.: Nanette for women’s health
Thurs: ?
(that’s 10 stories, if I can count)
PLEASE SIGN UP BELOW! Here’s the U.N.’s list of stories from which you can choose. Pick the one that suits you, if it hasn’t been taken.
Thanks for this apt initiative!
I can do northern Uganda – in fact I have a half-finished thingy on that which I should have completed long ago.
Fabulous. Just let me know when you’re ready to go so we can coordinate the release — do a press release — actually just so we don’t have 5 stories on the same day, but spread them out.
Can’t wait, Sirocco. Since you’re half done already, you might go first.
Can’t make it today. But tomorrow or any day after that. I tend to need a deadline.
Tomorrow. Is my tomorrow your tomorrow? I mean, I’m PDT in Washington state … oh well. Details. Whenever! Can’t wait.
Sure, we have the same tomorrows… May 10.
I am focusing on the war with the LRA and addressing the humanitarian situation in that context. Hope that is OK?
Go for it.
It’d be great if you could draw on the U.N. site’s storyline at the top of your piece…. for the sake of continuity of the project.
No problemo.
great idea Susan. All the news that’s (seen as not) fit to print. Soj has pretty much made this her life’s work. And it’s rewarding.
On the point, above, about the hurricane in Grenada versus the tsunami, I have to defend the media. That tsunami was one of the most unique weather events in modern history. It was a bigger story than ANY hurricane.
It just occurred to me that each person likely has
their own list.
Tsunami vs Grenada hurricane seems to be ‘confusing orders of magnitude’ – 200,000 dead and missing from the tsunami and 40 dead from the Granada hurricane. Numbers make it a bigger story, but one story should not obliterate the other.
it’s not just the numbers of dead though. It’s the fact that a tsunami of that size had not occurred in over 120 years.
Anything that rare is a big story just for its rareness.
But you’re right that other stories should not be ignored when bigger stories occur.
I’ll be willing to work on the Somalia-story.
As I may be even more of a procrastinator than Sirocco, it would not be posted until coming weekend.
As I may be even more of a procrastinator than Sirocco
That would be like crushing Tiger Woods in golf.
Year of practise. Many years.
Fantastic. I will bring up my trusty little Mac calendar and note you for the weekend.
Keep me posted, will you? Thanks!
P.S. I’m a great believer in procrastination. It’s amazing how some problems solve themselves simply by not acting on them.
As we get assignments, I’ll note them + the promised date in an update to this story.
The sneering backlash over some of the trivia that is being reported and highlighted and focused on for days on end is indicative of massive dissatisfaction with what the media is presenting.
MediaChannel.org
Watching for the issues that are not being reported is as important as countering the propaganda that is being dished out.
So, which story are you signing up for? 🙂
the list that were under reported, Human Rights in Burma and Women’s Health,
one diary here and one on DKos.
The thing is, I am trying to quit blogging in order to
spend more time on my art work but every time I check on
this Froggie blog I find something very interesting
and can’t keep my mouth shut/my fingers still. Someone,
please hide my keyboard so I can go into “read-only” mode.
Looking forward to coverage of Human Rights in general.
May I take this opportunity to highlight the 3 countries that
voted NO on the recent UN resolution on human rights violations
by multinational corporations:
USA, Australia and South America.
After Bolton gets to the UN it will require an entire
blog just to watch his human rights violations, both ‘up
close and personal’ and global.
I think you mean South Africa.
This is a wonderful thing to get stories out there that are not usually covered, or barely covered. I rarely use slang, but the only thing that covers this is… “You rock, Susan!”. If the people who take on the articles are agreeable, I’ll put them up too, under a “BooMan Tribune Columnist” type thing (real names, pen names or nicknames are fine for bylines).
I am slowly making contact with the CONIPRAT people, thanks greatly to the help and guidance of Melanchthon, about the genital mutilation thing. I will take on the “Tragic blindspot in women’s health” one, as that is related, unless someone already is. I am an even worse procrastinator than Sirocco and ask, so I will say beginning of next week, as that will give CONIPRAT time to reply and get all the translations done and all that, and see what we come up with.
A suggestion… there are many journalism tools out there in the big wide world of the internets for investigating things, gathering information, etc. Even if we don’t have the BooTrippedia yet, we can start listing sources we come across in a diary somewhere (this one maybe?), to be added to the pedia later.
Well done 🙂
THANK YOU! I only have two stories so far.
Tuesday: Sirocco on Uganda
Wed: ?
Thurs: ?
Fri: ?
Sat: Ask on Somalia
Sun: ?
Mon: ?
Tues: ?
Wed.: ?
Thurs: ?
Fri: ?
(that’s 10 stories, if I can count)
Only two Norwegians on this board (AFAIK).
And there they are, on Susan’s list.
Who should we shame into action… 😉
What does THAT say?! Thank you, both of you. I need to sign up for one too.
But, if we don’t get more people, it’s kind of a lame duck kinda idea.
You’ll get more people, some are just not here yet. Ductape will probably give you the entire article in a comment, once he gets here ;). (I wish such clear, concise and entertaining writing came so easily to me. Or came to me at all, for that matter).
You probably will have to repost this at different hours of the day, as it’s falling down the page.
Put me down for next Weds for the Women’s health story. That’ll give me time to hear from CONIPRAT, and the rest of the back and forth, and also to research the health issue. And try and present it in a way that doesn’t turn people off, lol.
Okay, I’m doing “Cameroon: Farming in the Dark.” I haven’t got a snigle clue about the story, but that’s what search engines are for. Besides, the U.N. site has almost al the info we need!
I’ll do it for Wednesday. That gives other volunteers more time.
I’m estimating, if people use the U.N. page’s info primarily, the story shouldn’t take more than 1/2-1 hour to do.
For the “Tragic blindspot in women’s health”, (from the UN site) for Wednesday of next week. I don’t want someone to take my spot! I’m very partial to Wednesdays, you see.
Well, as long as they are a week or more away.
One problem is that several of the UN “News Stories”, like the increase in Human rights organisations, violence against women, drugs growing reduction and the affect of environmental changes on health, are very broad. As such I would think they would be covered as in-depth features rather than as “news”. Individual aspects like the reduction in opium output or say when a report or intiative on domestic violence is covered.
Maybe because the only selling the BBC has to do is to get people to watch, listen or read its web site, it has covered virtally all of the specific stories. I list below the relevant stories that have appeared on the BBC news site recently. As you may be aware, most of the stories on this site have also appeared on radio or TV. In a couple of cases I have referenced non-news programmes where the story has been covered.
Somalia
In depth coverage from a sub-site at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/in_depth/africa/2004/somalia/default.stm
Female Fistula
4/1/2005 http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/4214629.stm
10/8/2004 http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/3727756.stm
6/10/2004 http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/3817009.stm
(In addition this has been reported on Radio 4 in “Women’s Hour”)
Uganda conflict
13 stories on BBC news site in 2005
Sierra Leone
10 news stories on BBC site in 2005
Special sub-site at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/in_depth/africa/2000/sierra_leone/default.stm
Cameroon
Latest story yesterday regarding Nigeria failure to pull out of disputed area.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/4537611.stm
UN singles out Cameroon farming as unstable due to uncertain prices. Much covoerage of the work of the Commission for Africa has centred on fair trade.
Grenada
4/2/2005 Report on progree five months after hurricane
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/4215917.stm
Popular BBC1 TV show “Holiday” examined the recover of the tourism industry 15 weeks after the hurricane.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/holiday/destinations/caribbean/
If the comments about the non-coverage of stories say anything about the media, it may not be that they ignore stories because there is no demand to read them. I would suggest that it is rather they have cut costs so they do not have the reporters on the ground to provide in depth reporting.
Hi Susan,
I work in infectious diseases research and would like to explore the topic of Environment and health: New insights into the spread of infectious diseases, but I would want a bit of time to organise the diary. I have never done a diary before and I am quite busy with work, and if I didn’t say so before, I have never done a diary before. If you think that about 2 weeks (erm, possibly even a bit more time) would not be a big problem, I would like to sign up.