In this edition: Scott McClellan has “no business” being WH Press Secretary; WaPo’s CIA secret prisons story; a Fox network evening newscast?; 2005 Election Ad buys; meet Iowa’s most influential political columnist David Yepsen; Bob Woodward sounds like his critics from the Watergate days (full coverage of the Woodward revelation); Online newspaper readership up 11% in Oct.; Is Jon Stewart the next Oprah?; Ken Tomlinson broke federal law; CIA leak investigation update; Anderson Cooper is one of People’s sexist men alive (and so is Patrick Fitzgerald); Dems’ call for universal broadband gets lots of trade industry coverage; MoDo says reporters shouldn’t blindly trust sources;
Thoughts, and Then, the News
The 11/22/05 Nightline will be Ted Koppel’s last. I always felt he was one of the few who was trying to get at the truth. He will be missed. As for another veteran journalist (Bob Woodward), I have some choice words for him.
Now for the news from the past week posted November 21, 2005:
Note: I’m going to put a %%% next to things that are more interesting or go into things more in-depth.
Before you jump on Dems for not fighting the GOP…
Double check to make sure that the media even tried to get the Dem side of the story. The deals made between the GOP and the media, sometimes, means that the Dems don’t get a word in edgewise, even if they hand delivered a statement.
Ted Koppel
- Koppel critiques CNN. If CNN were serious about hard news, the channel wouldn’t bury CNN Presents on Sunday nights.
- Koppel’s Farewell Party recap
- Things you didn’t know about Ted Koppel
The Growing Influence of Mr. Stewart
- Jon Stewart on list of 50 most influential Jewish Americans
- AdAge.com (Sub req.): “Jon Stewart: The Next Oprah? It’s official: Jon Stewart is funny, like in a New Yorker kind of way. His No. 1 best seller, “America, The Book,” nabbed this year’s Thurber Prize for American Humor, awarded [Monday 11/14/05] night at a ceremony at New York’s The Algonquin — where Harpo Marx and Dorothy Parker sat at the Round Table.” Zap2It has its take here.
- Jon Stewart builds an empire on Comedy Central
As fake news anchors go, Jon Stewart has been in a league of his own for years. No one satirizes political bigwigs better than Mr. Stewart and his team of bogus correspondents and commentators on his popular Comedy Central show.
But now Mr. Stewart has moved into even more select company. He’s becoming an opinion shaper–the Oprah of the political world. Publishers vie with each other to get their authors on “The Daily Show with Jon Stewart,” and the satirist is becoming an ever more powerful influence in the media world–particularly with the elusive younger generation.
“He is as important in shaping opinions today as Walter Cronkite was in the ’70s and Huntley and Brinkley were in the ’50s and ’60s.” says Seth Siegel, co-founder of The Beanstalk Group, a branding consulting firm. “There’s no other journalist today, real or fake, who is more significant for people 18 to 25.”
Last year, it seemed, was the year of Jon Stewart, when the former stand-up comic had the No. 1 nonfiction bestseller and his five-year-old program became a breakout hit with its “Indecision 2004” election coverage.
But 2005 has proved to be even better. The Daily Show audience is up 20%, to 1.4 million viewers, according to Nielsen Media Research.
[…]
Mr. Stewart’s influence spread further last month with the debut of “The Colbert Report,” starring former Daily Show regular Stephen Colbert as a faux Fox News personality. The Comedy Central show, produced by Mr. Stewart’s Busboy Productions, has been attracting 1.2 million viewers and has just been renewed.
Mr. Colbert is one of several alumni to use the Daily Show as a springboard. Others include Steve Carell, star of “The 40-Year-Old Virgin,” and Lewis Black, who has become a hot stand-up act and author of Nothing Sacred, a memoir.
The success of the Daily Show has also done wonders for Comedy Central, which is owned by Viacom. Through August, ad revenue for the show, which airs four nights a week and repeats four times the following day, is up 100%, to $41 million, according to TNS Media Intelligence.
“It’s what cable needs more of–original, appointment-viewing programming,” says Andy Donchin, senior vice president of national broadcast at media buying giant Carat USA. “And we like how young his audience is.”
[…]
“The Daily Show is one of the few places on television where you can get six to seven minutes to describe your book to an audience that reads,” says Mr. Cornfield. “And even if it’s someone he was making fun of the previous night, like Zell Miller or Ari Fleischer, Stewart pulls back. That’s another ingredient of his success.”
Mr. Stewart still has room to grow. He and his writers are planning a follow-up to America (The Book), their pseudo-history textbook, which has sold 1.5 million copies, according to Nielsen BookScan, which tracks about 70% of sales.
More spinoffs of the Daily Show could also be on the way. Earlier this year, Comedy Central struck a deal with Mr. Stewart’s production company that gives the channel first-look rights for its television projects. Other networks can pursue anything Comedy Central leaves on the table. The channel has also signed Mr. Stewart to the Daily Show through 2008, which means he gets to anchor another presidential election.
Liberals Get Dissed
NBC Universal President Bob Wright AAR and Ed Schultz are growing, and Olbermann (who plays it straight but probably attracts a more liberal audience) does alright on MSNBC. TDS has a strong following. I don’t think cable news has really given more liberal shows a chance.
Carlson suggested the creation of a cable channel that caters to liberals. But “going after a lefty audience would be futile, Wright said. ‘For some strange, probably genetic, reasons’ — we’re pretty sure that was a joke — ‘they don’t listen to a lot of radio and they don’t watch a lot of television.'”
Scotty Gets Dissed
* Ex-WH correspondent says McClellan has “no business there” LOL.
Reporters: Just Trying To Stay Alive
NBCNews workers wake up to suicide bomb attack in Baghdad.
WaPo’s CIA Secret Prisons Story
WaPo isn’t worried about a fight over the story
f The Washington Post is circling the wagons in preparation for a confidential sourcing fight with federal investigators, it certainly isn’t showing it. Both reporter Dana Priest and Executive Editor Leonard Downie Jr., tell E&P that no plans have been formulated to respond to a possible inquest by either Congress or the Justice Department about a Nov. 2 Priest story on secret overseas prisons.
[…]
Priest’s story, coming on the heels of the Judith Miller subpoena/jailing/resignation mess, drew both criticism and praise for reporting what she described as a “covert prison system” set up by the CIA four years ago. Priest’s use of confidential sources prompted the House Intelligence Committee last week to launch an investigation into who leaked the information, while the CIA asked the Justice Department to review possible sources.
Post media critic Howard Kurtz wrote today, “the controversy could mushroom into another Valerie Plame fracas. If prosecutors get involved, Priest could face the same dilemma that confronted Time’s Matt Cooper and former New York Times reporter Judith Miller: whether to reveal confidential sources under threat of imprisonment.”
There’s a big difference though between Cooper/Miller and Priest. Cooper/Miller were involved (albeit perhaps unwillingly) in the cover up of a leak, whose purpose was to destroy someone politically. Priest sources are whistleblowers. In other words, Priest’s sources are closer to being Mark Felts, and therefore, her wishes to protect her sources are defensible. In addition, Priest notes that her reporting on this story was pretty much done in the same manner as previous stories detailing the doings over previous administrations. Priest has a far better reputation than Miller.
Bob Woodward, Iraq, Judy Miller, Other Media Folk, and Plamegate
- Are there no fact checkers at all of these news organizations? On the Woodward revelation. More here.
- Vicky Toensing attacks Fitzie and Joe Wilson on Situation Room, by ajc888 Why are hacks allowed on those programs?
- Maureen Dowd at U of Texas
After her remarks, Dowd was asked numerous questions about the controversy surrounding Judith Miller, The New York Times reporter who served jail time for refusing to reveal an anonymous source and recently left the newspaper. The New York Times is currently experiencing “Judy fatigue,” she said, adding that Miller may end up with her own Fox talk show.
Her decision to write a column about Miller’s journalistic shortcomings was difficult because she didn’t want to be perceived as having a “WMD cat fight,” she said. “Judy has been a flash point at the Times for two decades now.”
Dowd said for reporters to be responsible, they cannot blindly trust their sources.
“Reporting is not stenography,” Dowd said.
- BushCo so mad at WaPo’s fact-filled article on BushCo pre-war intel claims, that it releases press release in response
- Factchecking WaPo’s stuff on Woodward
- Downie’s chat at WaPo The reviews, and Downie’s assertion that Woodward shouldn’t resign. See also: WaPo ombudsman lets Woodward’s lies stand, and VIDEO: Downie on Kurtz’s Reliable Sources.
- Questions for Bob Woodward
- Woodward claims that he prompted his source to go to Fitzie
- Woodward sounds like his critics from the Watergate days And now we know why. As I said in a post at my blog on this, Watergate hero/Plamegate jackass. Woodward should come clean, now that we know Woodward’s source came forward to tell Fitzie . Does this qualify him for wanker of the year? The Booby Files are a feature at Eschaton, in case you’re one of the few who don’t read it regularly. Also, Steve Clemons takes Woodward to the Woodshed. Kurtz reports on Woodward’s apology to WaPo, which does not undo the damage. Besides, Woodward’s explanations don’t add up, and WaPo readers are pissed. Meanwhile, WaPo editor Len Downie stonewalls, and the blogosphere remembers what Woodward’s fatal flaw is and that he goes through a process of `pre-clearing’ questions to upper-level government officials. E&P has Bernstein’s reaction, while some ask: What kind of reporter publishes a statement in his paper?. Ben Bradlee says that Woodward doesn’t have to disclose everything. Walter Pincus may have been one of the better reporters on Iraq, but why should he honor Woodward’s request to keep him out of Plame reporting? Joe Wilson calls for WaPo to probe Woodward, while WaPo’s internal message board posts get leaked. More Woodward stuff here.
- Dow Jones fights CIA leak probe request
- Miller with Martin Kalb at National Press Club Throrough roundup. %%%
- NY chapter of SPJ `dismayed’ by Miller’s First Amendment award
- Judy Miller gets testy on “On the Media” interview
- Keller suffering from “a serious case of Judy Miller fatigue”, which was partly his own doing.
The Decline of Quality in Public Broadcasting
- Public Broadcasters fight back against CPB, by Eddie Haskell
- NPR’s Morning Edition shills for Bush, by BenGoshi
- Ex-CPB Chair Ken Tomlinson broke federal law %%%
- Ken Tomlinson’s term caused turmoil, and what some want to do to change things.
RWCM Watch
- Article on Kurtz and conflicts of interest. I skimmed through it quickly, but I don’t think that the article mentions Kurtz’s wife (former GOP operative) and the conflicts of interest that might arise from that.
- Armando catches two NYT articles that are just wrong
- MoDo knocks newspaper for lack of female columnists
- Blistering column about Woodward & journalists in the LA Times, by Kitty
- NYT’s public editor on its anonymous sources policy. A decent policy that needs better enforcement. In addition, the NYT can’t grant anonymous source status willy nilly. If something is verifiable with an on the record quote, use that instead.
- NPR presents (only) the wrong side once again, by Spud1
- AP basically says that John Murtha isn’t pro-military anymore. What lousy writing and editorializing.
- ABCNews shows soldier spouting party line, but no mention of all those Democratic veterans challenging GOPers next year.
- Pelosi: O’Reilly Threat “Deadly Serious.”
- ABC’s The Note’s fake nonpartisanship
- Fact-checkers missing: Bridge to Nowhere money is still there
- Conrad Black and three ex-Hollinger International execs are charged in a federal fraud case. Tsk, tsk.
- Journalists in contempt in Wen Ho Lee case Walter Pincus joins the club.
- Brit Hume makes stuff up about Alito
- PTC accounts for 99.9% of FCC complaints in July, by Six Degrees of Aaron
- The shame that Jonah Goldberg brings to the LATimes editorial pages
- LATimes fails to explain why they no longer want to run Scheer’s column Related: LA Times readers are mad that it’s dropping Scheer’s column. BTW, Scheer’s column move to the SF Chronicle.
- FNC’s global warming doc. The first one was accurate, but FNC intends to follow up with other `perspectives.’ (And that would be why I listed it under RWCM watch.)
- DKos credited for forcing Pentagon admission of illegal weapons use in Fallujah, by revolute
- NYT writer Matt Bai is lazy
- Media Matters
Media People
- Ted Koppel in talks to do documentaries for HBO
- Mary Mapes interview on Air America
- CBS Marketwatch’s Friedman on Chris Matthews %%%
- Anderson Cooper named one of People’s 2005 Sexiest Men Alive
- Aaron Brown would take the anchor chair at ABC or CBS, that is if he were asked.
- NYT’s Bumiller talks at CSU HT FishBowlDC.
- Ted Koppel was asked to stay on, but he chose to leave.
- Bob Schieffer extends stay as Evening News anchor
- AUDIO: C&L interviews Katrina vandenHeuvel
- Speaker’s fees
In all the coverage of Washington Post reporter Bob Woodward ‘s surprise participation in the CIA- spy leak case came the revelation that he demands up to $50,000 a speech. That got us wondering what other notables ask. Some answers: ex-Democratic boss Terry McAuliffe, $10,000 to $30,000; political guru Charlie Cook, $5,000 to $10,000; former Sen. Bob Dole, $30,001 to $75,000; talk radio’s Laura Ingraham, $10,001 to $30,000; Newsweek ‘s Michael Isikoff, $5,000 to $20,000; and NBC’s Andrea Mitchell, $20,001 to $30,000.
- FNC anchor Martha MacCallum gets profiled HT TVNewser. I think FNC’s PR people are much better than CNN and MSNBC at getting local news stories and profiles on their anchors, especially the lesser known ones.
- RollCall profiles David Yepsen
Known to political insiders, the Yepsen caucuses are held almost daily in Iowa, as Des Moines Register political columnist David Yepsen expounds on matters ranging from the war in Iraq to mundane questions of public policy, handicapping races and passing judgment on candidates at almost every level along the way. While he’s best known by the national media for his work leading up to the presidential caucuses, Yepsen has no less impact on state, local and Congressional contests.
“He’s clearly the most influential journalist in Iowa politics; all of the players pay attention to what he writes,” said Arthur Sanders, a professor of politics and international relations at Drake University in Des Moines.
[…]
Academics say he is influential, especially with those Iowans who vote in the caucus elections that go far toward determining whom the Leader of the Free World will be. Democrats and Republicans alike claim he is knowledgeable and fair.
[…]
“He’s the pre-eminent voice, the pre-eminent handicapper — a real sage when it comes to Iowa politics and even national politics,” said John Lapp, executive director of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee and former aide to Iowa Gov. Tom Vilsack (D). “I’ve worked with him on the Vilsack re-election, in the governor’s office, and on the [then-Rep. Richard] Gephardt (D) presidential campaign, and spent a lot of time trying to win the David Yepsen caucus. He’s a tough critic, but at the end of the day a fair one who cares about his state.”Yepsen, a self-proclaimed policy wonk, describes himself as a centrist. He supported the war in Iraq and is a proponent for legalizing gay marriage.
[…]
“I know what I say, or don’t say, can have an impact, but you don’t let it go to your head; you take it very seriously. We’re talking about the American presidency here,” Yepsen said in an interview. “If I screw up, the best people in American politics are looking over your shoulder and notice, so you don’t want to screw up.”According to Republican consultant David Roederer, chairman of President Bush’s re-election campaign in Iowa, that doesn’t happen too often. Roederer said he’s had his disagreements with Yepsen, but he calls him objective and a “real student of politics.” If people are talking Iowa politics, they’re probably repeating something they read in a Yepsen column, or mimicking information that was a topic in a piece he wrote.
“I’d say he’s very thorough; he talks to people before he goes out on a limb,” said Roederer, who is based in Des Moines. “The other thing I’ve always appreciated about David is, if you don’t agree with him, he’ll sit down with you and take your thoughts under consideration. He seems to be very receptive when people bring additional information to him.”
News & Notes on Media orgs, Programming, Specials, etc.
- Peter Jennings’ Final Documentary to air Dec. 15
- USAToday opens permanent New Orleans bureau. TV media have already done so.
- USAToday article on the revamped Nightline Will it survive?
- Website to blend journalism with blogs This is Open Source Media, originally known as Pajamas Media. It got Yahoo main site placement when this AP story came across the wire. Related: OSM is Chinese Communist Party mouthpiece.
- Negative reviews for MoDo’s new book
- Anderson Cooper and Brian Williams are among those who suggested names for Time’s Person of the Year
- Can FNC chief work his magic for affiliates? Column looks at a possible network evening newscast for Fox and why Fox affiliates would resist the change. %%%
- Denver station drops O’Reilly because of low ratings He’s replaced by another right-wing talker.
- CNN gets praise for North Korea documentary
- Martha Raddatz becomes ABCNews’ new White House correspondent
- Walter Shapiro to Salon; Andrew Sullivan to Time
- CNBC to air first daily live global business program (4-6am)
- MSNBC cancels Connected Coast to Coast andentertainment shows. Some Rick Kaplan brainchilds go bye bye.
- Anderson Cooper 360 to repeat at 5am
State of the Media, Trends, Research Reports, Innovations
- FEC: Blogs are just as much “press” as everyone else, by Adam B
- A whole bunch of newspaper companies are giving employees the ax these days. AP explains why.
- CNN Pipeline, or an entire channel on your computer.
- link
A GROUP OF POLITICALLY LIBERAL Web logs organized into a mini-network of BlogAds has lost some prominent members Wednesday and Thursday, but advertisers were not affected, said BlogAds founder Henry Copeland. Some of the well-trafficked blogs no longer with the mini-network are Drudge Retort, Raw Story, and Smirking Chimp. Drudge Report author Rogers Cadenhead wrote on his site that the reason he and others were dropped was because their sites appear to be more like online news publications than blogs.
- House Dems call for Universal Broadband It also got ink at Ad Age.com (sub req. only). The link goes to a short blurb, but it does include a quote from Larry Page (Google founder).
- Wolf Blitzer speaks at UPenn Integrity Week
One audience member asked how Blitzer could attest to integrity in media when news coverage is increasingly sensationalized with theme songs and animations.
Blitzer responded that this can make a complicated story easier to digest, but on CNN, “I think we don’t go overboard. … Do you?”
“Yeah, I do,” the questioner replied.
[…]
Blitzer said he was surprised that journalists are no longer viewed as “good guys.” He stressed the need for precise, accurate and fair reporting.
“If we stick to our fundamental, core responsibilities as professional journalists, our image with the American public will improve. That’s what I strive to do,” Blitzer said.
He criticized the political polarization of some coverage and the limited news cycle of tragedies such as last year’s tsunami.
In defense of journalists’ mistakes, he said, “We’re a first draft of history. … As all of you who’ve written papers know, the first draft can be wrong.”
- LATimes columnist looks at the latest trend: in-house blogs %%%
- Rupert Murdoch talks about the influence of FNC
- Liberty Group buying Five CO papers
- PR Week asks: “What is the role and relevance of public broadcasting in the 200-channel universe?” %%%
- 2005 Elections Media: TV, Radio, Print Play Politics as Usual If you want specific stats on individual races, click on the link. An excerpt giving you an overview of ad spending will suffice for most:
Which medium was the 2005 political kingmaker: radio, TV, or print? It was probably a combination of all three media that played key roles in this year’s elections, and reaped record political ad dollars in the process.
[…]
As the Media Monitors study notes, neither party dominated radio ad buys nationally for the November 8th elections. Instead, buys were dominated by winning candidates, whatever their political affiliation.
[…]
Stats from Nielsen Monitor-Plus confirm this picture of a massive upswing in spending on political TV ads in 2005–especially remarkable given that these were “off year” elections. According to Nielsen, from August 1 to October 16th 107,171 political TV ad spots appeared nationwide, with over half–57,682–airing in the 10 biggest markets alone.
Ratings, Circulation, & Ad Revenue Strength
- Geraldo Rivera’s network show off to `modest’ start. Fox plans to take a patient approach.
- Hotline: “For the week of 11/13, NBC’s “Meet the Press” won with a 3.1 rating/9 share and 4.019M viewers. CBS’ “Face the Nation” and ABC’s “This Week” both had a 6 share, but “Face” had a 2.1 rating with 2.808M viewers and “This Week” had a 2.0 with 2.609M viewers. “Fox News Sunday” had a 1.0/3 with 1.272M viewers.”
- Yahoo News to host Gawker Media; it also hosts HuffPo. Web traffic stats in the link.
- Network evening newscast ratings for week of 11/7/05. NBC’s Nightly News wins big.
- Today Show continues to lead in the morning show ratings wars. As for the Weekend morning shows, Weekend Today continues its dominance.
- Online newspaper readership up 11% in Oct.
- Visitors to newspaper sites hit high
For the year’s third quarter, the monthly unique audience averaged over 41.5 million, or 27.7 percent of all Web users. The time Internet users spend on newspaper sites also continues to rise as users’ visits averaged more than 38 minutes during the quarter.
- CNN Pres. Jon Klein talks programming and ratings Well, I, for one, don’t believe that CNN’s improved all that much.
- Anderson Cooper’s ratings in the 25-54 demos are disappointing, and other ratings for Cooper’s new time slot are, too. It’s why Cooper is being called CNN’s New Coke. LOL. Cooper at 10PM is doing worse than when he was on at 7PM.
- Rita Cosby’s Live & Direct does well in the ratings. Tabloid `news’ works for her. Trashy but it gets the ratings.
Media News Monday is a compilation of media news from the past week posted on Monday. Media is an integral part of politics, and I think that it’s important to get to know media and media innovation in order to forecast future ways of campaigning, targeting voters, and disseminating information. If any of you are interested in campaigning, this weekly diary may help you with ideas. It is also important to keep up with right wing corporate media (RWCM) news. If you have any media news to add, please do so. For more RWCM watch & Media News: Penndit’s News, Media News, and RWCM Watch Links. I get the advertising, public relations, targetting voters information, and media research from a variety of sources other than the links above. Cross-posted at Penndit and My Left Wing. For previous editions, search my diaries or Penndit.
If you like this diary and don’t want to miss, consider subscribing. Thanks!