I’ve noted before that the Senate Republicans saw Brett Kavanaugh’s controversial confirmation to the Supreme Court as a way of protecting their majority even though they knew it would simultaenously hurt their party’s chances of holding onto the House. How it hurt and how it helped depends on which constituency you are looking at, but nowhere was it more helpful than in statewide elections in red states. One of those states is Ohio, where the Democrats are trying to take over the governor’s mansion and get Sherrod Brown reelected to the Senate. The reason Kavanaugh worked for the GOP in Ohio is because a lot of the Obama-Trump Democrats just simply do not care about issues like the #MeToo movement.
David Betras, the chairman of the Mahoning County Democratic Party, said liberal social causes “can’t be a centerplate issue’’ for Ohio Democrats, and preached a focus on pocketbook fare instead. “Most voters,” he said, “don’t give a whit one way or the other” about the former. (He did not say “whit.”)
You can see some of the Kavanaugh effect in Tennessee, too.
In Tennessee, Republican Marsha Blackburn has overtaken former Democratic Gov. Phil Bredesen. In the new poll, 49% back Blackburn, 45% Bredesen. That reflects a reversal since a mid-September CNN poll found Bredesen with a five-point edge over Blackburn.
Men and independents are now less apt to say they support Bredesen, with the Democrat’s backing among men dropping from 42% in September to 36% now. Among independents, Bredesen has gone from 54% support in September to 47% now.
It’s not just that these voters lack a sympathetic ear for women who claim to be victims of sexual assault. They also tend to have little patience for complaints about racism or police misconduct, and they’re sympathetic to the president’s hardline stance on immigration. That’s why Trump is running a nakedly racist advertisement at the close of the campaign.
Robert Verbruggen at the National Review makes an implausible case that the president’s ad isn’t an appeal to racism at all, but he’s probably not wrong when he says this, “I wonder if part of the thinking behind the ad was to goad liberals into making racism accusations that the GOP base would find ridiculous.”
I’d only dispute that we’re talking strictly about the GOP base. Trump is trying to hold onto the voters he poached from Obama, but many of them have been coming home to the Democrats, especially in the Midwest. If Trump can goad the Democrats into getting off message and talking about “social issues” rather than bread-and-butter stuff like health care and jobs, then he’s going to do better holding onto his Democratic voters.
The problem is that this kind of politics only works on a narrow band of voters, and it does real damage with a broader set of people who will decide the House elections. Going full racist at the close here might help the Republicans beat Phil Bredesen in Tennessee or win the governor’s race in Ohio, but it’s making it just a little more difficult for countless Republican candidates who are already endangered.
And when Paul Ryan complains about it, Trump just tells him to screw himself.
Paul Ryan should be focusing on holding the Majority rather than giving his opinions on Birthright Citizenship, something he knows nothing about! Our new Republican Majority will work on this, Closing the Immigration Loopholes and Securing our Border!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) October 31, 2018
The Democrats have to be smart about this. They can’t act like Pavlovian dogs and respond exactly how they’re expected to respond. If they stay on message, Trump’s last-second gambit may well fail, and we definitely don’t want to see this kind of politics rewarded.
This is merely a preview of the 2020 campaign which will be Turnip going full James Eastland mode. He is trying out themes he can run on, much more than he’s trying to hold onto the Senate. Frankly, I doubt it helps him much at all. These Senate races in red states were going to break towards the GOP anyway baring some unforeseen incident.
It might have helped him in Nevada. But, I never believed for one moment that a Democrat could win in Tennessee or Texas unless the GOP nominated a known pedophile like they did in Ala. Apparently, being a pedo is a “bridge too far” for maybe 10% of Alabama voters, enough to tilt that election.
It will be interesting if they really retain the Ohio Governor’s race or pick up any unexpected Senate seats. Heidi Heitkamp might have lost because of Kavanaugh, but clearly she was going to lose anyway if she was polling down by nearly double digits in many polls. 538.com has her down 5.2%, outside the margin of error. That sinks the Dems’ chances of winning the Senate which were never higher than 32% in the 538 rolling average.
If Trump hadn’t decided to help out Ted Cruz, Beto might conceivably have won Texas, but again he’s never led in any poll, except a 2% lead in an Ipsos online poll September 11. It’s unclear looking at the Texas polling that Trump had any impact at all.
Trump started his fall campaign with racists attacks and smear campaigns back in September. So, looking at the data this year prior to September the polling looks like this:
Cruz: +8, +3, +7, +6, +12, +11, +6, +5, +10, +9, +2, +6, +4, +4, +1. He’s averaging about a 5% lead prior to September.
Since then the race has barely changed to where it is now in the 538 rolling average – 51.7% to 46.7% – around 5%.
That’s about exactly where you would expect a Texas senate race between an oily, unappealing Republican whom virtually everybody who knows him hates, and a young charismatic Democrat. There just aren’t enough Texas voters willing to give any Democrat a chance to enable him to win.
So, outside of rhetoric, where is the “Trump effect?” I just don’t see it.
We’ll have to look at the Governor’s races and the Florida Senate race to see if Turnip’s racist attacks had any effect whatsoever. It might well be that he gets the GOP base to turn out when they might not have. OR it might be they were already going to do so because of Kavanaugh. Or it might be that it had no effect except to excite people on both sides who were always going to vote exactly as they did.
I had the impression that a large turnout of the female African-American vote gave the margin needed for the win in Alabama senate race.
http://www.vox.com/identities/2017/12/13/16772012/alabama-election-black-women/
The AA voter turnout in 2016 had dropped for the first time in 20 years.
http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/05/12/black-voter-turnout-fell-in-2016-even-as-a-record-nu
mber-of-americans-cast-ballots/
I see many stories of AA women organizing to turnout the AA vote this time. Can they make the difference in states normally not favorable to Democrats?
“Trump’s last-second gambit may well fail”
And that is the position that America is in…..that a blatantly racist `gambit’ may fail. Then again…it may not.
And I would like to add that Mr. Betras in Ohio is a jacka$$. He’s still sticking to whole `economic anxiety’ schtick, while the other side of the spectrum is using racist bull horns to rile up their base. One wonders if Mr. Betras has a position on how violent rhetoric leads to actual…..violence. Silence is approval, Mr. Betras.
.
Citizens United allows Repubs to run a multi-prong attack on Dems: the hydra-like Pluto-PACs run the negative ads about Dems coddling BLM criminals/whiners, while wrecking white working class lives through hated “Political Correctness” about racism (i.e. the “right” to be an asshole). The Repub candidate can then himself happily focus on the “popular” Trumpian issues of Latino ethnic cleansing and ISIS Caravans of Invasion. (This division of labor is quite obviously coordinated, whatever the toothless campaign finance “law” may be.)
One can be sympathetic to Dem fears of ignoring the final Big Lie push by Goebbelsian “conservative” forces. When one of two major parties has descended to nationwide campaigns of Big (and Bigger) Lies and professional-level bad faith, we have learned at peril to ignore them and rely on the wonderful common sense of the failed electorate. Damned if you do respond and damned if you don’t. If Obama Dems in these states eat this shit up, it’s hard to know what to do in the final 5 days, since it was baked into the cake that this cowardly anti-American sewage would be Trumper and his Repubs’ final argument.
I’d not call anyone racist in the final days, but would try to demonstrate that National Trumpalists are seeking to (once again) fool and misdirect you with Goebbelsian Big Lie(s)—this time being the “National Caravan Emergency!” and “Illegal Birthright Citizenship!” But one can’t make every counter-argument, resources are limited. Difficult decisions.
Betras is right.
I have to doubt that Ohio Dems are really trying to make “liberal social issues” the centerpiece of their campaigns. So this guy seems like he’s erecting a straw man.
What’s most likely happening is that dozens of rightwing Pluto-PACs are bombarding the airwaves claiming that Demonic Dems want to force hard-workin’ families to give half their paychecks to Bad Witch Pelosi to finance BLM re-education centers for working class white males, while having to let ISIS Caravan gang members crash in the downstairs bedroom after Demonic Dems confiscate their hand guns and enact their DemOpenBorders(tm) social engineering plan.
“[Dem X] just won’t tell you!”
There are 50 million kangaroos in the world, and around 10 million people live in Ohio. That means if the kangaroos invaded Ohio, each person would have to fight off 5 kangaroos.
I don’t think they could do it.
.
Takes a bit of cunning to defeat even one kangaroo:
I agree with you. Here in Ohio, the message of the Democratic Party is:
If those are “liberal social issues”, then I guess we plead “GUILTY”, as charged.
You live there so you know. I wish it were so here. Here in Illinois the (D) messages are guns and abortion. Funded out of California by California media specialists. Luckily the (R)’s are so inept they are going to lose anyway, except downstate where the incumbent governor is actually campaigning with Trump! In a state Trump lost by 17%
what ads are you seeing, all I see from Underwood & Castens is about healthcare, green energy and jobs
All the republican ads are about the evil Mike Madigan & Nancy Pelosi